Beyond the Grave: Judgment, Mercy, and the Possibility of Redemption After Death

Introduction: Is Death the End of Our Opportunity to Receive Christ?

One of the most deeply embedded assumptions in Western Christian theology is that death represents the absolute termination of humanity’s opportunity to respond to God. The theological formula is familiar: a person lives, encounters or rejects the revelation of God, dies, and thereafter enters a condition from which no further repentance, reconciliation, or redemption is possible. For many Christians, this understanding is so foundational that questioning it appears tantamount to questioning judgment itself. Yet these are not necessarily the same theological claims. Scripture speaks consistently of divine judgment, human accountability, resurrection, and the ultimate defeat of evil. Whether physical death necessarily constitutes the irreversible boundary of divine mercy is a related but distinct question, and one deserving careful exegetical consideration.

The question becomes particularly interesting when we consider the relationship between the Old and New Testaments, the descent of Christ to the dead, the universality of Christ’s redemptive accomplishment, and the biblical understanding of the final destruction of evil. If the gospel was in some sense proclaimed to those who died before Christ’s incarnation, might that event reveal something about the character of God and the possibilities of redemption beyond earthly life? Conversely, was Christ’s proclamation to the dead a unique event in salvation history, necessitated by the fact that those generations had not yet witnessed the incarnation, crucifixion, and resurrection? Could the event illuminate God’s mercy without establishing a continuing opportunity for repentance after death?

These questions cannot be resolved simply by appealing to what seems emotionally comforting or philosophically reasonable. Nor should they be dismissed because they challenge inherited theological conventions. The responsible task of biblical theology is to distinguish what the text explicitly affirms from what a particular theological tradition has inferred. My own position is one of considerable hope concerning the reach of divine mercy, alongside a firm conviction that judgment is real and that Scripture describes the possibility of ultimate destruction. I find the biblical vision of universal reconciliation compelling, even beautiful, but I have never been able to embrace its inevitability without qualification. I remain persuaded that human resistance to God matters, that the warnings of Jesus must be taken seriously, and that eternal life is a gift received from God rather than an inherent and indestructible possession of every human being. The following study is an attempt to hold these convictions together without claiming greater certainty than Scripture permits.

Death, Judgment, and the Limits of Hebrews 9:27

The passage most frequently invoked to establish the absolute finality of death is Hebrews 9:27, which declares that human beings are appointed to die once and afterward face judgment. The statement is significant, but its literary context deserves attention. Hebrews 9 is not primarily a treatise on the intermediate state, the mechanics of postmortem repentance, or the precise chronology of individual salvation. Rather, the author develops an analogy between the once-for-all character of Christ’s sacrifice and the singularity of human death. As human beings ordinarily die once and then encounter judgment, so Christ was offered once to bear sins and will appear again for the salvation of those awaiting him (Heb 9:27–28). The principal concern is the sufficiency and finality of Christ’s redemptive offering, not an exhaustive description of everything that can or cannot occur after physical death.[1]

This distinction matters. Hebrews 9:27 clearly establishes a movement from earthly mortality toward divine accountability, and nothing in the passage permits us to dismiss judgment as an unnecessary theological category. Nevertheless, the verse does not explicitly address whether the judgment itself might involve a disclosure of truth, an opportunity for response, or a process whose outcome is not identical for every person. It would be equally irresponsible, however, to argue that because Hebrews does not prohibit postmortem repentance, it therefore authorizes it. The silence of a passage does not establish either possibility. Moreover, Hebrews contains substantial warnings against apostasy and the willful rejection of God’s grace (Heb 6:4–8; 10:26–31). Any theology of hope beyond death must be developed alongside these passages, not by ignoring them.

Jesus himself offers some of the strongest language concerning the seriousness of judgment. In the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, a great chasm separates the two figures after death (Luke 16:19–31). The story communicates the gravity of earthly decisions, the reversal of human expectations, and the consequences of ignoring the suffering of others. Its imagery cannot simply be dismissed. At the same time, the parable employs a narrative setting and afterlife imagery familiar within the Jewish world, and its principal ethical concern is the failure to heed Moses and the Prophets. Whether every feature of its depiction should be interpreted as a literal map of the intermediate state remains debatable. The chasm is fixed within the story, but the parable does not expressly construct a complete doctrine of the final resurrection and judgment.[2]

Theologically, we therefore begin with two affirmations rather than a predetermined conclusion. Death is serious, and judgment is certain. Yet the exact relationship between physical death, divine judgment, and the ultimate realization of God’s redemptive purposes remains more complex than the customary appeal to Hebrews 9:27 might suggest.

Sheol and the Ancient Israelite Understanding of Death

A significant difficulty in modern Christian discussions of the afterlife is the tendency to impose later Western categories upon the Hebrew Scriptures. Ancient Israel did not initially possess the same elaborated conceptual distinctions between heaven, hell, purgatory, and the intermediate state that developed in subsequent Christian theology. The Hebrew term Sheol generally described the realm or condition of the dead, a destination associated with mortality, diminished earthly activity, and separation from the ordinary experience of human life. Job speaks of descending to Sheol, the psalmists describe its depths, and Ecclesiastes reflects upon the cessation of earthly labor and knowledge in death (Job 7:9–10; Ps 88:3–12; Eccl 9:10). The imagery has important parallels with ancient Near Eastern conceptions of the underworld, although Israel’s theological understanding was never merely an imitation of its neighbors.[3]

What is especially significant is that Sheol was not originally equivalent to the later Christian conception of a place where the wicked experience endless conscious torture. It was the realm of the dead, and both the righteous and the unrighteous could be described as descending there. Jacob expected to go down to Sheol mourning his son Joseph (Gen 37:35), while the psalmist expressed confidence that God would not abandon him to its power (Ps 16:10; 49:15). The theological hope was not primarily that a disembodied soul would escape the world of matter, but that Israel’s covenant God possessed authority even over the grave.

This conviction became increasingly explicit in the prophetic and later biblical traditions. Isaiah anticipated a day when God would swallow up death forever and wipe away tears from every face (Isa 25:6–9). Daniel envisioned the awakening of those sleeping in the dust, some to everlasting life and others to shame and everlasting contempt (Dan 12:2). The prophet Hosea portrayed death and Sheol as enemies that God could ultimately overcome (Hos 13:14). In Ezekiel 37, the valley of dry bones presented the restoration of Israel through resurrection imagery, declaring that God could open graves and bring his people into renewed life. Although Ezekiel’s immediate concern is Israel’s national restoration rather than an individual account of postmortem salvation, the imagery contributes to the developing biblical conviction that death does not lie beyond the sovereign reach of God.[4]

The important theological observation is that death, within the biblical narrative, is not an independent realm possessing authority equal to God’s. It is an enemy, a consequence of the fallen human condition, and ultimately something destined for defeat. This does not establish that all who die will eventually be saved. It does, however, challenge the assumption that physical death must necessarily represent an absolute limitation upon divine action. Scripture repeatedly portrays God as the one who can reach into the grave, summon the dead, and accomplish purposes beyond the boundaries of earthly existence.

The Descent of Christ: Proclamation to the Dead

Perhaps no New Testament passage raises the question of divine activity beyond death more directly than 1 Peter 3:18–20. Peter describes Christ as having suffered for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, in order to bring humanity to God. He then speaks of Christ being made alive and making proclamation to the spirits in prison who had been disobedient in the days of Noah. The passage is famously difficult, not least because its imagery intersects with Jewish apocalyptic traditions concerning rebellious heavenly beings, imprisonment, judgment, and the supernatural events associated with Genesis 6.

The Greek verb employed in 1 Peter 3:19 is kēryssō, meaning to proclaim or announce. The term does not, by itself, require an evangelistic invitation. It can describe the proclamation of a message, including a declaration of divine victory. Consequently, interpreters have offered several major explanations. Some understand Christ as proclaiming his triumph to rebellious spiritual beings associated with the Watchers tradition in 1 Enoch. Others understand the imprisoned spirits as deceased human beings from Noah’s generation who encountered Christ’s proclamation following his death. Still others interpret the passage as Christ preaching through Noah to people who were alive in Noah’s day but are now imprisoned. Each interpretation attempts to account for the grammar, historical setting, and wider theological context of the epistle.[5]

The connection to 1 Enoch should not be minimized. Jewish apocalyptic literature describes rebellious heavenly beings confined while awaiting judgment, and 1 Peter’s language would have been meaningful in a world familiar with such traditions. Nevertheless, the interpretation involving deceased human beings also has substantial historical precedent within Christian theology. On that reading, the significance of the passage is extraordinary: Christ’s redemptive victory was proclaimed even within the realm of the dead, including those associated with one of the most devastating judgments of the Hebrew Bible. The generation of Noah, traditionally presented as an example of profound human corruption, had not escaped the reach of Christ’s proclamation merely because its earthly existence had ended.

Yet this interpretation still leaves important questions unanswered. Peter does not explicitly state that the proclamation resulted in repentance, nor does he explain whether the event represents a singular accomplishment of the crucified and risen Christ or a continuing pattern of divine evangelization. The text establishes an important theological possibility under one legitimate interpretation, but it cannot independently sustain a universal doctrine of postmortem conversion.

The following chapter introduces an additional and potentially more direct consideration. First Peter 4:6 declares that the gospel was preached even to the dead, with the purpose that, although judged according to human existence in the flesh, they might live according to God in the spirit. Unlike 3:19, where Peter uses the more general language of proclamation, 4:6 employs euangelizō, the verb associated with announcing good news. This lexical difference is significant. Nevertheless, the timing of the preaching remains disputed. Some scholars conclude that the recipients heard the gospel during their earthly lives and subsequently died, while others understand the announcement as reaching people already deceased. The latter interpretation can be defended grammatically and contextually, particularly when 4:6 is read in connection with the preceding discussion of Christ’s proclamation to imprisoned spirits.[6]

If the latter interpretation is correct, Peter offers a remarkable picture of the gospel’s reach. The deceased are not described merely as hearing an announcement of condemnation; the stated purpose of the preaching is that they might live according to God. This is arguably the strongest textual basis for entertaining the possibility of redemptive activity beyond physical death. Nevertheless, the conditional language of academic interpretation remains necessary. We cannot turn a contested passage into an uncontested doctrine simply because its theological implications are attractive.

The Harrowing of Hades and the Witness of the Early Church

The belief that Christ descended into the realm of the dead was not a marginal speculation confined to a few unusual early Christian thinkers. It became a recognizable element of Christian confession, famously expressed in the Apostles’ Creed through the declaration that Christ descended to the dead. Within Eastern Christian iconography, the resurrection is frequently depicted through the image of Christ breaking the gates of Hades and raising Adam and Eve from their graves. This theological symbolism reflects something profoundly important within the early Christian understanding of salvation: the resurrection was not simply the resuscitation of Jesus’ physical body, but the beginning of God’s conquest of death itself.

The theological implications of this descent, however, were understood differently across early Christian traditions. Some interpreted the event principally as the liberation of the righteous who had awaited the Messiah. Others entertained a broader understanding in which the proclamation of Christ might result in repentance and salvation among those who had died without possessing the fullness of Christian revelation. The descent was widely confessed, but the assertion that all deceased persons received a subsequent opportunity for salvation was not universally accepted.

Clement of Alexandria provides one of the clearest early expressions of the more expansive understanding. Writing near the end of the second century and beginning of the third, Clement argued that Christ proclaimed the gospel in Hades and that those who had died without the fullness of revelation could respond to the truth when it was disclosed to them. In the sixth book of his Stromata, Clement considered the possibility that both Jews and Gentiles encountered the salvific proclamation after death. He reasoned that divine justice required careful consideration of what individuals had actually known, and that the proclamation of Christ might reach those whose earthly circumstances had not permitted them to encounter him.

Clement’s argument is especially significant because he did not merely imagine Christ announcing a completed victory to an audience incapable of responding. He explicitly contemplated repentance and faith among the deceased, identifying divine judgment with God’s restorative purposes rather than assuming that death necessarily terminated the possibility of transformation.[7] New Advent+1

We should not confuse Clement’s perspective with a unanimous teaching of the early church. The subsequent development of Christian theology included substantial disagreement concerning postmortem repentance, the permanence of judgment, and the ultimate restoration of creation. Later Catholic theology, for example, would explicitly distinguish Christ’s liberation of the righteous dead from the deliverance of those already finally condemned. The historical evidence demonstrates that these questions were genuinely discussed, not that one interpretation enjoyed universal agreement throughout antiquity. Vatican+1

Nevertheless, Clement provides a significant witness to an ancient Christian conviction that deserves renewed consideration: the work of Christ was understood to extend beyond the chronological boundaries of his earthly ministry, and at least some early Christian theologians believed that the redemptive proclamation could encounter human beings after physical death.

Was Christ’s Proclamation a Unique Event in Salvation History?

Here we encounter what may be the most important qualification in the entire discussion. Even if 1 Peter describes the gospel being proclaimed to human beings who had already died, does that necessarily establish that those who die after the resurrection will receive the same opportunity? I do not believe that conclusion can be drawn with certainty. In fact, there are substantial biblical and redemptive-historical reasons to distinguish the generations who lived before Christ from those who live in the age inaugurated by his incarnation, crucifixion, and resurrection.

The people of the Hebrew Scriptures lived within a covenantal world that anticipated the Messiah but did not yet possess the historical revelation of Jesus of Nazareth. Abraham believed God’s promises without having witnessed the cross. Moses encountered the covenant God of Israel without knowing the full dimensions of the incarnation. Countless individuals throughout the ancient world lived and died without meaningful access to Israel’s Scriptures, the prophetic hope, or the historical knowledge of the Messiah. Hebrews 11 celebrates the faithfulness of many who lived before the fulfillment of these promises, concluding that their perfection remained bound to the larger purposes God would accomplish through Christ (Heb 11:39–40).

Paul develops a related perspective in Romans 3:25–26, describing God’s former forbearance toward sins committed beforehand and the demonstration of divine righteousness through Christ. Romans 5:12–21 presents Adam and Christ as representative figures whose actions carry consequences extending across human history. These passages establish that the accomplishment of Christ has redemptive significance for people who lived before the crucifixion. They do not, however, specify that every individual who lived before Christ was personally evangelized after death.

If Christ’s proclamation in Hades involved an opportunity for the deceased to respond, it may therefore have represented a unique moment of redemptive disclosure within salvation history. Those who lived before the incarnation had not encountered the Messiah in the same manner as those living after his resurrection. Christ’s descent could be understood as the announcement of the fulfillment toward which the earlier covenantal story had been moving. In this sense, the event would reveal the extraordinary breadth of God’s mercy without establishing that a corresponding proclamation necessarily follows every human death.

This is where biblical typology requires considerable restraint. The Old Testament frequently anticipates realities fulfilled in Christ, but not every event associated with the earlier covenant establishes an identical pattern for the future. The exodus anticipates redemption, yet the Christian life does not require a second crossing of the Red Sea. The sacrificial system foreshadows Christ’s offering, yet that offering is not repeated. Similarly, even if the proclamation to the pre-Christian dead occurred as a historical event, we cannot assume that its redemptive circumstances are reproduced indefinitely.

The alternative, however, also deserves attention. If the descent reveals something about God’s character rather than merely addressing a temporary historical problem, perhaps its significance extends beyond the particular generations involved. God does not become more merciful after the incarnation, nor was the divine desire to redeem humanity invented at Calvary. The cross reveals the character of the God who has always been merciful. The descent could therefore represent not merely an exception but a disclosure of the depth of divine initiative.

Both possibilities deserve consideration. We may reasonably entertain the hope that those who die without reconciliation will encounter some further opportunity to respond to Christ, but we cannot promise that such an opportunity awaits them. Nor should the distinction between the pre-Christian and post-Christian eras become overly simplistic, since billions of people living after the resurrection have not encountered a clear, faithful, or meaningful presentation of the gospel. God’s perfect judgment must account for realities that our theological systems often flatten.

The conclusion, for now, is one of informed uncertainty. Christ’s redemptive work transcends the chronological boundaries of the cross, but Scripture does not disclose with sufficient clarity whether every person who dies afterward receives a subsequent opportunity for repentance.

Divine Judgment, the Violence of the Old Testament, and the Possibility of Mercy Beyond Death

One of the more challenging implications of this discussion concerns the character of God in the violent narratives of the Hebrew Scriptures. The destruction associated with the flood, the judgment upon Sodom and Gomorrah, and the conquest traditions concerning the Canaanites have generated substantial theological debate. At the center of the discussion is a question of divine character: how do we reconcile the God revealed in Jesus Christ, who teaches love of enemies and models self-giving mercy, with biblical narratives in which divine judgment results in the destruction of entire populations?

The problem becomes particularly acute when considering those who apparently had little opportunity to understand the covenantal revelation of Israel. The conquest narratives include commands expressed through the language of ḥerem, a Hebrew term associated with placing something under a ban or devoting it to destruction. Within the ancient Near Eastern world, such language also appears in military and royal traditions that employ comprehensive descriptions of victory. Scholars continue to debate the degree to which these accounts reflect literal total destruction, conventional military rhetoric, theological interpretation of historical events, or some combination of these elements. Whatever interpretive approach one adopts, the moral questions raised by the texts should not be minimized.[8]

The possibility of divine mercy beyond physical death introduces a significant, although not conclusive, consideration. If earthly death is not necessarily the termination of an individual’s existence before God, then the death of a human being within a narrative of temporal judgment need not automatically mean that the individual has also been condemned to everlasting exclusion from God’s redemptive purposes. Physical destruction and final eschatological condemnation would remain distinct realities.

Consider the generation of Noah. Genesis presents the flood as an extraordinary judgment upon human wickedness, yet 1 Peter may describe Christ proclaiming his victory or even the gospel to those associated with that very generation. If the proclamation involved a genuine opportunity for repentance, then those who suffered a devastating earthly judgment were not necessarily beyond the reach of divine mercy. Their earthly lives ended, but God’s redemptive engagement with them may not have ended.

The theological implications are substantial. A person could experience the consequences of judgment within history without those consequences necessarily constituting the final word concerning that person’s ultimate destiny. The God who judges wickedness could remain the God who desires repentance and restoration. In this framework, judgment and mercy would not be mutually exclusive; judgment might expose the destructive consequences of evil while divine mercy continued to seek reconciliation.

There is, however, an essential ethical qualification. The possibility of redemption after death does not morally justify the killing of innocent people, nor does it resolve every difficulty associated with attributing violent destruction to God. We must never suggest that genocide becomes good simply because those who are killed might subsequently encounter Christ. Such reasoning would ignore the intrinsic value of earthly human life, the suffering of victims, and the moral seriousness of violence. Nor can we confidently claim that God terminated particular lives mercifully for the purpose of offering those individuals a better opportunity after death. Scripture does not tell us that.

What the possibility does accomplish is to challenge the assumption that the fate of those who suffered earthly judgment can be determined solely by the circumstances of their deaths. The final destiny of human beings belongs to the righteous Judge, whose justice and mercy exceed the limits of our historical knowledge. Abraham’s question in Genesis 18:25 remains central: shall not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?

This perspective also reminds us that death may look very different from the vantage point of eternity. Human beings rightly regard death as a profound enemy because it brings suffering, separation, and the interruption of embodied life. Scripture does not trivialize these realities; Jesus himself wept at the tomb of Lazarus. Yet from the perspective of the resurrection, physical death does not possess final sovereignty. God’s purposes for creation are not exhausted by the brief duration of earthly life. The resurrection of Jesus fundamentally reorients our understanding of what death can and cannot accomplish.

The Biblical Case for Universal Reconciliation

It is at this point that the discussion naturally intersects with the theological position generally described as universal reconciliation, sometimes called Christian universalism or apokatastasis, a Greek term associated with restoration. The position should be distinguished from religious pluralism or the suggestion that Christ is unnecessary for salvation. Classical Christian universal reconciliation maintains that salvation is accomplished through Jesus Christ and that, ultimately, the reconciling work of God will reach every human being. Some historical expressions extend this hope even further to include all rational creatures, although that claim raises additional exegetical difficulties.

The biblical case is not without substantial theological force. Several New Testament passages use remarkably comprehensive language when describing the scope and intended accomplishment of Christ’s redemptive work.

Romans 5:18–19 is among the most significant. Paul compares the universal consequences of Adam’s transgression with the justifying work of Christ, speaking of one act of righteousness leading to justification and life for all people. The parallel between Adam and Christ creates an important theological question: if Adam’s action truly affected all humanity, should the universal language associated with Christ’s righteousness be interpreted with comparable breadth? Advocates of universal reconciliation argue that Paul’s comparison becomes especially powerful when the restorative work of Christ is understood as ultimately overcoming the consequences of Adam’s sin. Others interpret the second universal expression in relation to those united to Christ through faith. The question concerns not whether Christ’s work is sufficient for all, but whether Paul intends to affirm that its saving benefits will eventually be received by all.[9]

First Corinthians 15:22–28 develops the comparison further. Paul declares that as all die in Adam, so all will be made alive in Christ. He then describes the destruction of every hostile rule, authority, and power, identifying death as the final enemy. The passage reaches its climax when the Son subjects all things to the Father so that God may be all in all. The universalist interpretation sees this as the culmination of the reconciliation of creation, when every opposition to God’s reign has finally been overcome. A conditionalist reading can affirm the universal defeat of death and evil without necessarily concluding that every individual will be redeemed; the enemies of God may be abolished rather than transformed. Nevertheless, Paul’s language of cosmic restoration remains one of the strongest reasons to take the hope of universal reconciliation seriously.

Colossians 1:19–20 offers another remarkable statement, declaring that God was pleased to reconcile all things to himself through Christ, making peace through the blood of his cross, whether things on earth or things in heaven. The expression ta panta, meaning all things, appears within a hymn emphasizing Christ’s cosmic supremacy as both creator and reconciler. Because the scope of creation in Colossians 1:16 includes visible and invisible realities, the subsequent language of reconciliation naturally raises the question of whether the entirety of creation will eventually participate in restored harmony with God. The text does not specify the individual experience of every creature, and interpreters distinguish between reconciliation as willing restoration and reconciliation as the pacification of opposition. Yet the comprehensiveness of Paul’s language cannot be reduced without exegetical argument.

Philippians 2:9–11 similarly envisions every knee bowing and every tongue confessing that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father. Drawing upon Isaiah 45:22–23, Paul presents a universal acknowledgment of Christ’s lordship. One may understand this as the joyful confession of a reconciled creation or as the ultimate submission of defeated enemies. The language itself does not settle the question. Nevertheless, the fact that every creature ultimately acknowledges the lordship of Jesus remains a significant feature of Paul’s eschatological vision.

Additional passages contribute to this theological pattern. First Timothy 2:4 describes God’s desire that all people be saved and come to a knowledge of the truth. First Timothy 4:10 describes God as the Savior of all people, especially those who believe, although the meaning of this distinction remains debated. Titus 2:11 speaks of God’s grace appearing with salvation for all people. John 12:32 records Jesus declaring that, when lifted up, he will draw all people to himself. Second Peter 3:9 describes God’s patience and unwillingness that any should perish, while Ezekiel 18:23 and 33:11 emphasize that God takes no pleasure in the death of the wicked but desires their repentance and life.[10]

Taken together, these texts establish that the universalist hope is not simply an emotional reaction against the doctrine of hell. It arises from substantial biblical themes concerning the universal scope of Christ’s victory, God’s salvific desire, and the final restoration of creation. The interpretive question is whether these passages describe the extent of God’s redemptive invitation and accomplishment or guarantee the eventual salvation of every human being.

I find this vision profoundly attractive. Indeed, I believe Christians should desire that every human being eventually be reconciled to God, just as Scripture portrays God as desiring repentance rather than destruction. Yet a theological desire, even one rooted in God’s revealed character, is not necessarily identical to a revealed certainty concerning every person’s ultimate response.

The universal language must be read alongside the equally substantial biblical testimony concerning judgment, exclusion, destruction, and the possibility of persistent resistance. The task is not to choose whichever collection of verses best supports a preferred conclusion, but to develop an account capable of taking both sets of texts seriously.

Mark 3 and the Possibility of Irreversible Resistance to God

One of the principal reasons I remain hesitant to affirm universal reconciliation as a certainty is the warning of Jesus concerning blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. In Mark 3:28–30, Jesus announces the extraordinary breadth of divine forgiveness, declaring that human sins and blasphemies may be forgiven, before identifying an exception involving blasphemy against the Holy Spirit. Mark explains the immediate context: certain religious authorities had attributed Jesus’ liberating work to an unclean spirit, identifying the activity of God’s Spirit with the activity of demonic power.

The historical setting is essential. Jesus was not addressing someone who had experienced a moment of intellectual uncertainty, theological confusion, or emotional anger toward God. He was confronting religious authorities who encountered the liberating activity of the kingdom and characterized it as evil. Their accusation was not simply that Jesus was mistaken. They interpreted the very activity of the Holy Spirit as the work of Satan, demonstrating a profound inversion of moral and spiritual discernment.

The Greek text of Mark 3:29 is particularly forceful. Jesus declares that the one who blasphemes against the Holy Spirit does not have forgiveness eis ton aiōna and is guilty of an aiōniou hamartēmatos, commonly rendered an eternal sin. Matthew’s parallel strengthens the seriousness of the warning by saying that such blasphemy will not be forgiven either in the present age or in the age to come (Matt 12:31–32). Whatever interpretive difficulties surround the precise meaning of aiōnios, the language should not be casually diminished into a temporary disciplinary warning.[11] TIPs+1

A compelling theological explanation is that blasphemy against the Holy Spirit describes a condition of radical resistance to the very agency through which repentance and reconciliation become possible. If the Spirit reveals the truth of Christ, convicts the world concerning sin, and draws humanity toward reconciliation, then the deliberate identification of that work as evil represents a refusal of the very means by which forgiveness is received. In this sense, the problem is not a deficiency in God’s willingness to forgive but the persistent rejection of forgiveness itself.

Nevertheless, we must be careful not to replace Jesus’ actual warning with an interpretation that makes it less demanding. Mark does not explicitly say that the sin becomes forgivable when the individual changes his mind. The text presents a grave and enduring exclusion from forgiveness. Describing the sin as a settled condition of resistance may help explain the spiritual dynamics involved, but it does not erase the strength of Jesus’ words. Nor does Mark explicitly establish whether a person who has entered such resistance could eventually be transformed through an extraordinary disclosure of divine truth.

The implications for our present discussion are significant. If human beings are capable of decisively resisting the Holy Spirit, universal reconciliation cannot simply be assumed on the grounds that God desires everyone to be saved. Divine love is not necessarily identical to coercive salvation. Although God’s grace is capable of extraordinary transformation, the biblical warnings concerning human resistance remain meaningful.

Could such resistance continue beyond physical death? Scripture does not provide a detailed psychological account of human freedom in the intermediate state. Yet if a person’s fundamental orientation toward God persists beyond death, it is conceivable that someone could continue resisting reconciliation even in the presence of a fuller revelation of divine reality. In such a scenario, the possibility of repentance after death would not guarantee that every person ultimately repents.

The difference is important. An opportunity for salvation is not the same as the inevitability of salvation. It is possible to hope that divine mercy extends beyond the grave while acknowledging that some may finally and tragically refuse the life God offers. This remains a theological inference rather than an explicit biblical description of postmortem decision-making, but it provides one possible way of holding together the universal scope of God’s salvific desire and the seriousness of Jesus’ warning.

The Lake of Fire and the Question of Conditional Immortality

If universal reconciliation is not inevitable, we must consider the destiny of those who ultimately reject reconciliation. Christian theology has historically developed three broad approaches to this question: eternal conscious torment, universal reconciliation, and conditional immortality, often associated with annihilationism. These positions are not identical, and none should be represented without reference to the biblical texts that give rise to it.

In This Is the Way, I have previously argued that conditional immortality offers a particularly compelling account of the biblical relationship between sin, death, and final judgment. The central claim is that immortality is not an inherent possession of humanity but a gift grounded in the life of God. First Timothy 6:16 describes God as the one who alone possesses immortality, while Romans 6:23 contrasts the wages of sin, which is death, with the gift of eternal life through Jesus Christ. Jesus likewise speaks of destruction in Gehenna (Matt 10:28) and contrasts perishing with receiving eternal life (John 3:16). Taken together, these passages support the argument that the ultimate consequence of rejecting God is the loss of life itself, rather than the perpetual preservation of human consciousness for the purpose of suffering.[12]

The biblical narrative begins with humanity’s exclusion from the tree of life and concludes with the restoration of access to that tree in the renewed creation (Gen 3:22–24; Rev 22:1–5). This literary movement is theologically significant. Eternal life is consistently associated with participation in God’s life, not simply with the endless continuation of conscious existence. Conditionalism therefore argues that those who remain alienated from the source of life ultimately perish.

The book of Revelation introduces this question through the imagery of the lake of fire. Revelation 20:11–15 describes the final judgment before the great white throne, the opening of the books, and the judgment of the dead according to their deeds. Death and Hades are then thrown into the lake of fire, which John explicitly identifies as the second death. Revelation 21:8 applies the same designation to the destiny of those who remain aligned with evil. The language is striking because the lake of fire is not merely associated with punishment; it is specifically identified with death.

The conditionalist interpretation understands this second death as the ultimate destruction of those who reject God’s life. It is not an opportunity for rehabilitation, nor is it a temporary inconvenience followed by eventual restoration. It is final judgment, the irreversible loss of existence. Within this framework, the consequence is everlasting precisely because the destruction is not reversed. It is eternal punishment in its result rather than necessarily an eternal process of conscious suffering.

Yet Revelation also contains one of the strongest challenges to conditionalism. Revelation 20:10 describes the devil, the beast, and the false prophet as being tormented day and night forever and ever. The language is explicit and cannot responsibly be ignored. Conditionalist interpreters frequently argue that Revelation’s apocalyptic imagery communicates the irreversible defeat of evil powers, and that the beast and false prophet are symbolic figures whose destruction need not establish the endless conscious existence of every condemned human being. This reading deserves consideration, but the language of torment remains a serious interpretive difficulty. Likewise, Matthew 25:46 places eternal punishment and eternal life in direct parallel, a construction that understandably carries considerable weight for advocates of eternal conscious punishment.

The discussion also requires lexical precision. The Greek adjective aiōnios is associated with aiōn, meaning an age, and may communicate realities belonging to the age to come. Nevertheless, it would be mistaken to assert that aiōnios cannot communicate endless duration. Its meaning depends upon context, and the New Testament regularly employs the term for realities understood to be everlasting. Similarly, the Hebrew ʿolam can express an extended, indefinite, or perpetual duration, depending upon its usage. Neither term can be reduced to a single simplistic English equivalent.

Jude 7 provides an instructive example by describing Sodom and Gomorrah as undergoing the punishment of eternal fire. The ancient cities are not presently undergoing an observable process of combustion, and conditionalists therefore argue that the fire’s enduring character concerns the finality of its judgment rather than the endless continuation of flames. Others understand Jude’s description as pointing beyond the historical destruction of the cities toward an eschatological reality. The example demonstrates why duration, consequence, and apocalyptic symbolism must be considered together rather than determined by lexical definition alone.

My own reading continues to favor conditional immortality. I believe the biblical contrast between life and death, immortality and destruction, offers a more coherent account of final judgment than the proposition that God perpetually sustains the conscious existence of the wicked in order that they might suffer without end. Yet I recognize that the traditional position is grounded in serious exegetical arguments, particularly Matthew 25:46 and Revelation 20:10. The disagreement should be approached with theological humility rather than the assumption that those who read these passages differently are indifferent to Scripture.

A Possible Synthesis: Universal Hope, Genuine Judgment, and Final Death

The various strands of biblical evidence invite us to consider a theological synthesis that preserves the breadth of divine mercy without dissolving the reality of judgment. Such a synthesis begins with the conviction that God genuinely desires the salvation of humanity and that Christ’s redemptive accomplishment is sufficient for the reconciliation of all creation. It further acknowledges the possibility that Christ’s proclamation to the dead may reveal a divine willingness to engage human beings beyond physical death, particularly those who lived before the incarnation or without meaningful access to the gospel.

Nevertheless, this possibility must remain an open theological question. If Christ’s descent was a unique event in redemptive history, the biblical evidence does not establish that individuals who die after the resurrection will receive a comparable opportunity. If the descent reveals a continuing dimension of divine mercy, its implications may be considerably broader. Scripture does not resolve the distinction with sufficient clarity for either conclusion to become dogmatic.

At the same time, divine judgment remains a necessary component of biblical eschatology. The ultimate restoration of creation involves the defeat of evil, not merely its indefinite accommodation. The New Testament speaks of resurrection to life and judgment, of the exclusion of evil from the renewed creation, and of the final destruction of death itself. A doctrine of salvation that cannot account for these realities has not adequately engaged the biblical witness.

This is where conditional immortality offers what I consider a compelling theological possibility. God may extend mercy far beyond what we presently understand, yet those who finally and persistently refuse reconciliation may experience the second death. Within this framework, the lake of fire represents not an eternal chamber of torment but the final removal of evil and those who remain irrevocably committed to it. We may hope that few, or perhaps even none, ultimately make such a refusal, but we are not authorized to declare that outcome inevitable.

Importantly, this synthesis should not be mistaken for a fully established doctrine. It combines several biblical themes with a number of interpretive judgments about which thoughtful Christians disagree. The possibility of postmortem repentance is contested; the interpretation of Mark 3 as persistent resistance involves theological inference; and the conditionalist reading of the lake of fire remains disputed. The strength of the proposal is not that it eliminates every difficulty, but that it takes seriously the breadth of God’s mercy, the reality of human resistance, and the scriptural relationship between sin and death.

It also preserves an important distinction between hope and presumption. Christian hope trusts the goodness, wisdom, and redemptive purpose of God. Presumption claims knowledge of an outcome that God has not clearly revealed. I find ample biblical grounds for hoping that the mercy of Christ reaches farther than our theological boundaries sometimes permit. I do not find sufficient grounds for confidently announcing that every human being will ultimately be reconciled.

Similarly, I find it difficult to affirm that death necessarily terminates every conceivable opportunity for repentance, but I cannot promise someone that a subsequent opportunity will occur. We must allow the biblical tensions to remain tensions where Scripture itself does not provide their resolution.

Conclusion: The God Who Meets Us Beyond Our Understanding

Perhaps the most important lesson emerging from this discussion is that we should be exceedingly careful about constructing limitations upon the mercy of God that Scripture itself does not clearly establish. We know that God judges. We know that evil will not endure forever within his restored creation. We know that salvation comes through Jesus Christ and that the resurrection announces the defeat of death. What we do not know with certainty is precisely how the mercy and judgment of God will intersect with every human life, particularly those who never encountered the fullness of the gospel during their earthly existence.

I find considerable comfort in the thought that the God revealed in Jesus is more merciful than our theological systems sometimes allow us to imagine. The same Christ who welcomed sinners, restored the broken, forgave his enemies, and entered the realm of death is the Christ who will ultimately judge creation. We should not imagine that divine judgment somehow requires God to abandon the character revealed at Calvary. The Judge is the crucified and risen Messiah, and whatever judgment ultimately means for humanity, it will be administered by the one who loved the world enough to give himself for it.

This does not diminish the urgency of discipleship today. If anything, it deepens it. The gospel is not merely an escape from a future punishment, nor should Christian evangelism depend upon frightening people into a hurried profession of belief. Jesus invites us into the life of the kingdom now: a life of reconciliation, covenant faithfulness, sacrificial love, and participation in the restoration of creation. We follow Christ because his way is life itself, not simply because we fear what might happen if we refuse him.

And perhaps this discussion should also change how we view those who have died. We need not claim certainty about their eternal condition, nor must we pretend to possess knowledge of conversations between God and the human soul that Scripture has not disclosed. We entrust them to the same God whose mercy is revealed in Christ, whose justice is perfect, and whose wisdom extends beyond the boundaries of our understanding. Christian hope does not require us to know everything about the afterlife. It requires us to know something about the character of the one who holds eternity.

We should be careful not to close doors that Scripture has left open, but equally careful not to promise doors that Scripture has not clearly revealed.

Our calling is not to determine the limits of God’s mercy. Our calling is to embody that mercy faithfully while we have breath.

And if the resurrection teaches us anything, it is that death does not get the final word.

Jesus does.

Notes

Biblical references are discussed in their literary and historical contexts. Secondary sources include scholarly commentaries, early Christian primary texts, and representative works addressing judgment and the intermediate state.

1. Harold W. Attridge, The Epistle to the Hebrews, Hermeneia (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1989), commentary on Hebrews 9:23–28; Craig R. Koester, Hebrews: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Yale Bible 36 (New York: Doubleday, 2001), commentary on Hebrews 9. Both situate the analogy of death and judgment within Hebrews’ argument for Christ’s once-for-all offering.

2. Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke, New International Commentary on the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997), commentary on Luke 16:19–31; François Bovon, Luke 2: A Commentary on the Gospel of Luke 9:51–19:27, Hermeneia (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2013), commentary on Luke 16.

3. Philip S. Johnston, Shades of Sheol: Death and Afterlife in the Old Testament (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2002); John H. Walton, Ancient Near Eastern Thought and the Old Testament, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2018). See also Job 7:9–10; Psalms 16:10; 49:15; 88:3–12; and Ecclesiastes 9:10.

4. Jon D. Levenson, Resurrection and the Restoration of Israel: The Ultimate Victory of the God of Life (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2006). Levenson’s study is particularly helpful in tracing resurrection hope through Israel’s covenantal theology and traditions of restoration.

5. Karen H. Jobes, 1 Peter, Baker Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2005), commentary on 3:18–22; J. Ramsey Michaels, 1 Peter, Word Biblical Commentary 49 (Waco, TX: Word Books, 1988), commentary on 3:19–20. See also 1 Enoch 6–16 and the Watchers tradition underlying major interpretations of the imprisoned spirits. BECNT)

6. Jobes, 1 Peter, commentary on 4:6; E. G. Selwyn, The First Epistle of St. Peter (London: Macmillan, 1946), commentary on 4:6; A. F. Kirkpatrick, ed., The Cambridge Greek Testament for Schools and Colleges, commentary on 1 Peter 4:6. The Cambridge tradition favors the reading that the gospel reached those already dead, while Jobes presents substantial reasons for distinguishing 4:6 from 3:19 and interpreting its recipients as believers who had subsequently died. Cambridge Greek Testament Commentary+1

7. Clement of Alexandria, Stromata 6.6, especially the discussion of the gospel’s proclamation to Jews and Gentiles in Hades and the possibility of repentance after death. See also Jeffrey A. Trumbower, Rescue for the Dead: The Posthumous Salvation of Non-Christians in Early Christianity (New York: Oxford University Press, 2001). The distinction between Clement’s position and later doctrinal restrictions is important; see Catechism of the Catholic Church, §§632–635. New Advent+2

8. Susan Niditch, War in the Hebrew Bible: A Study in the Ethics of Violence (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993); K. Lawson Younger Jr., Ancient Conquest Accounts: A Study in Ancient Near Eastern and Biblical History Writing, Journal for the Study of the Old Testament Supplement Series 98 (Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1990). These works provide important historical and literary perspectives on conquest rhetoric and violence in the Hebrew Bible.

9. Thomas Talbott, The Inescapable Love of God, 2nd ed. (Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2014); Ilaria L. E. Ramelli, The Christian Doctrine of Apokatastasis: A Critical Assessment from the New Testament to Eriugena (Leiden: Brill, 2013). Both develop arguments for universal reconciliation, although their exegetical and historical conclusions remain contested.

10. Representative passages include Romans 5:18–19; 11:32; 1 Corinthians 15:22–28; 2 Corinthians 5:19; Ephesians 1:9–10; Philippians 2:9–11; Colossians 1:19–20; 1 Timothy 2:3–6; 4:10; Titus 2:11; John 12:32; and 2 Peter 3:9. These passages differ in literary genre, intended audience, and the precise sense in which universal language is employed, and should not be treated as interchangeable prooftexts.

11. Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Yale Bible 27 (New York: Doubleday, 2000), commentary on Mark 3:20–30; R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark, New International Greek Testament Commentary (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002), commentary on Mark 3:28–30. For the Greek construction and its relationship to Matthew 12:32, see the United Bible Societies’ translation commentary on Mark 3:29–30. TIPs+1

12. Edward William Fudge, The Fire That Consumes: A Biblical and Historical Study of the Doctrine of Final Punishment, 3rd ed. (Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2011); Preston Sprinkle, ed., Four Views on Hell, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2016); Will Ryan, This Is the Way: Covenant Discipleship, part 2, chap. 11, “The Three Classic Views of Hell.” See especially the discussion of conditional immortality, universal reconciliation, and eternal conscious torment.

This Is the Way to Covenant Discipleship Chapter 10

Editorial note: In the available Part 2 manuscript of This Is the Way, the discussion of the three views of hell appears in chapter 11 rather than chapter 10. The article draws upon that section, particularly its distinction between hopeful universal reconciliation and conditional immortality.

Comments Off on Beyond the Grave: Judgment, Mercy, and the Possibility of Redemption After Death Posted in ADVENTURE

What Will Heaven Actually Be Like?

Paradise, the Intermediate State, and the Restoration of Heaven and Earth

The Christian understanding of heaven has been shaped as much by centuries of religious imagination as by the biblical text itself. Images of departed believers entering an ethereal world, inhabiting celestial mansions, or spending eternity in an exclusively spiritual existence have become so familiar that they are rarely questioned. Yet when the biblical narrative is examined within its ancient Near Eastern setting, its Second Temple Jewish development, and the eschatological expectations of the earliest followers of Jesus, a considerably different picture begins to emerge. The biblical hope is not ultimately the abandonment of the earth for heaven, but the restoration of creation and the complete reconciliation of heaven and earth under the reign of God. This raises several important questions. What happens to believers immediately following death? Is that experience the same as the final resurrection? Will we recognize one another? Will our memories, personalities, relationships, and creative capacities continue? And perhaps most importantly, what does Scripture actually reveal about the eternal future of humanity?

N. T. Wright has been particularly influential in recovering the distinction between what he calls life after death and life after life after death. The former describes the intermediate condition of believers who have died in Christ, while the latter concerns bodily resurrection and participation in the renewed creation. Wright’s distinction is not an innovation but an attempt to recover the Jewish and early Christian framework in which resurrection was understood as God’s ultimate victory over death, rather than simply the survival of an immortal soul. [1] This distinction provides an important starting point for understanding the biblical hope.

Heaven and Earth in the Ancient Near Eastern World

The ancient Near Eastern world generally understood reality as encompassing divine and human domains, although the precise relationship between these realms varied considerably among cultures. Mesopotamian, Egyptian, and Canaanite traditions associated divine presence with particular cosmic regions, sacred mountains, temples, and heavenly assemblies. The distinction between the divine and human realms was not necessarily understood as a division between the material and the immaterial in the later philosophical sense. Sacred space provided points of intersection between the divine world and the ordinary world of humanity.

Israel’s understanding of creation both participated in and challenged these cultural frameworks. Genesis 1 presents the heavens and the earth as the comprehensive work of one sovereign Creator, while Genesis 2–3 depicts Eden as the place where humanity enjoys direct communion with God. The garden is not merely a primitive agricultural setting. Its sacred geography, divine presence, precious materials, and imagery of life anticipate features later associated with Israel’s tabernacle and temple. The cherubim guarding Eden in Genesis 3:24 find conceptual parallels in the cherubim associated with the ark and sanctuary. The movement from Eden to tabernacle, temple, and ultimately the New Jerusalem forms a significant biblical-theological trajectory. [2]

The resulting theological picture is important. Humanity’s original vocation was not to escape material existence but to live faithfully within creation in the presence of God. The rupture introduced by human rebellion affected relationships between God and humanity, human beings and one another, and humanity and the created order. Consequently, the biblical account of redemption is not simply concerned with relocating human souls after death. It concerns the healing of those ruptured relationships and the restoration of creation to its intended purpose.

This helps explain why the final vision of Revelation is not humanity ascending into heaven but the New Jerusalem descending from heaven. Revelation 21:3 announces the dwelling of God with humanity, echoing covenant promises throughout Israel’s Scriptures. The direction of the imagery is deliberate: God’s presence fills the renewed creation. Heaven and earth, previously distinguished, are brought into complete harmony.

Sheol, Death, and the Development of Israel’s Resurrection Hope

The Hebrew Bible does not present a fully developed doctrine of heaven as the immediate destination of every righteous person at death. Instead, the earlier texts frequently speak of Sheol, the realm of the dead. The Hebrew term sheʾol refers broadly to the condition or domain of the departed and should not automatically be equated with the later Christian concept of hell. Passages such as Psalm 88:3–12, Job 14:10–14, and Ecclesiastes 9:10 reflect the mystery, finality, and apparent silence associated with death.

Yet the Old Testament also contains important movements beyond this conception. Psalm 16:10 expresses confidence that God will not abandon his faithful one to Sheol, while Psalm 73:23–26 presents communion with God as more enduring than bodily life. These passages should not be treated as fully articulated descriptions of the intermediate state, but they establish the relational foundation from which later Jewish hope develops. The central confidence is that death cannot ultimately nullify God’s covenant faithfulness.

By the time of Daniel 12:2–3, resurrection hope becomes explicit. Those sleeping in the dust awaken, and the wise shine with heavenly brilliance. Isaiah 25:6–9 likewise anticipates the defeat of death itself, describing a future divine banquet and the removal of tears. These texts are not simply concerned with the continued existence of a soul. They envision divine action overcoming death and restoring life.

Second Temple Jewish literature reveals how these expectations developed in the centuries surrounding the emergence of Christianity. Wisdom of Solomon 3:1–9 places the righteous in God’s hands and anticipates their vindication. First Enoch 22 portrays differentiated places of waiting for the dead prior to judgment. Fourth Ezra 7:75–101 describes postmortem conditions preceding the final judgment, while Second Baruch 49–51 explores the transformation of resurrected bodies. These works do not speak with a unified voice, and some were composed after the New Testament period. Nevertheless, they demonstrate that Jewish thinkers could distinguish between the condition of the dead and the future resurrection. [3]

This distinction is essential when approaching Jesus and Paul. Their language emerged within a world already wrestling with the relationship between present death, continuing existence, divine judgment, and the ultimate restoration of creation. Christianity did not invent resurrection as a vague promise that life continues after death. Its distinctive proclamation was that Israel’s anticipated resurrection had already begun in Jesus the Messiah and would ultimately embrace those belonging to him.

Paradise and the Intermediate State: What Happens When Believers Die?

One of the clearest New Testament passages concerning the immediate condition following death appears in Luke 23:43. Jesus tells the repentant criminal that he will be with him in paradise. The Greek term paradeisos derives historically from an Iranian word associated with an enclosed garden or park and entered Jewish and Greek religious vocabulary as a way of describing an extraordinary place of life and blessing. In the Septuagint, the term is also used in connection with the garden of Eden. The significance is intriguing: Jesus does not provide a detailed geographical description of the afterlife but promises the dying man personal communion with himself in a place evoking the goodness of God’s garden.

Wright understands this paradise as an intermediate resting place rather than the final destination of the redeemed. His reasoning is grounded in the narrative sequence itself. Jesus promises paradise to the criminal, yet his own bodily resurrection occurs subsequently. Therefore, paradise and resurrection cannot simply be treated as identical experiences. In this reading, paradise is an expression of security, peace, and communion with Christ while awaiting the resurrection of the dead. [4]

Paul provides complementary language in Philippians 1:21–23, where he describes his desire to depart and be with Christ. The Greek expression syn Christō einai, meaning to be with Christ, places the emphasis upon relationship rather than geography. Similarly, 2 Corinthians 5:1–10 contrasts the fragility of present bodily existence with the enduring life God has prepared. Paul expresses confidence about being at home with the Lord, yet his imagery of being clothed rather than found naked also reveals a deeper longing for transformed embodiment.

The interpretation of 2 Corinthians 5 requires some caution. Scholars disagree about whether Paul’s heavenly dwelling refers to an immediate postmortem body, the future resurrection body, or the secure heavenly reality of the resurrection promise. His language cannot settle every question about the precise nature of intermediate existence. Nevertheless, Philippians 1 and 2 Corinthians 5 together provide substantial grounds for believing that death does not separate the faithful from Christ.

Revelation 6:9–11 offers another suggestive image. John sees the souls of those who have suffered martyrdom beneath the heavenly altar. They speak, receive white robes, and are instructed to rest while awaiting the completion of God’s purposes. The passage is apocalyptic rather than a literal architectural description of heaven, but its theological significance is considerable. The martyrs are remembered, their suffering has not been forgotten, and their vindication remains connected to God’s future judgment and renewal.

The intermediate state, then, may be understood as real communion with Christ in which the believer is secure, at rest, and awaiting the fullness of resurrection. Its exact experiential qualities remain largely undisclosed. Scripture does not provide enough detail to describe its physical surroundings, the ordinary passage of time, or the activities of departed believers with confidence. Alternative interpretations, including forms of unconscious waiting until resurrection, have also existed within Christianity. Yet the cumulative force of the passages concerning being with Christ gives substantial support to conscious fellowship with him beyond death.

The Christian hope is therefore not merely that believers survive dying. It is that those who belong to Christ remain his, and that death cannot prevent their future resurrection.

Isaiah 65 and the Creation of a New Heaven and Earth

Isaiah 65:17–25 is among the most important texts for reconstructing the biblical understanding of eternity. The passage announces God’s intention to create new heavens and a new earth and proceeds to describe a renewed Jerusalem characterized by joy, security, meaningful labor, abundant life, and harmony within the created order.

The Hebrew verb baraʾ, meaning to create, is particularly significant. It is the same verb prominent in Genesis 1 and appears repeatedly in Isaiah 65:17–18. The literary connection invites readers to understand the promised future as an act of divine creation. Yet Isaiah’s vision is not detached from the historical experience of Israel. Within the context of exile, imperial domination, dispossession, and threatened communal identity, the promise that people will build houses and inhabit them, plant vineyards and enjoy their fruit, and no longer labor in vain addresses recognizable human suffering.

Isaiah 65:21–23 presents a remarkable picture of restoration. The people are no longer displaced from their homes or deprived of the fruit of their labor. The covenant curses associated with oppression, insecurity, and the failure of agricultural life are reversed. The imagery recalls Deuteronomy 28, Leviticus 26, and Genesis 3. What was once characterized by frustrated labor and vulnerability is transformed into enduring peace and flourishing.

The theological implications are considerable. Isaiah’s future is not characterized by the rejection of ordinary human existence. It includes meaningful work, creativity, belonging, community, and the enjoyment of God’s material creation. The prophetic imagination does not regard houses, vineyards, land, and embodied life as temporary embarrassments to be discarded. Rather, these become expressions of God’s restored purposes.

However, Isaiah 65 also presents an exegetical difficulty that deserves careful attention. Verse 20 contains language concerning death at a hundred years of age. If this passage describes the final eternal state, why does death appear to remain possible? Some interpreters, particularly within premillennial traditions, understand the passage as referring to an intermediate messianic kingdom preceding the final elimination of death. Others argue that Isaiah employs familiar categories of human longevity to communicate a transformed reality that ultimately transcends death altogether.

G. K. Beale has defended the latter approach, arguing that Isaiah 65:20 should be understood within the broader context of eternal new creation rather than as evidence of a temporary kingdom in which death continues. His argument draws upon Isaiah’s creation imagery, the reversal of Genesis 3, the defeat of death in Isaiah 25:8, and the interpretation of Isaiah’s language in Revelation 21–22. [5]

This reading deserves serious consideration because prophetic literature frequently communicates realities beyond ordinary human experience through images drawn from the world known to its original audience. A prophet announcing the complete defeat of death to an ancient community devastated by infant mortality, warfare, famine, and premature death could communicate extraordinary restoration through the imagery of remarkably long life. At the same time, the original language of Isaiah 65:20 should not be dismissed simply because it complicates later theological formulations. Read within its own literary and historical setting, the verse describes longevity rather than explicitly declaring immortality. The movement toward a final state without death becomes clearer when Isaiah 25:8 is read alongside Revelation 21:4.

This represents a useful example of textured hermeneutics. The historical meaning of Isaiah, its prophetic literary form, its place within Israel’s developing eschatology, and its later reception in Revelation must all be considered without collapsing the distinctions between them. Isaiah’s immediate horizon concerns restoration in categories meaningful to Israel, while its canonical trajectory contributes to a larger vision of cosmic renewal.

Will We Remember Our Earthly Lives?

Isaiah 65:17 raises another important question by declaring that the former things will no longer be remembered or come to mind. Does this mean that believers will lose all recollection of their earthly existence? Will relationships, experiences, personal history, and even memories of loved ones disappear?

Such an interpretation faces several difficulties. The Hebrew term zakar, commonly translated to remember, frequently carries covenantal and relational significance beyond the simple retrieval of information. When God declares in Jeremiah 31:34 that he will remember sins no more, the statement does not imply a loss of divine knowledge. Rather, it concerns the termination of sin’s covenantal consequences. Likewise, Isaiah 43:18–19 calls Israel not to remember former things immediately before announcing God’s new work. The emphasis is not necessarily the destruction of historical memory but the arrival of a reality so transformative that the former conditions no longer define the community.

Randy Alcorn has made a similar argument regarding Isaiah 65:17, maintaining that the elimination of painful recollection is not equivalent to the erasure of personal history. He points to the continuity of redemptive memory within the biblical narrative, including the visible wounds of the risen Christ and the commemorative symbolism of the New Jerusalem. [6]

This distinction is especially important when considering personal identity. Christian resurrection theology presupposes some meaningful continuity between the person who dies and the person who is raised. Jesus’ resurrection provides the paradigmatic example. His glorified body is transformed, yet his identity remains recognizable. He remembers his disciples, refers to earlier events, and bears the wounds associated with his crucifixion (Luke 24:36–43; John 20:24–29).

Although these passages do not definitively describe the memory of every resurrected believer, they strongly suggest that transformation does not require the destruction of personal identity. It may therefore be more appropriate to distinguish between remembering suffering and remaining enslaved to suffering. The resurrection promise does not require God to erase the story of our lives. Rather, it anticipates the transformation of our relationship to that story. The sorrow attached to an experience need not remain the defining power of that experience. The redeemed person may remember loss without remaining captive to grief, recognize former wounds without continuing to suffer their destructive consequences, and understand past failures without being condemned by them. The biblical promise is not necessarily that we will forget everything that happened. It is that the former order of sorrow, evil, and death will no longer possess the power to govern our existence.

Resurrection, Embodiment, and the Continuity of Human Identity

One of the most persistent misunderstandings of the Christian afterlife involves the nature of the resurrection body. In 1 Corinthians 15, Paul contrasts the present psychikon body with the future pneumatikon body. These terms are frequently translated as natural and spiritual, leading some readers to conclude that the resurrection involves the abandonment of material existence.

Yet the contrast is not straightforwardly between a physical body and a nonphysical spirit. Paul’s argument concerns the transformation of human existence from its present mortal and corruptible condition into a form of life empowered by the Spirit. His agricultural analogy of the seed and plant emphasizes both continuity and discontinuity. The resurrected body is genuinely related to the present body, yet it is transformed beyond its present limitations. The risen Jesus demonstrates this tension. He is recognizable, speaks, interacts with others, and eats with his disciples, yet his resurrection life is no longer subject to the ordinary limitations of mortality. The Gospel narratives do not present his resurrection as mere resuscitation. They describe the inauguration of a transformed mode of embodied life.

This also raises questions concerning relationships, marriage, and biological identity. Jesus’ response to the Sadducees in Mark 12:18–27, Matthew 22:23–33, and Luke 20:27–40 indicates that marriage as presently constituted does not continue in the resurrection. However, the comparison with angels concerns the conditions of resurrection life, particularly freedom from death and the marital arrangements assumed by the Sadducees. It does not necessarily mean that resurrected humans lose their embodied humanity or become angels. Ian Paul has explored this question by examining early Christian reflection on bodily identity, sexual differentiation, marriage, and resurrection. His analysis draws attention to an important distinction between the continuity of human embodiment and the continuation of every social or biological function associated with mortal life. [7]

The New Testament does not provide a comprehensive description of resurrected biology. Speculation about reproduction, biological development, or the precise nature of bodily differentiation therefore needs to remain tentative. What appears considerably clearer is that resurrection restores rather than obliterates human personhood. We should expect transformation without assuming the loss of everything that makes us recognizably human.

The New Jerusalem: Temple, Eden, and the Dwelling of God

Revelation 21–22 brings several major biblical themes into a single eschatological vision. John sees a new heaven and new earth, the descent of the New Jerusalem, the removal of death and mourning, and the restoration of the river and tree of life. The imagery combines Isaiah 65–66, Ezekiel 40–48, Genesis 2–3, and numerous prophetic promises concerning Zion and the presence of God.

Particularly striking is the absence of a temple building in Revelation 21:22. This does not signify the abandonment of sacred space but its universalization. God and the Lamb are the temple, and the city itself participates in the divine presence. Its cubic dimensions recall the Holy of Holies, suggesting that the entire renewed dwelling of humanity has become sacred space.

Gregory Beale’s temple-centered interpretation of Revelation has been influential in understanding this imagery. The movement from Eden through the tabernacle and temple to the New Jerusalem reflects the expansion of God’s dwelling until creation itself becomes the setting of unhindered communion.

Raymond R. Hausoul’s interdisciplinary comparison of Karl Rahner, Jürgen Moltmann, and Beale provides a valuable contribution to this discussion. Hausoul examines the relationship between biblical and systematic theology in interpreting the new heavens and new earth, emphasizing the importance of both continuity and transformation. The new creation should not be reduced to the annihilation of the present world followed by an entirely unrelated replacement. Rather, the biblical vision points toward the glorification and consummation of God’s original creative purposes. [8]

The language of Revelation 21:1, particularly the declaration that the sea is no more, also requires attention to ancient symbolism. Throughout the Hebrew Bible and surrounding ancient Near Eastern literature, the sea can represent chaos, danger, hostile powers, and threats to God’s ordered creation. The imagery of the sea’s removal may therefore communicate the complete elimination of chaos and evil rather than the literal absence of every body of water in the renewed world. This interpretation is strengthened by the life-giving river flowing through the city in Revelation 22:1–2.

Similarly, the description of nations bringing their glory into the New Jerusalem (Revelation 21:24–26) suggests the redemption of human cultural life rather than its wholesale elimination. The imagery leaves room for understanding the diverse contributions of human society as purified and brought into the worship of God.

The final biblical vision is therefore neither an empty spiritual realm nor a return to ordinary mortal life. It is an embodied, relational, communal, and cosmic restoration in which God’s presence permeates creation.

Will There Be Work, Creativity, and Relationships in the Renewed Creation?

Isaiah 65:21–23 and Revelation 21–22 invite consideration of whether meaningful human activity continues within the eternal kingdom. The biblical evidence does not allow us to describe the precise occupations or ordinary routines of resurrected life. Nevertheless, the consistent affirmation of creation’s goodness provides grounds for questioning the assumption that eternity consists exclusively of passive contemplation.

Work itself precedes the fall. Genesis 2:15 presents humanity’s vocation in the garden through the language of service and care. The Hebrew verbs avad and shamar, commonly understood as working or serving and keeping or guarding, also appear in contexts associated with priestly responsibility. Humanity’s original task was therefore more than agricultural productivity. It involved faithful stewardship of sacred space.

Isaiah’s renewed creation includes the enjoyment of productive labor without exploitation or futility. Revelation presents the servants of God as engaged in worshipful service and reigning (22:3–5). While these descriptions should not be turned into speculative schedules of heavenly activity, they indicate that redeemed existence involves meaningful participation in God’s purposes.

Human relationships likewise appear within a transformed communal context. The New Jerusalem is populated, the nations are represented, and God’s people share a common life in the divine presence. The resurrection does not promise the permanent continuation of every institution that belongs to the present age, but neither does it present salvation as the isolation of individuals within private spiritual experiences.

There is considerable theological reason to anticipate recognition, fellowship, and a redeemed continuity of personal relationships. Yet questions concerning the precise form of those relationships should be approached with humility. Scripture provides the promise of communion more clearly than the details of its organization.

What emerges is a picture of eternity in which human life is neither diminished nor rendered meaningless. Creation, community, worship, and vocation reach their fulfillment in a world no longer governed by decay and death.

The Kingdom Already Present and the Creation Yet to Come

The distinction between the intermediate state and the final resurrection must also be placed within the New Testament’s inaugurated eschatology. The kingdom of God is not exclusively a future reality. Jesus announces its arrival, demonstrates its power through healing and deliverance, and identifies his resurrection as the decisive beginning of God’s victory over death.

Paul describes believers as participants in new creation in 2 Corinthians 5:17, while Romans 8:18–25 presents the entire created order as awaiting liberation from corruption. The Spirit is described as the firstfruits of the coming restoration. The Greek term aparchē, firstfruits, evokes the initial portion of a harvest that anticipates what is yet to come. The presence of the Spirit is therefore not merely evidence of individual spiritual experience but a foretaste of the future toward which creation is moving.

This means the present Christian life has an eschatological character. The church lives between the inauguration and consummation of the kingdom, participating already in a reality that will one day be fully revealed. Acts of mercy, reconciliation, hospitality, justice, faithful stewardship, and covenant love are not substitutes for the coming kingdom. They are expressions of the kingdom’s present reality.

Wright has repeatedly emphasized the implications of this understanding for Christian vocation. The promise of resurrection does not encourage indifference toward the present world. Instead, it establishes the significance of faithful work within God’s creation. First Corinthians 15 concludes its extended treatment of resurrection not with an invitation to withdraw from ordinary life but with an exhortation to remain steadfast in the work of the Lord, knowing that such labor is not in vain.

This provides an important corrective to forms of Christian eschatology that portray the future primarily as escape from a doomed world. The biblical story is not fundamentally one of divine abandonment but divine restoration.

Conclusion: Heaven Is Not the End of the Story

Perhaps the most beautiful aspect of the biblical hope is that death is neither the final word nor the ultimate destination of the believer. Those who die in Christ are not forgotten or abandoned. They belong to him, and nothing, including death itself, can separate them from his love. Yet even that extraordinary promise is not the conclusion of the Christian story. The resurrection of Jesus declares that God intends to do more than preserve our existence beyond the grave. He intends to restore what death has broken, heal what sin has wounded, and bring creation into the fullness of his presence. This changes how we understand grief, how we approach suffering, and how we live today. The relationships we nurture, the people we love, the mercy we extend, and the faithfulness we practice are not meaningless activities within a disposable world. They belong to a kingdom that has already begun breaking into the present. We may not know exactly what paradise looks like or how the renewed creation will feel beneath our feet, but we know the One who has promised to make all things new. Our hope is not simply that one day we will leave this world and go to heaven. Our hope is that God will finish what he began, and heaven and earth will finally become what they were always intended to be.

We are not waiting to escape creation. We are waiting for its restoration.

And until that day, we are called to live as people of the resurrection, bringing the life of the coming kingdom into the world around us.


Notes and References

  1. N. T. Wright, Surprised by Hope: Rethinking Heaven, the Resurrection, and the Mission of the Church (New York: HarperOne, 2008), especially chapters 3, 7, and 11; Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003).
  2. See Genesis 2:8–15; 3:24; Exodus 25:17–22; 1 Kings 6:18–35; Ezekiel 47:1–12; Revelation 21:1–22:5. For the broader temple theology, see G. K. Beale, The Temple and the Church’s Mission: A Biblical Theology of the Dwelling Place of God (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2004).
  3. Wisdom of Solomon 3:1–9; 1 Enoch 22; 4 Ezra 7:75–101; 2 Baruch 49–51. These sources illustrate the diversity of Jewish eschatological reflection and should not be treated as a uniform doctrine or as possessing the same canonical status across Christian traditions.
  4. Wright, Surprised by Hope, especially his discussion of paradise and the intermediate state. See also Luke 23:43; Philippians 1:21–23; 2 Corinthians 5:1–10; Revelation 6:9–11.
  5. G. K. Beale, “An Amillennial Response to a Premillennial View of Isaiah 65:20,” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 61, no. 3 (2018): 461–484. Compare Isaiah 25:8; 65:17–25; Revelation 21:1–4. Interpretations differ concerning whether Isaiah 65 describes the final creation, a millennial kingdom, or prophetic restoration language subsequently expanded in the New Testament.
  6. Randy Alcorn, “Does Isaiah 65:17 Mean We Won’t Remember Our Previous Lives When We’re in Heaven?” Eternal Perspective Ministries, November 20, 2020.
  7. Ian Paul, “Will We Be Male and Female in the New Creation?” Psephizo, July 2016. See also Mark 12:18–27; Luke 20:27–40; 1 Corinthians 15:35–49.
  8. Raymond R. Hausoul, The New Heaven and New Earth: An Interdisciplinary Comparison between Jürgen Moltmann, Karl Rahner, and Gregory Beale (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2020), especially chapters 5–7.
  9. For the Isaianic connections between exile, restoration, creation, and the reversal of the Genesis curses, see Isaiah 11:6–9; 25:6–9; 43:18–19; 65:17–25; 66:22. See also the discussions of Isaiah 65 in Working Preacher, Luther Seminary, particularly its treatments of the restoration of Jerusalem and Edenic imagery.
  10. N. T. Wright, “Heaven Is Not Our Home,” Christianity Today, April 2008; and Wright, “Apocalyptic and the Beauty of God,” sermon delivered at Harvard Memorial Church, October 22, 2006. Both address the relationship between new creation, resurrection, and Christian participation in God’s restorative purposes.
  11. Paul develops the already-and-not-yet character of new creation in Romans 8:18–25; 1 Corinthians 15:20–28, 42–58; and 2 Corinthians 5:1–21. These texts must be read within Paul’s wider understanding of the Spirit, resurrection, and the reign of Christ rather than as isolated descriptions of the afterlife.
  12. N. T. Wright, “The Great Story of the Bible Is Not About Going to Heaven. It’s About God Coming to Us,” Bible Gateway, February 17, 2026. The essay develops the relationship between the divine dwelling, the New Jerusalem, and God’s intention to renew creation rather than abandon it.

Revelation 19:1–10: The Wedding of the Lamb — Heaven Coming to Earth, Not Escaping It

Dr. Will Ryan

For many Christians, the book of Revelation has been understood through the popular Left Behind perspective, a theological framework largely shaped by dispensationalism. In this understanding, believers are suddenly removed from the earth in an event called the rapture, followed by a period of tribulation, the rise of the Antichrist, and eventually the return of Jesus to establish his earthly kingdom. Revelation 19 is often understood as a heavenly celebration involving a church that has already escaped the suffering of the world. While this interpretation has become familiar in modern evangelicalism, it is not the only historic Christian understanding of Revelation, nor do we believe it best reflects the larger biblical narrative.[1]

At Expedition 44, we have consistently encouraged readers to understand Revelation through its first-century Jewish context, its connections to the Hebrew Scriptures, and the kingdom Jesus has already inaugurated. We are not waiting for Jesus to become king. Through his death, resurrection, and ascension, Jesus has already been enthroned (Acts 2:32–36; Eph. 1:20–23). He announced that the kingdom had drawn near (Mark 1:15), demonstrated its arrival through his ministry (Luke 11:20), and declared that all authority in heaven and earth had been given to him (Matt. 28:18). We await the full restoration of creation, but we are already living under the reign of the Lamb. Revelation 19, therefore, is not primarily about escaping a world God has abandoned. It celebrates the defeat of oppressive powers, the faithfulness of God’s covenant people, and the ultimate marriage of heaven and earth.[2]

The Fall of Babylon: The Victory of the Lamb (Revelation 19:1–5)

Revelation 19 opens with heaven celebrating the judgment of Babylon. Within John’s first-century setting, Babylon evokes Rome, the great imperial power whose political, economic, and religious systems demanded allegiance. Yet the imagery reaches further back into Israel’s history. Egypt, Assyria, and Babylon each represented oppressive kingdoms that exalted themselves against Yahweh and his covenant purposes. Daniel 7 portrays these empires as terrifying beasts, while the kingdom of God is given to one like a son of man (Dan. 7:13–14). John employs this same prophetic language to reveal the conflict between the kingdoms of this world and the reign of the Lamb.[3]

An interesting detail is John’s repeated use of Hallelujah, from the Hebrew halelu-Yah, meaning “Praise Yahweh.” The word appears four times in Revelation 19, its only appearances in the New Testament. The worship recalls Israel’s praise following deliverance from Egypt (Exod. 15:1–18). Just as Israel celebrated the defeat of Pharaoh, heaven celebrates the defeat of Babylon. The message is not that God’s people have escaped creation, but that the powers corrupting creation have been judged. This is an expression of Christus Victor: Jesus has conquered the powers that enslave and destroy.

There is also a fascinating contrast between Revelation 18 and 19. The merchants of Babylon mourn because their wealth and security have collapsed, while heaven rejoices because God’s justice has prevailed. What Babylon calls prosperity, heaven recognizes as exploitation. The victory of Jesus exposes the false promises of empire and reminds the church that our ultimate allegiance belongs to the Lamb rather than the systems that compete for our worship.

The Lord God Almighty Reigns (Revelation 19:6)

John hears the declaration that the Lord God Almighty reigns. The Greek title Pantokratōr emphasizes God’s authority over all things. In the Roman world, emperors claimed extraordinary authority and were celebrated as sources of peace, stability, and salvation. Revelation challenges those claims by announcing the sovereignty of Israel’s God.

This declaration recalls Exodus 15:18: “The LORD will reign for ever and ever.” It also connects to Psalm 110, where the Messiah is seated at God’s right hand. Peter explicitly applies this psalm to the resurrected and ascended Jesus in Acts 2:34–36. The kingdom is not postponed until a future political arrangement. Jesus reigns now, even as we await the day when every enemy, including death itself, will finally be defeated (1 Cor. 15:24–26).

This is the important distinction between the kingdom’s inauguration and its consummation. We are living in what theologians describe as the “already and not yet.” The Lamb is already reigning, and his followers are called to embody that reign through justice, mercy, reconciliation, and sacrificial love. Our prayer remains, “Your kingdom come, your will be done, on earth as it is in heaven” (Matt. 6:10).

The Marriage of the Lamb: The Fulfillment of Covenant (Revelation 19:7–8)

The imagery of marriage is deeply rooted in the Hebrew Scriptures. God repeatedly describes his relationship with Israel through the language of marriage and covenant. In Hosea 2:19–20, Yahweh promises to betroth his people in righteousness, justice, steadfast love, and faithfulness. Isaiah 54:5 identifies Israel’s Maker as her husband, while Isaiah 62:4–5 anticipates a restored people over whom God rejoices as a bridegroom rejoices over his bride.

John’s announcement that the marriage of the Lamb has come should therefore be understood within this larger covenant narrative. Jesus is fulfilling God’s longstanding promise to restore his relationship with his people. The bride represents the covenant community gathered around Israel’s Messiah, including Gentiles who have been grafted into God’s covenant promises (Rom. 11:17–24).

Notice something beautiful in Revelation 19:8. The bride is granted fine linen, bright and pure, which John identifies as the righteous deeds of the saints. The Greek edothē means “it was given,” emphasizing that the bride’s clothing is received through grace. Yet the clothing also represents the faithful actions of God’s people. Grace and covenant participation belong together. The bride is being prepared through a life of allegiance to Jesus.

John deliberately contrasts two women and ultimately two cities. Babylon embodies corruption and rebellion, while the bride represents the faithful people of God, later pictured as the New Jerusalem descending from heaven (Rev. 21:2, 9–10).

This imagery is profoundly practical. The church does not prepare for the wedding by withdrawing from the world or waiting passively for a heavenly rescue. We prepare through lives shaped by the character of Jesus. The righteous deeds of the saints are expressions of a kingdom already at work among us.

The Marriage Supper: The Great Messianic Banquet (Revelation 19:9)

The marriage supper of the Lamb has one of its richest Old Testament connections in Isaiah 25:6–9. There, Yahweh prepares a magnificent feast for all peoples, removes the covering over the nations, swallows up death, and wipes away tears. This is not merely a picture of people escaping to heaven. It is a prophetic vision of God’s victory over death and the restoration of his creation.

Jesus repeatedly draws upon this banquet imagery. In Matthew 8:11, people come from east and west to share the feast with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. In Luke 14:15–24, the kingdom is pictured as a banquet welcoming those whom society often overlooks. At the Last Supper, Jesus anticipates drinking the fruit of the vine anew in his Father’s kingdom (Matt. 26:29). Revelation 19 brings these promises together in the great wedding feast of the Lamb.

The direction of the biblical story is particularly important. In Revelation 21:2, John sees the New Jerusalem coming down out of heaven from God. The final vision is not humanity permanently departing the earth, but God dwelling with humanity in renewed creation. Genesis begins with heaven and earth in communion, and Revelation concludes with the restoration and fullness of that relationship (Gen. 1–2; Rev. 21–22).

This does not eliminate the future return of Christ, bodily resurrection, or final judgment. These remain central to Christian hope. Rather, it places those promises within the biblical expectation of restoration rather than permanent separation from creation.[4]

The Testimony of Jesus Is the Spirit of Prophecy (Revelation 19:10)

John concludes this vision by falling at the feet of an angel, who immediately redirects his worship toward God. The angel then declares, “For the testimony of Jesus is the spirit of prophecy.” The Greek expression hē martyria Iēsou can refer to testimony concerning Jesus or testimony given by Jesus, but in either case the prophetic message is inseparable from him.

This is an important corrective to the modern tendency to treat prophecy primarily as a mechanism for predicting future geopolitical events. The Hebrew prophets certainly spoke of future events, but their ministry was fundamentally concerned with revealing God’s character, confronting injustice, challenging idolatry, and calling people back into covenant faithfulness. Isaiah, Jeremiah, Amos, and Ezekiel spoke into the real circumstances of their audiences while announcing the purposes of Yahweh.

John stands within that same prophetic tradition. His message calls believers to faithful allegiance to Jesus despite the competing claims of empire. The church is not instructed to become consumed with identifying future villains or calculating the timing of the end. We are called to worship God and bear witness to his Son.

Living as the Bride in the Kingdom of the Lamb

Jeremiah 29 provides a wonderful connection for understanding our present calling. While living in Babylonian exile, God’s people were instructed to seek the shalom, or flourishing, of the city where they had been placed (Jer. 29:7). They were not called to embrace Babylon’s idolatry, nor were they permitted to abandon their responsibility toward their neighbors. They were to remain faithful to Yahweh while seeking the good of those around them.

This captures something essential about the church’s calling today. We live among the systems of Babylon without surrendering our allegiance to Babylon. We seek the flourishing of our communities while refusing the exploitation, injustice, and false worship that characterize the kingdoms of this world. We belong to the Lamb, and our lives should reflect the character of his kingdom.

In our recent book, Heaven to Earth: Rethinking Revelation and the Hope of the Kingdom, Matt Mouzakis and I explore this very theme. The biblical story is not moving toward the abandonment of creation but toward its renewal under King Jesus. The church lives between resurrection and restoration, participating through the Holy Spirit in the work that Christ has already begun.[5]

Revelation 19 is therefore a beautiful invitation to faithfulness. Babylon does not have the final word. Death does not have the final word. The Lamb who was slain is victorious, and his bride is being prepared. We are not waiting for Jesus to become king, nor are we waiting to begin living as citizens of his kingdom. We belong to him now.

Perhaps the most important question we should ask when reading Revelation 19 is not when the wedding will take place, but how we are preparing for it. If the fine linen of the bride represents the righteous deeds of the saints, what should our churches, families, relationships, and communities look like today?

The bride is already making herself ready. The Lamb is already reigning. And the people of God are called to make the beauty of his kingdom visible in the world until the day when heaven and earth are fully united and all things are made new.

Living in the Victory of the Lamb

How we understand the end of the story shapes how we live in the middle of it. If we are simply waiting to escape, we may miss the very kingdom Jesus has called us to embody. The Lamb is already reigning, and his bride is already being made ready. Every act of mercy, reconciliation, justice, and sacrificial love becomes a visible expression of his kingdom breaking into our world.

Our hope is not that Jesus will rescue us from a creation he has abandoned, but that he will finish restoring what he has already begun. We are not waiting for the kingdom to arrive before we begin living as kingdom people.

Revelation is not an invitation to calculate our departure but a call to faithful participation. We are not called to be experts in the timing of his return, but living witnesses to the reality of his reign.

The bride is not preparing to abandon the world. She is preparing to welcome the King who is making all things new.


Notes

  1. See Will Ryan and Matt Mouzakis, Heaven to Earth: Rethinking Revelation and the Hope of the Kingdom (2026), chap. 2, for an overview of dispensational eschatology and its distinction between Israel and the church. The familiar Left Behind presentation particularly reflects pretribulational dispensationalism, rather than every premillennial interpretation.
  2. Ryan and Mouzakis, Heaven to Earth, chaps. 1, 4–5, 10. See also Ps. 110:1; Dan. 7:13–14; Acts 2:32–36; Col. 1:13–20.
  3. See Dan. 2:31–45; 7:1–14; Rev. 17–18. The identification of Babylon with Rome is prominent in historical-critical interpretations of Revelation, while preterist readings also examine the first-century judgment of Jerusalem. These emphases need not exclude the symbol’s continuing relevance to oppressive powers.
  4. See Isa. 25:6–9; Rom. 8:18–25; 1 Cor. 15:20–28, 51–58; Rev. 21:1–5. Compare Ryan and Mouzakis, Heaven to Earth, chap. 7, on partial preterism and the continuing expectation of resurrection and new creation.
  5. Ryan and Mouzakis, Heaven to Earth, chap. 10 and conclusion, especially the discussion of the church as the bride, the inaugurated kingdom, and the renewal of creation.
Comments Off on Revelation 19:1–10: The Wedding of the Lamb — Heaven Coming to Earth, Not Escaping It Posted in ADVENTURE

RENDER UNTO CAESAR: WHOSE IMAGE DO WE BEAR?

Following another election, I’ve found myself reflecting on the relationship between the church and political power, particularly the way Christians have been treating one another. I’ve been troubled by how easily political disagreements turn into anger, hostility, and even contempt among people who profess to follow Jesus. I think this points to a deeper issue concerning our allegiance and how we understand the Kingdom of God.

There’s a passage I’ve been thinking about that often comes up in conversations about Christianity and politics:

“Give back to Caesar what is Caesar’s and to God what is God’s” (Mark 12:17).

This passage is frequently used as a prooftext for the Christian’s political duty to earthly governments. It’s often interpreted as Jesus establishing two separate spheres of allegiance, one political and one spiritual. Caesar gets our political loyalty, while God gets our religious devotion. But when we examine the historical and theological context, I think Jesus is doing something far more profound.

In Mark 12:13–17, the Pharisees and Herodians attempt to trap Jesus with a question about paying taxes to Caesar. For first-century Jews, Roman taxation was more than an economic burden. It was a reminder that God’s covenant people were living under foreign occupation, subject to an empire that made competing claims to divine authority. If Jesus supported the tax, he risked alienating those who opposed Roman rule. If he rejected it, he could be accused of rebellion.

But notice what Jesus does. He refuses to answer their question on their terms. Instead, he reframes the entire conversation.

They ask whether it is lawful to give (didōmi) taxes to Caesar. In other words, the question is framed around what Caesar is owed. And isn’t that precisely the question Caesar wants people asking? The conversation begins with his authority, his demands, and what belongs to him. But Jesus refuses to allow Caesar to define the conversation.

Instead, he asks them to produce a denarius. And here’s an interesting detail we often overlook: this exchange takes place in the Temple courts, the very place dedicated to the worship of Yahweh.

The coin they produce likely bore the image of Tiberius Caesar, along with the inscription, “Tiberius Caesar Augustus, son of the divine Augustus.” On the reverse was the title Pontifex Maximus (chief priest), accompanied by a figure associated with Pax, the Roman personification of peace. Think about what this coin was communicating. Caesar was presented as the son of a god, Rome’s chief priest, and a representative of the peace the empire claimed to bring to the world. This wasn’t simply currency. It was imperial theology stamped into silver. And here’s the irony: standing in the courts of God’s Temple, Jesus’ opponents readily produce a coin bearing these claims while attempting to trap the very Son of God!

Jesus asks, “Whose image (eikōn) is this? And whose inscription (epigraphē)?”

“Caesar’s,” they respond.

The Greek word eikōn is the same word used in the Greek Old Testament when Genesis describes humanity as created in God’s image (Genesis 1:26–27). Jesus then tells them to give back (apodidōmi) to Caesar what belongs to Caesar and to God what belongs to God. Notice the shift. They want to know what they owe Caesar, but Jesus redirects their attention toward something much more significant: what belongs to God?

Caesar’s image was stamped upon the coin, but God’s image was stamped upon humanity. As Psalm 24:1 reminds us, “the earth is the LORD’s, and everything in it.” Jesus wasn’t dividing our lives into competing allegiances. He was exposing the limits of Caesar’s claims while reminding his audience of God’s comprehensive claim upon their lives.

In other words, give Caesar back his stupid coin (not your allegiance), and give God all of you because you are his image.

But there’s another fascinating detail in Mark’s Gospel. The Greek word epigraphē (inscription) appears again at Jesus’ crucifixion, where the inscription above his head reads, “The King of the Jews” (Mark 15:26). Caesar’s claims to power were inscribed upon a coin, while Jesus’ kingship was proclaimed above a cross. Two radically different expressions of kingship.

And Jesus had already explained the difference to his disciples. In Mark 10:42–45, he reminds them that the rulers of the Gentiles “lord it over” others and exercise authority through domination. Then he says something that should challenge every Christian understanding of power: “Not so with you.” Greatness in his Kingdom is measured not by the ability to control others but by the willingness to serve them. Jesus himself came “not to be served, but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many.”

This doesn’t mean God’s people should withdraw from the world or remain silent about injustice. Throughout Scripture, God’s people are called to be prophetic witnesses, speaking truth to earthly powers and embodying an alternative way of life. But our calling is not to rule the world according to Caesar’s methods while claiming to advance Jesus’ Kingdom. We cannot accomplish the purposes of a crucified Messiah through domination, coercion, and the pursuit of worldly power.

And this is where I think the passage becomes particularly challenging for the American church.

When we become too entangled in the politics of this world, we risk being formed into the image of Caesar rather than the image of Christ. We begin adopting the patterns of earthly kingdoms: tribalism, ethnocentrism, consumerism, the pursuit of power, and the tendency to “other” those who disagree with us. Rather than being a prophetic witness to the world, we begin reflecting the very systems we are called to challenge.

I’ve been particularly disappointed by the way I’ve seen Christians treating one another following another election. The anger, hostility, and contempt directed toward those of a different political persuasion are troubling, especially when we begin acting as though our preferred political party represents God’s side.

But Jesus is not left or right… He is above. His Kingdom cannot be reduced to our political categories, and neither party can claim him as its own. God has one Kingdom, and it cannot be identified with any earthly nation, political party, or government. America is not the Kingdom of God, nor can any earthly nation claim to be the Christian nation.

In 1 Peter 2:9, Peter describes the church as “a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God’s special possession.” Notice who Peter identifies as God’s holy nation. It isn’t Rome or any other earthly empire. It’s the people of God. This nation isn’t defined by geographical borders, ethnic identity, or earthly citizenship, but by allegiance to Jesus. It is a people gathered from every nation, tribe, people, and language (Revelation 7:9), united under the reign of one King. Our identity as citizens of God’s Kingdom must transcend every earthly allegiance.

And the way we treat others should reflect the character of that King. In Matthew 5:21–22, Jesus takes the commandment against murder and presses it deeper, confronting the anger and contempt we harbor toward others. We may congratulate ourselves for never taking another person’s life, but Jesus challenges the hostility we allow to take root in our hearts. The same contempt that dehumanizes another person stands in direct opposition to the Kingdom he came to establish. He then goes even further, commanding us to love our enemies and pray for those who persecute us (Matthew 5:43–48). If Jesus calls us to love even our enemies, how much more should that shape the way we treat fellow Christians whose political convictions differ from our own?

We can hold different political convictions without allowing those differences to produce contempt for people who bear God’s image. But when our political allegiances begin determining who we love, who we reject, and how we treat one another, perhaps we’ve already given Caesar far more than his coin.

Jesus held up a coin and asked whose image it bore. The question for us is whether we’ve allowed the kingdoms of this world to reshape the image we’re supposed to reflect.

Give Caesar his coin. Give God your whole life. And don’t let Caesar remake you in his image.

Your soul is reserved for bearing the divine image of Christ, not the beastly image of Caesar.

written by Matt Mouzakis Th.D.

Comments Off on RENDER UNTO CAESAR: WHOSE IMAGE DO WE BEAR? Posted in ADVENTURE

Foreword: Missed Assignment – A Guide to Biblical Discipleship and the Church’s Forgotten Calling

Through the work of The King’s Commission School of Divinity, there is an extraordinary privilege in walking alongside pastors and ministry leaders who have devoted their lives to serving Jesus and caring for His people. Many have spent decades faithfully preaching, counseling, teaching, planting churches, and shepherding congregations through seasons of tremendous joy and profound difficulty. Yet a concern emerges repeatedly in conversations with these leaders. Somewhere amid the demands of ministry, many churches have gradually lost sight of the first-century understanding of discipleship that remains central to our calling. We have developed sophisticated approaches to worship, preaching, organizational leadership, and congregational growth, while often struggling to cultivate the kind of relational and spiritual formation that characterized the ministry of Jesus. Dr. Roger Sherwood understands this tension from the experience of pastoral ministry. His book, Missed Assignment, addresses an essential concern facing the contemporary Church with the humility of a shepherd and the conviction of someone who deeply loves the people of God.

Having had the privilege of working with Roger through his doctoral studies, I have come to appreciate his willingness to examine the assumptions and practices that shape contemporary Christian ministry. His reflections emerge from years of pastoral service, theological study, and the lived experience of investing in people through the ministry of New Creation Family Church. Throughout these pages, the reader encounters an author who understands the challenges of congregational leadership and possesses the pastoral courage to reconsider familiar approaches when they no longer adequately serve the Church’s calling. The Kingdom fruit evident through his ministry, including restored relationships, strengthened families, and the development of believers into faithful servants and leaders, provides a meaningful context for the concerns he raises. Roger writes with an evident affection for the Church and a sincere desire to see its people mature in their understanding of Scripture, their relationship with Christ, and their responsibility toward one another.

The contemporary Church has become accustomed to evaluating its influence through measurable institutional outcomes. Attendance, financial stability, organizational expansion, ministry participation, and increasingly digital engagement frequently serve as indicators of success. Such measurements can provide useful information about the reach and practical circumstances of a congregation, yet they cannot adequately describe the spiritual maturity of its members. A church may experience numerical growth while remaining uncertain about the theological understanding, relational health, and spiritual formation of those who attend. A congregation may possess considerable organizational strength while depending upon a small number of leaders for nearly every aspect of its ministry. These tensions invite a more careful examination of ecclesial purpose. What does the New Testament actually envision when it describes the people of God, and what kind of formation should emerge from their shared participation in the life and mission of Jesus Christ?

Roger’s central concern is situated within this question. His argument invites pastors and believers to reconsider the relationship between the activities of Christianity and the formation of Christian disciples. He approaches discipleship as the central responsibility entrusted to the Church, with implications for pastoral leadership, theological education, spiritual formation, and the shared life of the congregation. His work provides a thoughtful opportunity to recover the biblical and theological foundations of disciple-making while considering how those foundations might reshape the practices of contemporary ministry.

Discipleship Within the Covenantal World of Scripture

Any serious theological consideration of discipleship benefits from recovering the covenantal world in which the biblical writings emerged. Modern Western Christianity frequently approaches religious identity through categories shaped by individual belief, personal decision, institutional membership, and the acquisition of theological information. These concerns have their place within Christian life, but they can obscure the relational and communal framework through which the biblical authors understood belonging to the people of God. In the ancient Near East, identity was deeply connected to households, kinship relationships, communal obligations, and the larger political and religious allegiances that structured everyday existence. Faithfulness to YHWH therefore involved far more than participation in prescribed religious activities. It encompassed the ordering of individual and communal life according to the purposes of the covenant.

The Hebrew term bĕrît (בְּרִית), commonly translated as “covenant,” provides an important theological framework for understanding this relationship. Although the various covenant forms found throughout the ancient Near East differed considerably in their provisions and purposes, their emphasis upon established relationships, loyalty, obligations, and communal identity helps illuminate significant dimensions of Israel’s Scriptures. The biblical covenants should not be reduced to any single ancient treaty model, yet the relationship between belonging and covenantal responsibility remains indispensable to understanding Israel’s identity.¹ The exodus preceded Sinai, establishing the gracious deliverance of YHWH as the foundation for Israel’s subsequent calling. Israel was redeemed into a particular way of life, one in which worship, justice, family responsibilities, economic relationships, hospitality, and treatment of the vulnerable were understood within the wider reality of covenant faithfulness.

This integrated understanding of human existence is especially important when considering spiritual formation. The Hebrew Scriptures do not consistently separate the spiritual life from the ordinary experiences of embodied existence in the manner sometimes assumed within modern religious discourse. The term nepeš (נֶפֶשׁ), often translated as “soul,” frequently refers to the living person or life itself rather than to a distinct spiritual component isolated from the body.² Within this anthropological framework, human beings respond to God through their relationships, choices, desires, worship, and responsibilities. Their faithfulness is demonstrated through the ordinary circumstances of life. Consequently, the formation of God’s people cannot be adequately described through intellectual development or religious participation alone. It concerns the integration of covenantal identity with the habits and practices through which that identity becomes visible.

Deuteronomy 6:4–9 provides one of the clearest biblical illustrations of this formative responsibility. The Shema begins with the command šĕmaʿ yiśrāʾēl (שְׁמַע יִשְׂרָאֵל), “Hear, O Israel,” followed by the confession concerning YHWH and the command to love Him with heart, nepeš, and strength. The Hebrew verb šāmaʿ, meaning “to hear” or “to listen,” frequently carries implications of attentive reception and responsive obedience within covenantal contexts. The command calls Israel to receive divine instruction as something that will shape the conduct and allegiance of the community. Moses subsequently instructs the people to keep these words upon their hearts and to teach them diligently to their children. The verb šānan (שָׁנַן), used in verse 7, carries the basic sense of sharpening and, within this instructional context, describes the careful impressing of teaching upon another person.³

The imagery is instructive. Just as a blade is sharpened through repeated contact, covenant instruction is impressed upon the lives of God’s people through sustained engagement, observation, conversation, and practice. Moses situates this process within the ordinary rhythms of household life, instructing the people to speak of God’s words while sitting at home, walking along the road, lying down, and rising. These expressions describe the comprehensive nature of covenantal formation. The household becomes a primary setting for the transmission of faith, while the larger community shares responsibility for remembering and embodying the covenant. Biblical instruction is inseparable from the relationships and experiences through which one generation prepares another to live faithfully before God.

This pattern extends throughout Israel’s Scriptures. Psalm 78 emphasizes the responsibility of communicating the works of YHWH to succeeding generations so that they might place their confidence in God, remember His deeds, and observe His commandments. The recurring Hebrew language of remembrance, particularly the verb zākar (זָכַר), frequently connects recollection with action appropriate to the relationship being remembered. Israel’s feasts, memorials, songs, and communal practices preserved the testimony of God’s faithfulness while bringing its significance into the continuing life of the covenant people. The objective was the formation of succeeding generations whose lives would reflect the identity and commitments of the community to which they belonged.

Roger recognizes this theological continuity in his discussion of discipleship before the New Testament. His treatment of Deuteronomy 6, Psalm 78, Moses and Joshua, and Elijah and Elisha demonstrates that intentional spiritual formation did not originate with the institutional development of the Christian Church. The Gospel narratives introduce a distinctive and climactic expression of discipleship through the person and ministry of Jesus, yet this development belongs within the larger biblical story of God forming a people who receive His instruction, embody His purposes, and participate in transmitting that faith to others. Appreciating this continuity helps readers understand why discipleship must be approached as a comprehensive way of life rather than as an isolated program within the congregation.

The First-Century Calling to Follow Jesus

The ministry of Jesus developed within the social, religious, and theological world of Second Temple Judaism, where teachers gathered students and various Jewish communities cultivated recognizable patterns of instruction and shared religious practice. Although care must be exercised when relating later rabbinic traditions to the first century, the Gospel narratives themselves provide substantial evidence that discipleship involved a relationship extending beyond the formal communication of religious knowledge.⁴ The Greek noun mathētēs (μαθητής), commonly translated as “disciple,” identifies a learner or pupil, but its significance within the Gospels is shaped by the particular demands of following Jesus. His invitation, akolouthei moi (ἀκολούθει μοι), “Follow me,” summoned individuals into a relationship that would progressively reorder their priorities, relationships, understanding of God, and participation in the world.

The pedagogical practices of Jesus reveal the deeply formative character of this invitation. His disciples accompanied Him through villages and marketplaces, observed His interactions with the marginalized, witnessed His responses to opposition, shared meals, listened to His teaching, and participated in the proclamation of the Kingdom. Their misunderstandings, failures, fears, and competing ambitions became occasions for continued instruction and correction. Mark 3:14 offers a particularly important description of their calling, explaining that Jesus appointed the Twelve so that they might be with Him and so that He might send them to preach. The relationship between proximity and mission deserves careful consideration. Their preparation unfolded within the shared experiences of life with Jesus, where theological understanding developed alongside character, obedience, discernment, and practical responsibility.

This understanding of discipleship challenges approaches to theological education and congregational ministry that assume information alone will naturally produce spiritual maturity. The acquisition of biblical knowledge is indispensable to faithful Christian formation, but the New Testament consistently connects instruction with the transformation of the person receiving it. Luke 6:40 provides a concise description of this objective when Jesus declares that the disciple who has been fully trained will become like the teacher. The participle katērtismenos (κατηρτισμένος), from katartizō, conveys the sense of being prepared or brought into a fitting condition. Resemblance to the teacher becomes an essential outcome of the formative relationship. Within Christian discipleship, the life, character, teachings, and mission of Jesus provide the pattern toward which believers are continually being formed.

The Great Commission in Matthew 28:18–20 brings this formative responsibility into the explicit missionary calling of the Church. The central imperative, mathēteusate (μαθητεύσατε), commands the followers of Jesus to make disciples of all nations. The accompanying participles concerning going, baptizing, and teaching identify essential dimensions of this commission, while the instruction to teach new disciples to observe everything Jesus commanded establishes obedience as an integral component of disciple-making. The commission is framed by the authority of the risen Messiah and His promise of continuing presence. The Church is therefore summoned to participate in the mission of the enthroned Christ, cultivating communities whose members increasingly embody His teaching and bear witness to His reign.

Roger’s treatment of the relationship between following Jesus and developing mature disciples is especially valuable within this context. His concern extends beyond the initial response of faith to the continuing formation of the believer. His discussion of Jesus’ relational methods, the distinction between church attendance and discipleship, and the responsibility to prepare others for ministry reflects the central insight that Christian maturity involves participation in the life and mission of the One being followed. Robert Coleman’s familiar discussion of the methods of Jesus and Dallas Willard’s emphasis upon intentional apprenticeship provide helpful scholarly conversation partners for this approach.⁵ Roger brings these concerns into the practical circumstances of congregational life, where pastors and ministry leaders must continually consider whether their teaching and organizational practices are contributing to the formation of mature followers of Christ.

The Church, Consumer Culture, and the Problem of Formation

A particularly useful contemporary illustration appears in the prologue to Brave Cities, where the development of surfing culture provides an analogy for the changing relationship between shared practices and consumer participation. The authors describe a culture historically shaped by commitment, relationships, sacrifice, and embodied experience that underwent considerable transformation as commercial interests expanded access to its outward activities and symbols. The growth of the surrounding industry created new opportunities for participation while raising important questions about the relationship between consuming a particular experience and inhabiting the way of life from which that experience emerged.⁶ The illustration invites a similar consideration of contemporary Christianity, particularly the extent to which the expansion of religious programs and institutional resources may coexist with a diminished commitment to the relational practices that historically sustained Christian communities.

Many congregations have become highly capable of providing meaningful religious experiences. Considerable attention is devoted to effective communication, worship environments, ministry programming, leadership development, and the practical systems necessary to sustain organizational life. These efforts can serve important purposes within the Church, yet their expansion can also contribute to an understanding of congregational participation increasingly shaped by consumer expectations. Pastors become providers of religious content, while congregants approach church involvement primarily through what they receive. The resulting organizational structures may support considerable activity without necessarily cultivating the mutual responsibility and spiritual maturity envisioned in the New Testament.

The ecclesiology of Ephesians 4:11–16 offers a significant corrective to this tendency. Paul describes the gifts given to the Church for the equipping of the saints toward the work of ministry and the building up of the body of Christ. The Greek noun katartismos (καταρτισμός), commonly translated as “equipping,” concerns preparation for an intended purpose. Within this passage, the responsibilities of Christian leadership are directed toward the maturity and participation of the entire community. The body grows through its living relationship with Christ and the contribution of its members, who are called to speak truth in love, exercise their gifts, and participate in the mutual strengthening of the Church. Pastoral leadership therefore carries a fundamentally formative responsibility. Its purpose includes preparing believers to participate meaningfully in ministry rather than concentrating the congregation’s spiritual responsibilities within a relatively small group of professional leaders.

Roger illustrates the consequences of this distinction through one of the most meaningful accounts in his book. He describes a season when his congregation appeared to be functioning successfully. Worship was well organized, ministry positions were filled, and the ordinary responsibilities of congregational life were being fulfilled. Over time, however, he began to recognize that some of the people participating in these ministries were not necessarily developing the deeper discipleship relationships and spiritual maturity he had hoped to cultivate. His reflections led him to reconsider the relationship between ministry participation and spiritual formation, particularly the possibility that people could become highly involved in church activities without receiving the intentional investment necessary for mature discipleship.

This account gives Missed Assignment much of its pastoral credibility. Roger allows readers to encounter the questions through the experience of a shepherd willing to examine his own leadership. His concern for the Church emerges alongside a recognition that familiar structures and sincere intentions do not necessarily guarantee the outcomes toward which ministry should be directed. His willingness to reflect upon these experiences with humility offers an example for leaders who may be confronting similar questions within their own congregations. The discussion encourages careful discernment rather than simplistic judgments about church size, organizational development, or particular ministry models. Congregations of different sizes and traditions can cultivate meaningful discipleship, just as any congregation can become distracted by the maintenance of its own activities. The central question concerns whether the Church is forming people whose lives increasingly reflect the character and mission of Jesus.

Word, Spirit, and the Formation of Covenant Community

The New Testament presents spiritual formation as an ongoing work of God within the life of His people. The Church’s responsibility to teach, encourage, correct, and equip believers remains essential, yet the transformation of human character cannot be manufactured through organizational efficiency or educational sophistication. In 2 Corinthians 3:18, Paul describes believers as being transformed into the image of the Lord through the activity of the Spirit. The verb metamorphoumetha (μεταμορφούμεθα), “we are being transformed,” communicates a continuing process in which the people of God increasingly reflect the character of Christ. Likewise, Galatians 4:19 provides an especially intimate expression of Paul’s pastoral concern as he describes his longing for Christ to be formed within the Galatian believers. The language of formation reveals an apostolic vision extending beyond the communication of religious knowledge toward the development of a community whose life reflects the Messiah.

This transformation unfolds within the relational and communal environment of the Church. Acts 2:42–47 describes believers devoted to the apostles’ teaching, fellowship, the breaking of bread, and prayers, with their shared life extending into hospitality, material generosity, worship, and responsibility toward one another. The Greek term koinōnia (κοινωνία) describes sharing or participation and contributes to the portrait of a community whose common allegiance to Jesus produced tangible patterns of relational and material involvement. The Church’s earliest communities were certainly not without conflict, as the apostolic letters demonstrate, but their calling required believers to develop the habits and relationships appropriate to their new identity in Christ. The New Testament’s recurring instructions to love, encourage, forgive, serve, and bear one another’s burdens presume an environment in which the members of the community share responsibility for one another’s growth.

This covenantal and communal understanding of discipleship is particularly important for interpreting Roger’s emphasis upon the relationship between Word and Spirit. Scripture provides the authoritative witness through which believers learn the story, teachings, and purposes of God, while the Holy Spirit forms the character of Christ within the community and empowers believers for faithful participation in His mission. The relationship between biblical understanding and spiritual transformation is therefore essential to mature discipleship. A congregation may develop considerable theological knowledge without cultivating the relational maturity that should accompany it, just as enthusiasm for spiritual experience may become detached from the biblical discernment necessary for faithful Christian practice. Roger appropriately emphasizes the importance of both dimensions, encouraging pastors and believers to pursue a form of discipleship in which sound instruction and dependence upon the Spirit contribute to the formation of mature Christian character.

This formative process also requires the recognition that spiritual growth is rarely uniform or easily measured. The development of patience, humility, generosity, forgiveness, wisdom, and faithful obedience often becomes visible through the ordinary experiences of relationships and communal life. Believers learn to embody the teachings of Jesus as they navigate conflict, respond to suffering, extend hospitality, care for the vulnerable, and share responsibility for the needs of others. These practices provide opportunities for the transforming activity of the Spirit to become evident in concrete expressions of Christian faithfulness. Roger’s discussion of relational discipleship helps readers recognize that the Church’s formative responsibility belongs to the entire body. Pastors are entrusted with important responsibilities of leadership and instruction, but the continuing growth of the community depends upon believers learning to participate faithfully in one another’s lives.

From Following Jesus to Multiplying Disciples

The New Testament’s vision of discipleship extends beyond individual spiritual maturity toward the continuing transmission of faithful Christian witness. In 2 Timothy 2:2, Paul instructs Timothy to entrust what he has received to faithful people who will be capable of teaching others. The passage describes a movement extending across successive generations of believers, demonstrating that the preservation of apostolic teaching and the development of future leaders were inseparable concerns. Paul understood that his personal ministry would not continue indefinitely, and Timothy was therefore responsible for preparing others to carry forward the work entrusted to him. The spiritual health of the community could not remain permanently dependent upon the presence or abilities of its founding leaders.

Roger develops this principle through a practical progression from following Jesus to walking with Him, serving within His body, and participating in the multiplication of disciples. His framework recognizes that mature Christian formation should increasingly extend beyond the individual believer toward the spiritual encouragement and development of others. This process is not restricted to those who occupy formal ecclesiastical offices. Parents, teachers, neighbors, students, and ordinary members of the congregation participate in disciple-making whenever they intentionally help others grow in their understanding of Scripture, their relationship with Jesus, and their participation in the life of the Church. The resulting influence may unfold slowly and often remains difficult to quantify, yet its significance becomes evident as faithfulness is transmitted through relationships and across generations.

This understanding also challenges the tendency to evaluate pastoral effectiveness primarily through the accomplishments of individual leaders. One of the most meaningful expressions of faithful pastoral ministry is the development of people who can eventually carry responsibility, exercise their gifts, and strengthen others without remaining dependent upon the pastor’s direct involvement. Such leadership requires humility, patience, and a willingness to entrust responsibility to those who are still growing. It also requires confidence that the mission belongs ultimately to Christ rather than to the institutions or personalities through which it is presently expressed. The Church serves its calling faithfully when its members become increasingly capable of participating in the ministry of the whole body and preparing others to do likewise.

Roger’s practical discussions of shepherding, relational investment, leadership development, and multiplication make these theological convictions accessible to readers serving in a variety of ministry contexts. His reflections encourage pastors to consider how their existing ministries contribute to the formation of disciples and invite ordinary believers to recognize their own responsibility within the mission of the Church. The book’s recurring opportunities for reflection, application, and intentional next steps further reinforce its formative purpose. Readers are encouraged to examine their assumptions, identify practical opportunities for growth, and consider how their own lives might become instruments through which others encounter the love and teachings of Jesus.

The Assignment Before Us

One of the most encouraging aspects of Missed Assignment is the spirit in which it has been written. Roger’s reflections are grounded in a genuine affection for the Church and an abiding confidence in the continuing work of God among His people. He recognizes the considerable pressures facing contemporary congregations and the difficulties pastors encounter as they seek to balance spiritual care with organizational responsibility. His writing offers encouragement to leaders who may sense that their ministry has become consumed by activity and who desire to recover a more intentional approach to forming mature followers of Jesus. His concern is ultimately constructive, inviting readers to reconsider the purpose of familiar practices and to cultivate forms of ministry that bring biblical instruction, spiritual formation, relational investment, and shared participation into closer alignment.

Roger’s conclusion provides a particularly meaningful expression of the theological humility necessary for this work. He reminds readers that faithful discipleship frequently involves sacrifice, surrender, and the willingness to invest in others without controlling the outcome. His memorable observation, “Your job is the cross. God’s job is the resurrection,” captures the conviction that Christian obedience requires patient participation in the work of God while recognizing that transformation ultimately belongs to Him. Pastors may invest faithfully in people without immediately witnessing the results they desire. Parents may spend years nurturing the spiritual lives of their children while continuing to trust God with their development. Believers may offer encouragement, instruction, and care without knowing how profoundly those ordinary acts of faithfulness will influence another person’s journey. The life of discipleship calls us to persevere in such relationships, trusting that the Spirit continues His formative work through the faithful participation of God’s people.

The beauty of Christian discipleship is often most evident in circumstances that attract little attention. It appears when a young believer begins to understand Scripture, when a struggling marriage moves toward reconciliation, when someone discovers the grace to forgive, or when a mature Christian patiently accompanies another person through a difficult season of life. These experiences rarely receive the recognition associated with institutional achievement, yet they reveal something profoundly important about the Kingdom of God. The life of Jesus becomes visible through ordinary people whose relationships, priorities, and practices are being transformed by His presence. Such fruit may develop quietly over many years, extending into families and communities in ways that no pastor or congregation can fully measure.

Dr. Roger Sherwood has devoted his ministry to cultivating this kind of Kingdom fruit. His love for the people of New Creation Family Church, his commitment to theological learning, and his willingness to examine his own pastoral journey have contributed to a work that deserves thoughtful attention. The reader will encounter sound biblical reflection, meaningful pastoral experience, and practical encouragement for recovering the formative character of Christian discipleship. Roger has written with a shepherd’s heart, inviting the Church to remember the mission entrusted to it and to consider how that mission might be more faithfully embodied in its common life.

It is a privilege to commend Missed Assignment to pastors, ministry leaders, students of Scripture, and believers who desire to participate more intentionally in the mission of Jesus. My prayer is that the Holy Spirit will use these pages to encourage and strengthen those who have grown weary in ministry, to renew the vision of those entrusted with shepherding God’s people, and to awaken within our congregations a deeper longing for the life of Christ. May we become communities where the words of Scripture are faithfully taught, where relationships provide opportunities for genuine spiritual formation, and where each generation accepts the responsibility of preparing those who will follow. May we recover the patience to walk with people, the humility to learn from one another, and the courage to reconsider whatever may distract us from the calling of our King. Ultimately, the assignment before the Church is a beautiful invitation to participate in the continuing work of Jesus, whose grace forms us into His likeness and whose Spirit empowers us to carry His love into the lives of others.


Notes

  1. George E. Mendenhall, “Covenant Forms in Israelite Tradition,” Biblical Archaeologist 17, no. 3 (1954): 50–76; Dennis J. McCarthy, Treaty and Covenant: A Study in Form in the Ancient Oriental Documents and in the Old Testament, 2nd ed., Analecta Biblica 21A (Rome: Biblical Institute Press, 1978); Christopher J. H. Wright, Old Testament Ethics for the People of God (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2004).
  2. Hans Walter Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1974), particularly the discussion of nepeš and the integrated conception of human existence within the Hebrew Scriptures.
  3. Francis Brown, S. R. Driver, and Charles A. Briggs, A Hebrew and English Lexicon of the Old Testament (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1907), s.v. “שנן”; Jeffrey H. Tigay, Deuteronomy, JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1996), commentary on Deut 6:4–9.
  4. Michael J. Wilkins, Following the Master: A Biblical Theology of Discipleship (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1992); Rainer Riesner, Jesus als Lehrer: Eine Untersuchung zum Ursprung der Evangelien-Überlieferung, Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 2/7 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1981).
  5. Robert E. Coleman, The Master Plan of Evangelism (Old Tappan, NJ: Fleming H. Revell, 1963); Dallas Willard, The Great Omission: Reclaiming Jesus’s Essential Teachings on Discipleship (San Francisco: HarperSanFrancisco, 2006).
  6. Brave Cities, prologue, “The Day Everything Changed in Surfing and the Church,” particularly the discussion of surfing culture, commercialization, and consumer-oriented Christianity. Complete bibliographic details should be confirmed from the publication’s copyright page before typesetting.

Comments Off on Foreword: Missed Assignment – A Guide to Biblical Discipleship and the Church’s Forgotten Calling Posted in ADVENTURE

Should Christians Vote? The Kingdom Jesus Refused to Build

Political Power, the Great Commission, and the Question of Christian Allegiance

I have written several times over the years about Christians and voting. My position has not always been particularly popular, especially among American evangelicals who have come to understand voting as something approaching a Christian obligation. Yet I have never been entirely convinced that Scripture requires Christians either to vote or to abstain. I suspect the answer is considerably more complicated, and perhaps more situational, than either position allows.

Recently, my good friend Dr. Steve Cassell preached a message concerning Christian responsibility in the political arena. I have tremendous respect for Steve, not only as a pastor and theologian, but as someone who has given considerable thought to what faithful Christian engagement with government should look like. In fact, I consider him one of the finest examples I know of someone attempting to approach political involvement through a genuinely Christian worldview. Whether Jesus would agree with all of our conclusions about politics is another question entirely, and perhaps part of the reason this conversation is worth having! Although Steve and I do not always see eye to eye on these matters, I believe his position is thoughtful, biblically motivated, and worthy of serious consideration.

We share an essential conviction: Jesus Christ is King, and our allegiance belongs to Him above every earthly institution. In his recent message, Steve argues that because Christians are commanded to love their neighbors, seek the welfare of their communities, and disciple the nations, they should participate in political processes that allow them to influence the laws governing those communities. He connects this responsibility particularly to Matthew 28, suggesting that voting can become one means through which Christians disciple their nation. You can watch Steve’s message here.

I appreciate his concern for justice and the welfare of our neighbors, and I agree that laws can profoundly influence the communities in which we live. However, I am less convinced that Scripture establishes voting as a Christian duty or that influencing legislation is necessarily an expression of discipling the nations. The question becomes particularly interesting when we consider the political world Jesus entered and the remarkable ways He refused the available models of power.

First-century Judaism was anything but politically unified. The Jewish people had experienced centuries of foreign domination, and the memory of the Maccabean revolt against Seleucid oppression remained an important part of their national identity. Some Jewish leaders cooperated with Rome, while others sought greater separation from its religious and political influence. The Essenes, described by Josephus and often associated with the communities responsible for the Dead Sea Scrolls, cultivated distinctive covenantal communities that anticipated God’s judgment upon wickedness. Their relationship to the broader political resistance of the period remains debated, but their writings reveal an expectation that God would eventually confront the corrupt powers governing the world.[1]

Other movements were considerably more confrontational. Josephus describes Judas the Galilean, whose movement arose in opposition to Roman taxation during the census associated with Quirinius in 6 CE. Judas and his followers believed that recognizing Roman political mastery compromised their allegiance to God. Josephus explains that they insisted God alone was their rightful ruler and lord, maintaining this conviction even under the threat of suffering and death.[2]

I find this historical connection fascinating. The declaration that God alone is King was already a politically charged confession before the ministry of Jesus began. Yet Judas understood this conviction in ways that encouraged resistance to Roman domination, while Jesus announced the arrival of God’s kingdom without adopting the revolutionary methods associated with such movements. Their theological language could sound remarkably similar, but their approaches to earthly authority were profoundly different.

Jesus had opportunities to align Himself with the political expectations of His contemporaries. John 6:15 records that a crowd intended to seize Him and make Him king, yet He withdrew. He did not join a Maccabean-style liberation movement, identify His ministry with the separatist vision associated with Qumran, or pursue influence within the existing religious-political establishment. His refusal was not a rejection of His identity as King, but a rejection of the means through which people expected that kingship to be established.

John the Baptist provides another intriguing comparison. Josephus records that Herod Antipas feared John’s influence might produce an uprising, leading to his imprisonment and execution.[3] The Gospels emphasize John’s prophetic confrontation with Herod’s conduct rather than any revolutionary program, so we should not assume John was organizing political resistance. Nevertheless, it is striking that when John questioned Jesus from prison, Jesus pointed toward healing, restoration, and good news for the poor rather than political liberation (Matt 11:2–6). Jesus did not organize John’s release, although the text gives us no reason to conclude that He disapproved of John’s prophetic ministry. The kingdom was arriving, but its arrival did not mean that Jesus would overthrow every unjust ruler or immediately liberate every faithful person suffering beneath political authority.

Perhaps the most revealing event occurs in Luke 4:5–8, where the devil offers Jesus authority over the kingdoms of the world in exchange for worship. Within the narrative, the devil claims that this authority has been given to him, and Jesus refuses the offer without directly disputing that claim. Matt Mouzakis and I examine this passage extensively in our book Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, connecting it to the Deuteronomy 32 worldview, in which the nations exist amid rebellious spiritual powers and disordered political authority.[4]

The temptation offered Jesus an apparently efficient path toward possessing the nations without the suffering of the cross. He refused because His kingship could not be established through compromised allegiance. This does not make every form of governmental participation inherently evil, but it should challenge our assumption that acquiring political influence necessarily advances the kingdom of God.

Jesus later told Pilate that His kingdom was not ek tou kosmou toutou, not from this world (John 18:36). His point concerned the origin and character of His kingdom, as demonstrated by His explanation that His followers would otherwise fight to prevent His arrest. Likewise, in Mark 10:42–45, Jesus contrasted the rulers of the nations, who exercise domination over others, with the servant leadership expected of His disciples.

Jesus possessed legitimate authority over the nations while refusing the very methods by which earthly rulers ordinarily secured and exercised that authority. Surely that should inform how His followers think about political power.

This brings me back to Steve’s argument concerning Matthew 28:18–20. Jesus declares that all authority in heaven and earth belongs to Him and commands His followers to make disciples of all nations. Steve reasons that because Christians possess opportunities to shape national legislation through voting, political participation can become an extension of the Great Commission.

While I understand the connection, I believe this interpretation moves beyond what the passage actually teaches. The primary imperative in Matthew 28:19 is mathēteusate, meaning to make disciples. The object of that command is panta ta ethnē, all nations or peoples. The accompanying participles describe baptizing and teaching these disciples to observe what Jesus commanded. The passage concerns the formation of people who follow Jesus, not the establishment of political structures that compel societies to observe Christian moral standards.[5]

This distinction matters because legislation and discipleship are fundamentally different activities. Civil laws may restrain harmful behavior, protect vulnerable people, and establish conditions that encourage social flourishing. Those are legitimate concerns, but governmental compliance does not produce covenantal allegiance to Jesus. Israel’s own history illustrates that possessing righteous laws did not necessarily produce a righteous people. The prophets anticipated a deeper restoration through transformed hearts and the work of God’s Spirit (Jer 31:31–34; Ezek 36:26–27).

There is also a historical difficulty with interpreting the Great Commission as a mandate for political influence. The earliest Christians received this command while possessing little opportunity to influence Roman legislation, yet Acts describes them faithfully fulfilling their calling through proclamation, baptism, teaching, hospitality, and the formation of distinctive communities. Their inability to control governmental policy did not prevent them from making disciples.

A Christian might reasonably view voting as one way of seeking justice or protecting neighbors, but that is a potential application of Christian ethics rather than an explicit command of the Great Commission. Christ’s authority over the nations does not automatically establish an obligation for Christians to govern those nations in His name.

In Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, Matt and I argue that the relationship between the church and earthly government must be understood within the broader biblical narrative rather than through isolated interpretations of Romans 13. Paul’s instruction to submit to governing authorities follows Romans 12, where Christians are commanded not to conform to the present age, to bless persecutors, to refuse retaliation, and to overcome evil with good. Romans 13 itself continues into the command to love one’s neighbor. The passage addresses how Christians should conduct themselves within existing political arrangements, not how they might acquire authority over those arrangements.

Revelation 13 introduces the other side of this theological tension. Drawing upon Daniel 7, John portrays imperial power through the imagery of a beast whose authority comes from the dragon. Within its first-century context, this imagery confronted Rome’s claims to political and religious allegiance. The contrast between the beast and the Lamb is not simply a distinction between immoral and moral leaders. It concerns competing kingdoms, each demanding the loyalty of those who belong to it.[6]

This is where the language of allegiance becomes essential. The question is not merely whether a Christian participates in society, pays taxes, or exercises certain civic responsibilities. It is whether those activities begin to redefine the believer’s identity and loyalty. The distinction becomes especially clear in Jesus’s response concerning taxation. When asked whether the imperial tax should be paid, Jesus pointed to Caesar’s image upon the coin and instructed His questioners to return to Caesar what belonged to Caesar while giving God what belonged to God (Mark 12:13–17).

The early Christian writer Tertullian recognized the deeper theological implications of this exchange. Caesar’s image appeared upon his coin, but humanity bears the image of God. The coin might be returned to Caesar, but the human person belongs to the Creator.[7] Jesus had transformed a political question into a question of ultimate allegiance.

I think this distinction is particularly important in modern American Christianity. Voting may begin as a thoughtful attempt to serve one’s community, yet political participation can gradually cultivate loyalties that compete with our identity in Christ. Political movements encourage believers to identify with their parties, defend their candidates, and view opposing groups as threats. Eventually, the church may become better known for its political commitments than for its embodiment of the teachings of Jesus.

The danger is not necessarily the act of casting a ballot. It is allowing political systems to shape our understanding of righteousness, community, enemies, and ultimately the kingdom of God. When Christians begin defending behavior they would otherwise condemn because it advances their political interests, the problem is no longer merely political disagreement. It has become a question of compromised allegiance.

Scripture also provides meaningful reasons why a Christian might choose to participate in government. Jeremiah 29:7 instructed Israel’s exiles to seek the shalom, or welfare, of Babylon, even though Babylon was responsible for their displacement. Joseph and Daniel exercised governmental responsibilities within foreign empires, demonstrating that participation in imperfect political institutions did not necessarily constitute spiritual compromise. Paul likewise called Christians to pray for rulers and pursue peaceful lives characterized by dignity and godliness (1 Tim 2:1–2).

These passages remind us that allegiance to Christ does not require indifference toward our neighbors. There may be circumstances in which voting provides a responsible opportunity to protect vulnerable people, restrain injustice, or contribute to the welfare of a community. A Christian may participate in these ways without imagining that political success establishes the kingdom of God.

However, these same biblical examples do not establish a universal obligation to participate. Jeremiah instructed the exiles to seek Babylon’s welfare without commanding them to acquire political authority. Daniel served faithfully within government while remaining prepared to suffer rather than violate his allegiance to God. The early church contributed to the welfare of Roman society while some Christian teachers maintained distance from forms of public service they regarded as incompatible with discipleship. Origen, responding to the pagan critic Celsus, even argued that Christians served society through the distinctive life and ministry of the church rather than necessarily occupying governmental office.[8]

I believe there is room for Christians to reach different conclusions concerning a particular election. One believer may prayerfully conclude that voting is a responsible way to serve the community under the circumstances. Another may conclude that participation would require an unacceptable compromise of conscience or an identification with political conduct contrary to the teachings of Jesus.

Neither conclusion should automatically become a measure of another person’s faithfulness. Romans 14 reminds us of the importance of conscience and humility in matters where believers may reach different practical judgments while remaining accountable to the same Lord. Although Paul was addressing different disputes, the principle cautions against transforming an application of Christian ethics into a universal command when Scripture has not done so.

As another election approaches, I recognize how deeply these conversations affect our churches, families, and friendships. There are Christians who genuinely believe their participation in the political process is an expression of loving their neighbors. There are others who look at the character of political discourse, the compromises required by party loyalty, and the increasingly hostile spirit of public life and wonder whether their participation is drawing them away from the way of Jesus.

I think both concerns deserve serious consideration. What troubles me pastorally is how quickly we have allowed voting to become a test of Christian faithfulness. We sometimes speak as though a believer’s commitment to the kingdom can be measured by whether they enter a voting booth, or even by the particular choices they make once inside. Yet Jesus never established political participation as the defining evidence of discipleship. He spoke instead about love, mercy, reconciliation, holiness, faithfulness, and the willingness to lay down one’s life for others.

For those who choose to vote, I would encourage you to do so with humility and a conscience formed by the teachings of Jesus. Take seriously your responsibility to your neighbors, particularly those who are vulnerable or unable to defend themselves. But refuse to surrender your integrity to a candidate or party. Do not excuse dishonesty because it serves a cause you support, and do not allow political disagreement to become an excuse for withholding love from someone Christ has called you to serve.

For those who choose not to vote, I would offer a similar encouragement. Let your abstention emerge from conviction rather than apathy. Continue seeking the welfare of your community, caring for people in need, confronting injustice, and demonstrating the character of Christ in ordinary life. The kingdom has never depended upon the availability of a ballot, and the responsibility to love our neighbors does not disappear when we choose not to cast one.

Above all, I would ask each of us to consider what our political involvement is doing to our hearts. Are we becoming more gracious, more patient, more truthful, and more willing to love our enemies? Or are we becoming increasingly fearful, angry, suspicious, and convinced that everything depends upon the next election? If our political convictions are producing qualities that look increasingly unlike Jesus, perhaps we need to examine what has been discipling us.

I deeply appreciate Steve’s conviction that Christ alone is King. It is precisely because I share that conviction that I hesitate to make political participation a necessary expression of Christian discipleship. Jesus had opportunities to secure His kingdom through familiar mechanisms of earthly power, yet He consistently chose another way. His kingdom would be revealed through people who embodied His character, even when doing so placed them at odds with the authorities of their age.

My hope is that Christians on both sides of this question can recover that same confidence in Jesus. We do not need to question one another’s devotion to Christ simply because we reach different conclusions about an election. Our unity is not found in a candidate, a political party, or a shared strategy for influencing government. It is found in the One who has called us to follow Him.

And perhaps this is what I most want to leave with the church: Please do not allow the politics of this world to rob you of the people Jesus has called you to love. Do not sacrifice a friendship, divide a family, or wound a brother or sister in Christ over an earthly kingdom that will one day pass away. Speak truthfully, pursue justice, and act according to conscience, but remember that the person across the political aisle is still someone made in the image of God.

You may enter the voting booth believing it is an act of faithfulness, or you may refrain for precisely the same reason. Either way, when the election is over, the calling of Jesus remains. We will still be commanded to love our enemies, care for the poor, welcome the stranger, forgive those who wrong us, and bear witness to a kingdom unlike the nations surrounding us.

The kingdom of God has never needed an electoral victory to move forward. It has advanced through ordinary people who faithfully follow an extraordinary King.

Vote if you believe you should. Refrain if your conscience leads you otherwise. But do not confuse either decision with the fullness of Christian discipleship.

Jesus is already King. Let us make certain our lives reveal that we believe it.


Endnotes

  1. Josephus, J.W. 2.119–161; Community Rule (1QS 1–9); War Scroll (1QM). See also Joan E. Taylor, The Essenes, the Scrolls, and the Dead Sea (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012). The relationship between the Qumran community and the wider Essene movement remains a matter of scholarly discussion.
  2. Josephus, Ant. 18.4–10, 23–25. Josephus associates Judas the Galilean’s movement with opposition to Roman taxation and a conviction that God alone was ruler and lord. His retrospective interpretation of revolutionary movements should be considered when evaluating the account.
  3. Josephus, Ant. 18.116–119; cf. Mark 6:17–29; Matt 11:2–6. Josephus emphasizes Herod’s fear that John’s popular influence might lead to rebellion, while the Gospel accounts emphasize John’s prophetic confrontation with Herod’s marriage.
  4. Matt Mouzakis and Will Ryan, Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances: Interpreting Romans 13:1–7, 1 Peter 2:13–17, and Revelation 13 within a Deuteronomy 32 Worldview (2025), chaps. 1–4, especially “Jesus and Empire.” The discussion of Luke 4 situates Jesus’s temptation within the wider biblical narrative of the nations and hostile spiritual powers.
  5. Matt 28:18–20. See Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar beyond the Basics: An Exegetical Syntax of the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1996), 640–45, for discussion of the grammatical relationship between the main imperative and accompanying participles.
  6. Mouzakis and Ryan, Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, chaps. 6–8. The authors interpret Romans 13:1–7 and Revelation 13 through the larger biblical narrative of exile, the nations, and the principalities and powers, emphasizing the distinction between responsible conduct beneath earthly authorities and ultimate allegiance to Christ.
  7. Tertullian, Marc. 4.38. Tertullian connects Caesar’s image on the denarius with the image of God borne by humanity, drawing a distinction between civil obligations and divine ownership.
  8. Origen, Cels. 8.73–75. Origen defends the Christian contribution to public welfare through prayer, ecclesial service, and the cultivation of a community ordered toward God’s purposes. See also Mouzakis and Ryan, Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, introduction, discussion of patristic interpretations.

A Life Fully Alive: Remembering My Friend Paul Turnbaugh

There’s something extraordinary about gathering to remember a man like Paul Turnbaugh. Over these past several weeks, as I’ve reflected on his life and visited with so many people who loved him, I’ve come to recognize something remarkable about my friend Paul.

Everybody thought Paul was the greatest guy in the world.

And almost everybody seemed to believe they were one of his best friends.

I’ve been thinking about that. How does one man manage to have a hundred best friends? But that was Paul. He possessed an extraordinary capacity to love people, to take an interest in their lives, and to make them feel genuinely important. He was about as true-blue, all-American a man as I’ve ever known. He loved his family, his friends, his country, the outdoors, and above all, his Lord Jesus Christ.

Paul was an artist, a musician, a photographer, a hunter, a fisherman, a teacher, a mentor, a thinker, and a wonderful friend. He loved life. And if I could summarize something about him in just a few words, I would say that Paul had a remarkable gift for being fully alive.

This morning, we gathered at St. Francis, and the priest reminded us that we are presently in what the Church calls Ordinary Time. In the Christian liturgical calendar, Ordinary Time is represented by the color green, a color that reminds us of life, growth, and the ongoing work of God in the world.¹

As I sat there thinking about Paul, I couldn’t help but smile.

Ordinary Time. Green. Life. Growth. Creation.

I thought, how wonderfully appropriate for Paul Turnbaugh.

Because Paul had an extraordinary love for the ordinary things of life.

For Paul, there really wasn’t such a thing as an ordinary day. There were ordinary routines, certainly, but he approached them with an enthusiasm that made each day feel like a new adventure.

Paul could look at the same birds every single day and somehow be just as excited about them as he had been the day before.

Some of you may remember Paul’s fascination with the sandhill cranes, particularly one young crane he affectionately named Egbert.

Paul became captivated by this little bird. He would photograph him, follow his development, and document his life with the kind of enthusiasm you might expect from someone witnessing a once-in-a-lifetime event. Except Paul could experience that same excitement again tomorrow, and the day after that, and the day after that.

I can just imagine him heading out with his camera, ready to capture another chapter in Egbert’s life.

And it wasn’t just the cranes.

There were the turkeys. The deer. The birds along the roadside. Thérèse laughed as she remembered Paul wanting to stop and photograph the turkeys yet again. She would remind him that they had just photographed them yesterday, and that they were, after all, standing in the middle of a road!

But Paul couldn’t help himself. There was something beautiful to see, and he didn’t want to miss it.

And then there were the crows.

Apparently, Paul developed a special relationship with the neighborhood crows. He started feeding them, eventually settling on peanuts, and before long he was making crow noises to call them into the yard. Whenever he heard them nearby, he would excitedly announce their arrival and head outside.

And he would tell Thérèse how beautiful they were. Crows!

Most of us look at a crow and see a black bird. But Paul would point out the extraordinary colors hidden in those feathers, the purples and other iridescent shades that become visible when the sunlight catches them just right.

He was seeing things the rest of us didn’t even notice.

And Thérèse said something that I thought was profoundly beautiful. She said that because of Paul, she will never look at turkeys, cranes, or even crows quite the same way again.

That’s what happened when you spent time with Paul. He changed the way you saw the world.

I love that.

Psalm 19 tells us that the heavens declare the glory of God and the skies proclaim the work of his hands. The psalmist describes creation as a continual witness to its Creator, declaring his glory without ever needing to speak a word.²

Paul seemed to understand that instinctively.

He spent his life photographing a creation that was already proclaiming the majesty of the Lord. And in sharing those images, he invited the rest of us to stop long enough to appreciate it.

There is something deeply Christian about that kind of attentiveness. We live in a world where it’s easy to become so occupied with responsibilities, worries, and schedules that we overlook the simple gifts God has placed all around us.

But Paul didn’t need extraordinary circumstances to experience joy. He recognized the extraordinary goodness of God in ordinary life. and in ordinary time.

And that brings me to a passage of Scripture that I think describes Paul remarkably well.

In Romans 12, the apostle Paul gives a beautiful description of what a life devoted to Christ ought to look like. He speaks of sincere love, affection for one another, generosity, hospitality, and faithfulness.

And in verse 11, he writes:

“Never be lacking in zeal, but keep your spiritual fervor, serving the Lord.”

The Greek word translated fervent is zeontes (ζέοντες), pronounced ZEH-on-tess.

It’s a wonderful word that comes from the Greek verb zeō, which means to boil or to be hot. Figuratively, it describes someone burning with enthusiasm, zeal, and devotion.³ Calmly overflowing. Somewhat calculated but consistent and persevering, almost never stopping -overflowing.

I can’t think of a better description of Paul. He was fervent in spirit.

Look at the surrounding verses. Love sincerely. Honor one another. Practice hospitality. Rejoice with those who rejoice. Weep with those who weep.

In other words, our devotion to the Lord becomes visible in the way we love and serve others.

And this is where I think Paul’s life offers such a beautiful testimony.

He didn’t simply love God’s creation. He loved the people God had placed within it. At our TOV community Paul Loved to be the photographer. And he treated everyone as if they were the most important person of the night. Come over here stand next to this person, Lets get this truck in the background put your arms around each other, oh you have a great smile, WOW look at this- Check out the light in the sky… LOOK at this photo! People were so captivated by his presence.

Paul could find common ground with almost anybody.

Even when someone was a little different, awkward, or perhaps not the easiest person to connect with, Paul would find something interesting about them. He would ask questions. He would engage them in conversation. He would take time to listen.

He had a way of removing the awkwardness from a conversation and making people feel completely comfortable being themselves.

I think that’s one of the reasons so many people considered Paul their best friend.

He wasn’t looking for reasons to avoid people. He was always finding reasons to love them. I was his pastor, but he shepherded me in this area.

I am also a wedding photographer and Paul would often shoot with me. The first time He shot a wedding with me I found him in a barn surrounded by groomsmen, laughing and talking with everyone. There he’d be, sitting on a pool table, right in the middle of the conversation, having the time of his life.

“Paul, aren’t we supposed to be taking pictures?” But Paul was enjoying the people and the joy of the occasion.

That was Paul.

He never seemed too busy to enjoy someone else’s happiness.

And I think that reflects something beautiful about the heart of Christ. Jesus had an extraordinary way of seeing people whom others overlooked. He made time for those who were often pushed aside, and he treated them with dignity, patience, and genuine compassion.

I saw something of that same spirit in my friend.

Of course, one of the most beautiful expressions of Paul’s love was his relationship with Thérèse.

Over the years, when I’ve spoken about marriage within our TOV community, I’ve often pointed to Paul and Thérèse as a wonderful example of covenant love.

They genuinely delighted in each other.

The smiles, the laughter, the morning coffee, their walks together, the drives through the countryside, and their endless conversations about life, creation, and the Lord.

They weren’t simply committed to one another. They thoroughly enjoyed being together.

And there is something deeply meaningful about that.

So much of marriage is discussed in terms of commitment, responsibility, and perseverance. Those things certainly matter. But Paul and Thérèse also demonstrated the beauty of friendship within marriage, the kind of relationship where two people continue discovering reasons to be thankful for one another.

Thérèse, your life together has been a beautiful testimony to so many of us.

And Paul’s love for Elliott, Rachel, Trinity, Marie, and Max was equally evident. His family meant the world to him. You couldn’t spend much time talking with Paul before he began telling you about the people he loved. His family wasn’t simply one part of his life. They were at the very heart of it.

Paul also left a remarkable impression on so many young people.

He was an extraordinarily gifted artist who spent more than forty years as a professional illustrator. He contributed to hundreds of books and taught art at Judson College and Faith Christian School.

But beyond his professional accomplishments, I think one of his greatest gifts was the way he encouraged creativity in others.

He helped young people recognize that the gifts God had placed within them were meaningful and worth developing.

The opening chapters of Genesis introduce God as Creator, and humanity is subsequently described as bearing his image. Our capacity to create, cultivate, imagine, and bring beauty into the world reflects something of the Creator whose image we bear.⁴

Paul understood this. He used his gifts to celebrate God’s creation and inspire others to do the same.

I think particularly about the students at Faith Christian School, many of whom will carry something of Paul’s influence for the rest of their lives.

And on a very personal level, I think about my own children, especially my son Will, who shares Paul’s love for art.

As a father, I’ve spent a great deal of time thinking about the kind of men I hope my boys become. And as I reflect on Paul’s life, I realize how much of what I desire for them was embodied in my friend.

I hope they grow to appreciate life the way he did. To love their families, cultivate meaningful friendships, develop their gifts, and serve the Lord with genuine enthusiasm.

I hope they learn to see beauty where others might overlook it.

And I hope they learn to love people the way Paul did.

When you find yourself hoping that your children grow up to resemble one of your friends, that says an extraordinary amount about the character of that friend.

Paul was that kind of man.

I’m also deeply grateful for the friendship we shared.

The hunting excursions, the early mornings outdoors, the countless conversations about theology and life, the men’s Bible studies, and the hours we spent wandering around with our cameras trying to capture something extraordinary.

Paul had so many interests, and somehow we seemed to share an awful lot of them.

His love of music was another important part of his life. Through Tribe 519, Ebenezer Stone, and the many opportunities he had to worship with others, Paul expressed his devotion to the Lord with the same enthusiasm he brought to everything else. I think his practice times in His studio with the Band were some of the greatest and most cherished days of his life.

He loved Christ.

And that love permeated the way he lived.

One of the things I appreciated most about my conversations with Thérèse was her description of their final morning together.

It was, in so many ways, an ordinary morning.

They had their coffee. They talked. They enjoyed being together. They went for a walk.

There was no indication that it would be the last day they shared in this life.

And yet, as Thérèse reflected on that morning, she said something that has stayed with me.

Paul didn’t know it was his last day.

But he lived that day with the same enthusiasm and gratitude that had characterized all the others.

He didn’t suddenly decide to appreciate life because he knew time was running out.

He had already made a practice of appreciating life.

Every day was a new opportunity to enjoy the people he loved and the beauty God had created.

And isn’t that something?

We often hear people say that we should live every day as though it might be our last. But I think Paul’s example teaches us something a little deeper.

We should live every day as though it is a gift from the Lord, because it is.

Not with anxiety about what tomorrow might bring, but with gratitude for what God has entrusted to us today.

Jesus reminds us in Matthew 6 not to become consumed with tomorrow’s worries. And the book of James reminds us that we do not know what tomorrow will bring (Jas 4:13–15).

That uncertainty is part of our humanity. It doesn’t mean we should live in fear. It means we ought to live faithfully, gratefully, and attentively in the time we have been given.

Paul did that so beautifully.

And this brings me back to that reflection from St. Francis this morning.

Ordinary Time.

Green.

Life. Growth. Hope.

In the Christian calendar, Ordinary Time is not a season when nothing significant is happening. It’s a season of learning to follow Christ in the ongoing rhythms of daily life. A season of growing in faithfulness, love, and maturity.

Paul’s life was a beautiful illustration of that.

His greatest testimony wasn’t found only in the extraordinary accomplishments of his professional career, although those were considerable.

It was found in the ordinary faithfulness of his life.

In loving his wife.

In cherishing his family.

In encouraging a student.

In befriending someone others might overlook.

In lifting his voice in worship.

In photographing a sunrise.

In finding delight in a sandhill crane named Egbert.

Or in noticing the remarkable colors hidden in the feathers of a crow.

Paul didn’t have to wait for some great spiritual occasion to experience the goodness of God.

He found opportunities to love and serve the Lord in the ordinary moments of every day.

And perhaps that’s one of the most important lessons his life leaves with us.

The Christian life is not simply about preparing for eternity. It is about learning to live faithfully before the Lord here and now, allowing his love to shape the way we see creation, treat other people, and steward the gifts we’ve been given.

Of course, today there is also genuine sorrow.

We miss Paul.

I miss my friend.

I miss the conversations, the laughter, the hunting adventures, the music, and the countless memories I thought we still had time to make.

And for Thérèse and the family, that absence is felt in ways deeper than words can express.

But Christian hope never asks us to pretend that grief is insignificant.

When Jesus stood before the tomb of Lazarus, his friend, he wept. He entered into the sorrow of those who loved Lazarus, even as he proclaimed himself the resurrection and the life.

And because of the resurrection of Jesus Christ, we believe that death does not have the final word.

The apostle Paul describes the hope of resurrection in 1 Corinthians 15, while Revelation 21 gives us that magnificent picture of God’s ultimate renewal of creation, when death and mourning will be no more.⁵

Our hope is rooted in the faithfulness of God, who has promised to make all things new.

And I find that especially meaningful as we remember a man who loved God’s creation so deeply.

A man who delighted in the beauty of this world and whose faith was anchored in the Lord who created it.

As I reflect on Paul’s legacy, I realize that his life has left me wanting to live differently.

I want to notice more sunrises.

I want to be more patient with people.

I want to be more generous with encouragement.

I want to take more time with my family and friends.

I want to see more beauty in the ordinary things I might otherwise overlook.

And perhaps that’s the greatest gift Paul leaves us.

His influence doesn’t end with his passing. It continues in the people whose lives he touched and whose perspectives he helped change.

Thérèse said that she will never look at a crane, a turkey, or a crow quite the same way again.

And I think all of us who knew Paul could say something similar.

Because when you spent time with Paul, you came away seeing life a little differently.

I began today by wondering how one man could have a hundred best friends.

I think I understand it a little better now.

Paul simply loved people. And he loved them with the same extraordinary enthusiasm with which he embraced the rest of God’s creation.

He lived richly.

He loved deeply.

He gave generously.

And he followed the Lord with genuine fervency.

My dear friend, thank you for the hunts, the photographs, the music, the conversations, and the years of extraordinary friendship. Thank you for loving my family and investing in my children. Thank you for the joy you brought to our TOV community and for the example you set for so many of us.

Thank you for reminding us that the glory of God can be found in the most ordinary moments of life, if only we will take the time to see it.

And thank you for demonstrating what it means to be fervent in spirit, faithful in love, and fully alive in Christ.

I will miss you tremendously, my brother.

But I suspect that every time I see a sandhill crane, hear a crow, or pause to appreciate a beautiful sunrise, I’ll be reminded of you.

And I’ll smile.

Because somewhere along the way, you taught me to see those things differently.

Until we meet again, my friend.


Endnotes

  1. United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, “Ordinary Time,” USCCB, https://www.usccb.org/prayer-worship/liturgical-year/ordinary-time. Ordinary Time emphasizes growth in Christian discipleship and the continuing life of Christ in the Church. Green is its designated liturgical color.
  2. Ps 19:1–4; cf. Ps 104:1–24. The heavens are portrayed as a continual witness to God’s glory, offering testimony through the created order without spoken words.
  3. Rom 12:11. Greek ζέοντες (zeontes), from ζέω (zeō), “to boil” or “to be fervent.” See Walter Bauer, Frederick W. Danker, William F. Arndt, and F. Wilbur Gingrich, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000), 426. See also Acts 18:25. The immediate context of Rom 12:9–21 connects spiritual fervency with sincere love, hospitality, generosity, and mutual devotion.
  4. Gen 1:26–28; 2:15; Exod 31:1–5. The biblical theme of humanity as the image of God includes the vocation to cultivate and steward creation. Bezalel’s Spirit-enabled craftsmanship provides a particularly meaningful example of artistic skill employed in service to God.
  5. John 11:25–35; 1 Cor 15:20–28, 42–58; Rom 8:18–25; Rev 21:1–5. Christian hope is grounded in the resurrection of Christ, the promised resurrection of the dead, and God’s ultimate renewal of creation.

Comments Off on A Life Fully Alive: Remembering My Friend Paul Turnbaugh Posted in ADVENTURE

The Pedagogy of Jesus: Recovering the Way of the Master Teacher

Beyond the Pulpit: Teaching, Mentorship, and the Formation of a People Who Follow Jesus

One of the most significant questions facing contemporary homiletics is whether the modern church has gradually elevated one dimension of Jesus’ ministry—public proclamation—above the larger vocation that gave proclamation its purpose. In many congregations, the pastor’s primary responsibility has become the preparation and delivery of a weekly sermon. The congregation assembles, receives instruction from a platform, and returns to ordinary life until the following gathering. Spiritual growth is often measured through attendance, sermon engagement, and familiarity with biblical teaching. While public proclamation has an undeniable place within the biblical tradition, this arrangement deserves careful examination against the actual ministry of Jesus and the patterns of the earliest Christian communities.

Jesus certainly preached. The Gospels describe him teaching in synagogues (Mark 1:21–22), addressing crowds (Matt 5–7), and proclaiming the kingdom throughout Galilee (Mark 1:14–15). Yet the remarkable feature of his ministry is how little of his work can be adequately described by the modern concept of delivering a weekly sermon. Jesus called people to follow him, not merely to listen to him. He shared meals, traveled with his disciples, interpreted Scripture along the road, confronted their misplaced ambitions, involved them in ministry, corrected their misunderstandings, and eventually entrusted them with responsibility for others. His ministry was lived in proximity to those he was forming. The proclamation of truth was central, but proclamation belonged to a much larger process of discipleship.

The contrast becomes even more striking in Acts 2:42–47. Luke describes the first community of believers as devoted to the apostles’ teaching, fellowship, the breaking of bread, and prayer. The Greek verb proskartereō (προσκαρτερέω), expressed here as the participle proskarterountes, communicates sustained devotion or persistent participation. Teaching was essential, but it was embedded within a shared life characterized by meals, generosity, prayer, mutual responsibility, and daily fellowship. Public teaching and household gatherings operated alongside one another (Acts 2:46; 5:42). The earliest church was not simply an audience gathered around gifted communicators; it was a community being formed around the risen Messiah.¹

This does not mean the first-century church possessed no recognizable preaching ministry, nor does it establish that every congregation must reproduce the social arrangements of Jerusalem. The New Testament repeatedly emphasizes public instruction (Acts 20:7–12; 1 Tim 4:13; 2 Tim 4:2), and historical developments in Christian worship are considerably more complex than a simple movement from homes to auditoriums. Nevertheless, we should distinguish the biblical legitimacy of public preaching from the modern tendency to make sermon delivery the organizing center of pastoral ministry.

In some contemporary settings, the pastor has become an increasingly distant religious professional whose principal contact with the congregation occurs through a microphone. The congregation knows the preacher’s voice, illustrations, opinions, and theological positions, yet may have little opportunity to observe the preacher’s life, participate in ministry alongside that leader, or experience personal spiritual mentorship. We have become highly proficient at constructing platforms for teaching while sometimes neglecting the relationships through which teaching becomes embodied.

This raises a difficult but necessary question: If our model of pastoral ministry produces effective public speakers but few mature disciples capable of discipling others, have we preserved the form of proclamation while neglecting its intended purpose?

John Stott’s Between Two Worlds appropriately identifies the preacher’s responsibility to bridge the world of Scripture and the world of contemporary hearers. Yet the biblical picture suggests that the bridge cannot be constructed through communication alone. The shepherd must also be present among the sheep. Preaching should not become a substitute for the personal, relational, and communal formation that characterized the ministry of Jesus.²

The formation of disciples is not an innovation introduced by Jesus in the first century. It belongs to the larger biblical story of God’s intention to dwell among humanity and form a people who reflect his character within creation.

Genesis 1:26–28 describes humanity as created in the ṣelem (צֶלֶם), or image, and dĕmût (דְּמוּת), or likeness, of God. Ancient Near Eastern royal ideology frequently associated kingship with the representation of divine authority, while divine images could symbolize a deity’s presence and rule. Genesis places this representative vocation upon humanity itself, male and female alike. Rather than restricting divine representation to a particular earthly king, the narrative identifies human beings as those commissioned to reflect God’s purposes throughout creation.³

This vocation develops through Israel’s covenant calling. Exodus 19:5–6 identifies Israel as a treasured possession, a kingdom of priests, and a holy nation. The priestly imagery is significant because Israel’s calling was never exhausted by its own religious preservation. Israel was to embody Yahweh’s character among the nations, mediating knowledge of the true God through its worship, justice, covenant loyalty, and communal practices.

The theme of divine dwelling accompanies this vocation. Yahweh commands Israel to build a sanctuary so that he might dwell among them (Exod 25:8). Jeremiah anticipates a renewed covenant in which God’s instruction is written upon the hearts of his people (Jer 31:31–34). John’s Gospel identifies Jesus as the Word who became flesh and dwelt among humanity (John 1:14), employing the verb skēnoō (σκηνόω), which evokes the language of dwelling or tabernacling. Finally, Revelation 21:3 announces the consummation of this trajectory: God’s dwelling is with humanity.

The goal is not merely that people receive correct information about God. God forms a covenant people who know him, reflect his character, and participate in his purposes. Discipleship therefore belongs to the theological structure of the entire biblical narrative. It concerns the recovery and fulfillment of humanity’s vocation as God’s image bearers through Jesus Christ, the definitive image of God (Col 1:15).

Ancient education was not ordinarily understood as the detached communication of information by an isolated lecturer. Mesopotamian scribal training involved memorization, copying, repetition, correction, and the progressive acquisition of practical competencies. Evidence from Old Babylonian scribal exercises indicates that education frequently operated through apprenticeship and household instruction, although more formal scribal settings also existed. Knowledge was transmitted through sustained relationships and repeated participation in the activities associated with a particular vocation.⁴

Israel’s covenant traditions likewise emphasize formation within ordinary life. Deuteronomy 6:4–9 instructs parents to teach Yahweh’s commandments to their children while sitting at home, traveling, lying down, and rising. The Hebrew šānan (שָׁנַן), used in Deuteronomy 6:7, communicates diligent instruction or impressing something upon another. The point is not that Israel should occasionally offer religious lectures to its children, but that covenant identity should permeate the daily rhythms of the household.

The prophetic narratives provide another analogy. The bĕnê hannĕbîʾîm (בְּנֵי הַנְּבִיאִים), or “sons of the prophets,” appear in communities associated with Samuel, Elijah, and Elisha (1 Sam 19:18–24; 2 Kgs 2:3–5; 4:38; 6:1). Although the expression “school of the prophets” may suggest more formal educational institutions than the texts warrant, the narratives reveal communities in which prophetic identity and vocation were cultivated through association with recognized prophetic leaders.

The succession of Elijah and Elisha is particularly illuminating. Elijah’s mantle, ʾadderet (אַדֶּרֶת), becomes a sign of Elisha’s calling (1 Kgs 19:19), while 2 Kings 2 describes the transmission of prophetic responsibility in the context of Elisha’s continuing allegiance to his master. Elisha requests a double portion of Elijah’s spirit, language that evokes the inheritance of a principal heir rather than simply a request to perform twice as many miracles. The mantle becomes a visible symbol of continuity, but the narrative ultimately emphasizes the presence and empowerment of Yahweh.

The theological relevance for pastoral ministry is considerable. Leadership was not simply the possession of specialized religious knowledge. It involved forming others who could continue the work after the mentor was gone. The measure of Elijah’s legacy was not how many people had heard him speak, but whether the prophetic vocation continued through Elisha.

The calling of the first disciples challenges some of the most comfortable assumptions of contemporary church life. In Mark 1:16–20, Jesus encounters Simon and Andrew while they are fishing and calls them to follow him. Mark records that they immediately leave their nets. Jesus then calls James and John, who leave their father Zebedee in the boat with the hired servants.

The Greek verb aphiēmi (ἀφίημι), used for their leaving, can convey releasing, abandoning, or leaving something behind. Mark employs the adverb euthys (εὐθύς), “immediately,” emphasizing the urgency of their response. Luke 5:11 strengthens the imagery, describing the disciples as leaving everything and following Jesus.

This is not merely a commitment to add religious instruction to an otherwise unchanged life. Jesus’ invitation reorganizes their vocational identity, daily schedule, social relationships, and future expectations. They are not signing up for a weekly Bible study. They are entering the life and mission of a rabbi whose calling will demand an entirely different ordering of their priorities.⁵

The language of discipleship in the Gospel tradition is important. The Greek mathētēs (μαθητής), “disciple,” identifies a learner or follower, while akoloutheō (ἀκολουθέω), “to follow,” frequently communicates the concrete act of accompanying Jesus and the deeper allegiance that accompaniment represents. The Hebrew term talmid (תַּלְמִיד), meaning student or disciple, provides a helpful Jewish conceptual parallel, although the detailed educational structures of later rabbinic Judaism should not simply be projected backward onto Jesus’ ministry.

Later rabbinic literature offers evidence of master-disciple relationships involving close association, observation, and the imitation of a teacher’s conduct. These materials illuminate broader Jewish traditions of learning but were compiled after the lifetime of Jesus and must be used with historical caution. The Gospel narratives themselves, however, offer sufficient evidence to establish that Jesus’ discipleship involved sustained personal participation rather than periodic attendance at formal instruction.⁶

The distinction becomes especially significant in Mark 3:13–15. Jesus appoints the Twelve so that they might be with him, hina ōsin met’ autou (ἵνα ὦσιν μετ’ αὐτοῦ), and so that he might send them out, hina apostellē autous (ἵνα ἀποστέλλῃ αὐτούς). Presence precedes mission. Their formation takes place through proximity to Jesus before they are commissioned to represent him publicly.

This raises a challenging comparison with contemporary theological education. A residential seminary or intentional discipleship community may, in some respects, resemble the immersive learning environment of the Gospel narratives more closely than a congregation organized almost exclusively around weekly attendance. Students study Scripture, share life, wrestle with theological questions, receive correction, and prepare for a vocation that reshapes their priorities.

Yet even seminary education can reproduce the very problem under consideration when it becomes primarily the accumulation of academic credits, detached from spiritual mentorship, communal life, and actual ministry practice. The greater challenge is not to turn every Christian into a full-time seminary student. It is to recover the seriousness of Jesus’ call to discipleship within the ordinary circumstances of Christian life.

Jesus did not explicitly require every follower to abandon their occupation. Some continued to maintain households, support his ministry, and serve within existing social relationships (Luke 8:1–3; 19:1–10). Peter himself appears fishing again in John 21. Therefore, the command to leave the nets should not be universalized into a prohibition against ordinary employment. Nevertheless, the underlying demand remains uncompromising: no occupation, possession, family obligation, or former identity may retain ultimate authority over the call of Jesus. Luke 9:57–62 and 14:25–33 make this especially clear. Following Jesus requires a willingness to relinquish competing allegiances. His teaching is not framed as a convenient religious supplement to an otherwise autonomous existence.

This also illuminates Jesus’ invitation in Matthew 11:28–30. He invites the weary to take his zygos (ζυγός), or yoke, upon themselves and learn from him: mathete ap’ emou (μάθετε ἀπ’ ἐμοῦ). The term zygos could signify a literal yoke, but it also functions metaphorically for obligation or submission to instruction. Jewish wisdom traditions offer important parallels, including Sirach 51:26, which invites learners to place their necks under the yoke of wisdom.

Jesus’ yoke is described as chrēstos (χρηστός), kind or well-suited, and his burden as elaphron (ἐλαφρόν), light. This does not mean discipleship requires little commitment. Matthew’s Gospel contains demanding teachings about self-denial, faithfulness, and costly allegiance. The distinction is that Jesus offers a form of discipleship grounded in his own character, authority, and provision of rest. The yoke is gracious, but the allegiance is comprehensive. Jesus does not invite disciples to attend his teaching occasionally while retaining their former way of life as the governing framework of their existence. He invites them to learn an entirely new way of being human.

Jesus’ methods of instruction reveal a remarkable integration of theological exposition and lived experience. His teaching was neither an uninterrupted lecture nor an unstructured series of religious encounters. The Gospel narratives suggest deliberate development in the understanding, character, and participation of his disciples. They observe Jesus, receive instruction, engage in ministry, misunderstand his intentions, experience correction, and are repeatedly brought back to the central realities of the kingdom.

Mark 4 provides an example of his use of parables. The Greek parabolē (παραβολή) refers broadly to a comparison, illustration, or figurative saying and shares conceptual territory with the Hebrew māšāl (מָשָׁל). Jesus employs familiar agricultural imagery to communicate the character and reception of the kingdom. Yet the parables do more than make complex theological concepts accessible. Mark 4:10–12 presents a tension between revelation and concealment, emphasizing that the hearer’s response is itself part of the narrative. Jesus subsequently explains the parables to his disciples (4:33–34), showing that public proclamation and more intimate theological instruction were complementary rather than competing practices.⁷

In Luke 10:25–37, Jesus demonstrates another form of pedagogical engagement. A legal expert asks what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus directs him back to Scripture, asking, Pōs anaginōskeis? (πῶς ἀναγινώσκεις), “How do you read?” The question is not merely whether the man possesses biblical information but how he understands and interprets it. After the lawyer correctly identifies love for God and neighbor as central to the law, Jesus tells the parable of the Samaritan.

The rhetorical movement is significant. The lawyer initially seeks to establish the boundaries of his obligation by asking who qualifies as his neighbor. Jesus reverses the question, identifying the one who acted as a neighbor through mercy. The concluding imperative, poreuou kai sy poiei homoiōs (πορεύου καὶ σὺ ποίει ὁμοίως), directs the hearer toward action: go and do likewise. The distinction between knowing the law and embodying its intent becomes the central pedagogical achievement of the exchange.⁸

John 4 illustrates another dimension of Jesus’ method. In his encounter with the Samaritan woman, Jesus engages questions of social identity, religious tradition, worship, and messianic expectation. The conversation develops through a series of responses and misunderstandings, allowing the woman’s assumptions to emerge before Jesus redirects her toward a more comprehensive understanding of worship. The encounter subsequently becomes the occasion for communal testimony, as others from the town come to hear Jesus for themselves (John 4:39–42). Teaching moves from conversation to revelation and then toward the participation of a wider community.

Jesus also teaches through embodied demonstration. In John 13:1–17, he washes the feet of his disciples and then explains the significance of his actions. The Greek hypodeigma (ὑπόδειγμα), used in John 13:15, identifies his action as an example or pattern. The disciples are not merely instructed to value humility. They encounter humility practiced by the one they recognize as Lord and Teacher, and they are called to imitate what they have witnessed.

Equally important is the way Jesus permits his disciples to participate in ministry before they fully understand it. Mark 6:7–13 describes the Twelve being sent out with authority to proclaim repentance and confront unclean spirits. When they return, they report what they have done and taught (Mark 6:30). The pattern resembles supervised participation more than conventional lecture-based instruction.

Even their failures become occasions for formation. The disciples repeatedly misunderstand Jesus’ identity, the meaning of his mission, and the character of greatness within the kingdom (Mark 8:14–21; 9:33–37; 10:35–45). Rather than abandoning them, Jesus revisits these themes through further teaching, correction, and demonstration.

This recurring pattern offers an important challenge to contemporary preaching. How often do pastors revisit a theological subject because the congregation has not yet learned to embody it? How frequently do leaders invite people into actual ministry, observe their development, and provide personal correction? Jesus’ teaching was repetitive not because he lacked additional material, but because the formation of disciples required more than a single encounter with truth.

The encounter on the road to Emmaus (Luke 24:13–35) provides one of the most compelling narratives of Jesus’ pedagogical approach. It also illustrates why correct information alone is insufficient for faithful biblical interpretation. The two disciples possess considerable information about Jesus. They know of his prophetic ministry, his crucifixion, the discovery of the empty tomb, and the reports of angelic witnesses. Yet they interpret these events through disappointed expectations concerning Israel’s redemption. Their confession in Luke 24:21, hēmeis de ēlpizomen (ἡμεῖς δὲ ἠλπίζομεν), “but we had hoped,” reveals the tension between their expectations and what has occurred.

Jesus begins with questions, allowing the disciples to articulate their understanding. He then challenges their failure to comprehend the prophetic witness and interprets the Scriptures concerning the Messiah’s suffering and glory (Luke 24:25–27). Luke uses the verb diermēneuō (διερμηνεύω), meaning to interpret or explain, to describe Jesus’ exposition of Moses and the Prophets. The significance is not simply that Jesus supplies additional proof texts. He reconstructs their understanding of Israel’s story around the necessity of the Messiah’s suffering and vindication. Their problem is hermeneutical. They possess biblical expectations, but those expectations have not adequately accounted for the shape of God’s redemptive purposes.

Recognition occurs when Jesus takes bread, blesses it, breaks it, and gives it to them (Luke 24:30–31). The narrative deliberately brings together scriptural exposition, shared hospitality, and recognition of the risen Lord. The breaking of bread recalls earlier Lukan meal scenes, particularly the feeding narrative and the Last Supper, without requiring the conclusion that Luke is describing a formal Eucharistic service. The disciples subsequently return to Jerusalem and bear witness to their encounter. Their explanation of Scripture has become inseparable from recognition, renewed hope, and communal testimony.

For homiletics, Emmaus is especially instructive because Jesus does not merely deliver a theological lecture to disappointed followers. He walks with them, listens to their confusion, engages their assumptions, interprets Scripture, shares a meal, and brings them into a renewed recognition of the Messiah. The primary theological claim remains the revelation of the risen Christ, but the narrative also demonstrates that biblical understanding often develops within relationships and experiences that extend beyond formal instruction.

A sermon may faithfully interpret the Scriptures, but discipleship asks what happens when the sermon concludes. Who walks with the people who remain confused? Who helps them reconsider assumptions that have shaped their theology for decades? Who sits with them in their grief, answers their questions, and helps them recognize the presence of Christ within their circumstances?

The preacher who understands Emmaus should not only aspire to explain Scripture with clarity but also cultivate a ministry where people are accompanied through the difficult process of learning to understand and inhabit the biblical story.⁹

If the purpose of pastoral ministry is the formation of disciples, then sermon preparation should be connected to a more intentional understanding of congregational development. Most pastors understandably plan their preaching in terms of individual messages or short sermon series. A biblical book may occupy several months, followed by topical series addressing marriage, prayer, spiritual disciplines, or the life of Jesus. While there is considerable value in these approaches, they can become disconnected from a larger vision of what a congregation needs to learn and practice over time.

Educational theory offers a helpful framework through the concepts of scope and sequence. Scope concerns the breadth of material to be addressed, while sequence considers the order and recurrence through which learning develops. These concepts should not turn the local church into a conventional classroom or impose an artificial timetable upon spiritual growth. They can, however, help pastors consider whether their teaching ministries are intentionally forming a mature community or simply producing a succession of individual sermons.

A pastor might begin by asking what a healthy congregation should understand and embody after three, five, or ten years of shared life. Such planning would consider the biblical narrative, the character of God, the Trinity, creation and image bearing, covenant, the kingdom, the person and work of Christ, the Holy Spirit, the church, reconciliation, spiritual formation, justice, suffering, prayer, mission, and the hope of renewed creation. The goal would not be to create a checklist of doctrines to be completed once, but to establish a framework of theological formation that is intentionally revisited and deepened.

The doctrine of the Trinity provides an illustrative example. A church might devote an entire sermon series to the biblical foundations and historical development of Trinitarian theology. Yet the subject should not disappear for the following decade simply because the series has been completed. The Trinity should continually inform teaching about prayer, worship, creation, salvation, Christian community, baptism, and the ministry of the Holy Spirit. Congregants encounter the doctrine repeatedly within different biblical and practical contexts, gradually developing a more integrated theological understanding.

This approach reflects the importance of repetition in the ministry of Jesus. The disciples encountered recurring themes of servanthood, kingdom greatness, faith, prayer, and the necessity of the cross. Their understanding developed over time as Jesus returned to these subjects in new circumstances.

For pastoral planning, I would recommend organizing a congregational teaching map around several recurring fields of formation rather than a rigid sequence of isolated courses.

Illustrative rhythms for a congregation, not a mandatory curriculum or prescribed biblical schedule

Area of formationSuggested recurrence
Biblical narrative and hermeneuticsContinuous exposition, with dedicated interpretive training annually
God’s character and the TrinityRegular reinforcement, with substantial treatment every 2–3 years
Jesus, covenant, kingdom, and atonementIntegrated throughout the year, with periodic focused series
Holy Spirit, spiritual gifts, and discernmentAnnual attention and recurring practical engagement
Spiritual practices, prayer, and worshipContinuous practice, with seasonal teaching and mentoring
Marriage, family, friendship, and reconciliationRegular relational formation, with periodic focused teaching
Justice, generosity, vocation, and public witnessIntegrated into exposition and revisited through service opportunities
Suffering, lament, death, and resurrection hopeRegular pastoral teaching alongside care for actual suffering
Mission, evangelism, and discipleshipContinuous participation, with annual equipping and assessment
Leadership development and mentoringOngoing apprenticeship with periodic evaluation

The purpose of such a map is not to displace expository preaching or force biblical passages into a predetermined topical system. Rather, it encourages pastors to recognize the cumulative theological and formational effect of their teaching over the life of a congregation. A pastor might discover, for example, that the church regularly addresses personal morality while rarely teaching the biblical story of covenant, kingdom, and new creation. Another congregation might possess extensive doctrinal knowledge while giving comparatively little attention to reconciliation, hospitality, or the care of vulnerable people.

A congregational teaching map makes these imbalances visible. It also helps pastors select sermon series with greater theological and pastoral intentionality.

The selection of a sermon series should therefore involve several considerations: What does the biblical text itself demand? What theological subjects have been neglected? What questions or misunderstandings are emerging within the congregation? What practices require renewed attention? Where is the Spirit directing the community toward repentance, growth, or mission? How does the proposed series contribute to the church’s larger understanding of Scripture?

These questions do not guarantee an ideal preaching calendar, but they provide a more intentional alternative to selecting messages primarily because a topic seems interesting, timely, or likely to attract an audience.

The most important implication of an intentional teaching strategy is that preaching cannot be expected to accomplish the entire task of discipleship by itself. A sermon may introduce, clarify, challenge, and reinforce biblical truth, but the formation of Christian character ordinarily requires sustained participation within a community of faith.

The New Testament provides several complementary expressions of this ministry. Acts 2:42–47 integrates teaching with fellowship, prayer, shared meals, and generosity. Acts 20:20 describes Paul’s ministry as both public and house-to-house. Colossians 3:16 envisions believers teaching and admonishing one another, while Ephesians 4:11–16 identifies the purpose of ministry leadership as equipping the saints for the work of ministry and the growth of the whole body.

In Ephesians 4:12, the term katartismos (καταρτισμός), often translated “equipping,” points toward preparing God’s people for their responsibilities. The pastor is not simply the person who performs religious ministry on behalf of the congregation. Pastoral leadership helps others become capable participants in the life and mission of the church.

A congregation committed to this understanding will recognize the value of multiple environments of formation. Sunday preaching provides corporate proclamation and a common theological framework. Small groups allow believers to wrestle with biblical teaching, pray together, confess struggles, and practice mutual encouragement. Personal mentorship provides opportunities for mature disciples to accompany those who are developing in faith. Deeper Bible-study gatherings enable the exploration of historical context, biblical languages, theological questions, and matters that cannot be adequately addressed within a typical sermon. Retreats, conferences, and study intensives create opportunities for concentrated reflection and fellowship. Shared meals, hospitality, service projects, pastoral counseling, and opportunities to participate in ministry provide contexts in which theological convictions are tested and embodied.

These environments should not be treated as unrelated programs competing for attention. They are complementary expressions of a common discipleship vocation. A sermon on forgiveness might be followed by small-group conversations about reconciliation, pastoral support for those navigating painful relationships, and practical opportunities to cultivate peacemaking. A series on the kingdom of God might connect with deeper biblical studies on covenant and eschatology, opportunities for local service, and mentoring relationships that help believers discern their own vocation.

The objective is not to keep congregants perpetually occupied with religious activities. Excessive programming can undermine the ordinary household, vocational, and relational settings in which discipleship must also take place. Rather, the objective is to provide meaningful environments in which biblical teaching becomes practiced wisdom.

The pastor, then, must think beyond the sermon calendar toward the entire formative life of the community. The question is no longer simply what will be preached on Sunday, but how the church will help people understand, practice, and pass on what is being taught.

Another practice worthy of recovery is the communal dimension of sermon preparation. The contemporary pastor often develops messages in relative isolation, moving from personal study to manuscript preparation and finally to public delivery. While solitude and careful exegesis are indispensable, the New Testament’s vision of the church as a body possessing diverse gifts challenges the assumption that one individual necessarily possesses every insight required for faithful and pastorally effective proclamation.

Ephesians 4:11–16, 1 Corinthians 12–14, and Colossians 3:16 portray a community in which teaching, wisdom, discernment, encouragement, and mutual edification extend beyond a single leader. This does not eliminate the responsibility of pastors and teachers to interpret Scripture faithfully. It does suggest that the congregation’s gifts can meaningfully contribute to the preparation and application of biblical teaching.

As discussed in our earlier Expedition 44 article, The Message, the Method, and the Messenger, a ministry think tank offers one practical expression of this principle.¹⁰

A pastor might gather a small group of trusted participants two or three weeks before a planned sermon or series. The group could include other pastors, teachers, elders, individuals with theological training, counselors, younger and older believers, and people whose life experiences offer perspectives that the primary preacher may not possess.

The discussion would begin with the biblical text rather than a predetermined message. Participants might examine the literary setting, historical context, difficult interpretive questions, competing theological perspectives, and possible applications. They might identify where a proposed sermon risks oversimplification, where an illustration may unintentionally alienate or harm listeners, or where a familiar passage has been interpreted through assumptions that deserve further scrutiny.

For example, a series addressing marriage and covenant might benefit from the perspectives of married and single believers, widows, counselors, and those who have experienced relational trauma. A message concerning poverty or generosity could be enriched by people who understand economic hardship firsthand. A sermon addressing the role of women in ministry should not be developed without serious engagement with women who have studied, practiced, and reflected upon their calling.

Such conversations can also reveal the questions a congregation is actually asking. The pastor may enter preparation intending to answer one theological problem only to discover that the text raises a more pressing question for the community.

The think tank should not become a committee that determines biblical truth through majority opinion. Sound exegesis remains essential, and the primary preacher retains responsibility for the message. Nor should pastoral confidentiality be sacrificed in the pursuit of relevant illustrations. Rather, the process encourages humility, collaboration, and the recognition that God has distributed gifts throughout the body.

This practice also models discipleship. Participants are not simply supplying material for a better sermon; they are learning to handle Scripture responsibly, listen across differing perspectives, and participate in theological discernment. Sermon preparation itself becomes an environment of formation.

A mature preaching ministry should therefore aspire to do more than produce fifty excellent sermons each year. It should increasingly develop people capable of studying Scripture, discerning truth, mentoring others, and participating in the ongoing work of the kingdom.

Perhaps one of the most important recoveries needed in contemporary ministry is a renewed understanding of what it means to be a pastor. The Greek poimēn (ποιμήν), translated “shepherd,” is not primarily a title for a professional religious communicator. It describes one entrusted with the care, guidance, protection, and nurture of a flock. In John 21:15–17, Jesus charges Peter to feed and tend his sheep. In Acts 20:28, Paul instructs the Ephesian elders to shepherd the church of God, while 1 Peter 5:2–3 calls elders to exercise oversight willingly, not as domineering authorities, but as examples to the flock. These passages present pastoral ministry as a responsibility for people, not merely for the delivery of messages.

There is something deeply challenging about the distance that can develop between this biblical vocation and contemporary pastoral practice. A minister may become extraordinarily skilled at sermon preparation, public communication, organizational leadership, and theological explanation while remaining largely absent from the ordinary lives of the people entrusted to that ministry. Yet Jesus’ example consistently brings leadership back into relationship. He knew his disciples, shared their experiences, recognized their weaknesses, challenged their misplaced ambitions, and entrusted them with responsibilities they were still learning to carry. His disciples did not simply learn his teachings; they learned his way of life.

Recovering this model does not mean every pastor must personally mentor every congregant or abandon the necessary responsibilities of public proclamation. The New Testament’s emphasis upon a plurality of leaders, shared gifts, and mutual ministry provides a healthier vision than concentrating all spiritual formation in one individual. Nevertheless, the pastor must help establish and personally embody a culture of discipleship. Sermons, small groups, shared meals, mentoring relationships, theological studies, pastoral conversations, and opportunities for ministry should not function as disconnected programs. They should belong to a coherent vision of helping people grow into the likeness of Christ.

Ultimately, the question facing aspiring preachers is not simply whether they can hold the attention of a congregation for thirty minutes. It is whether they are willing to give themselves to the long, patient, frequently inconvenient work of forming disciples. Jesus invited fishermen to leave their nets, not to become spectators of his ministry, but to walk with him, learn his ways, and eventually participate in the same mission. His invitation remains profoundly demanding. The church does not need to abandon preaching; it needs to recover the larger life of discipleship within which preaching belongs. We need shepherds who open the Scriptures and open their homes, who teach from the platform and walk alongside people in their struggles, who proclaim the kingdom and demonstrate its character, and who measure the fruitfulness of their leadership not merely by those who gather to hear them but by those who are learning to follow Jesus and teach others to do the same. The church was never intended to become an audience gathered around a religious personality. It was called to become a people walking in the Way of Jesus. And perhaps the greatest legacy of any pastor is not the sermons remembered after their ministry is finished, but the disciples who continue walking in that Way long after the pastor is gone.

Endnotes

1. Eckhard J. Schnabel, Acts, ZECNT (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2012), commentary on Acts 2:42–47; Wayne A. Meeks, The First Urban Christians: The Social World of the Apostle Paul, 2nd ed. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003). See also Larry W. Hurtado, At the Origins of Christian Worship: The Context and Character of Earliest Christian Devotion (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999).

2. John R. W. Stott, Between Two Worlds: The Challenge of Preaching Today (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1982); Thomas G. Long, The Witness of Preaching, 3rd ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2016). Both works underscore the pastoral and theological significance of proclamation, although the critique of contemporary sermon-centered ministry developed here is the present article’s argument.

3. J. Richard Middleton, The Liberating Image: The Imago Dei in Genesis 1 (Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2005); John H. Walton, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2009).

4. Niek Veldhuis, Religion, Literature, and Scholarship: The Sumerian Composition Nanše and the Birds, CM 22 (Leiden: Brill, 2004); Christopher A. Rollston, Writing and Literacy in the World of Ancient Israel: Epigraphic Evidence from the Iron Age, ABS 11 (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2010). For prophetic associations, see Joseph Blenkinsopp, A History of Prophecy in Israel, rev. and enl. ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1996).

5. R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark: A Commentary on the Greek Text, NIGTC (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002), commentary on Mark 1:16–20 and 3:13–19; Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, AB 27 (New York: Doubleday, 2000).

6. Catherine Hezser, The Social Structure of the Rabbinic Movement in Roman Palestine, TSAJ 66 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1997); Shmuel Safrai, “Education and the Study of the Torah,” in The Jewish People in the First Century, ed. S. Safrai and M. Stern, CRINT 1.2 (Assen: Van Gorcum, 1976), 945–70. Later rabbinic evidence should be distinguished from direct first-century documentation.

7. Klyne R. Snodgrass, Stories with Intent: A Comprehensive Guide to the Parables of Jesus, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2018); France, Gospel of Mark, commentary on Mark 4.

8. Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke, NICNT (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997), commentary on Luke 10:25–37; Expedition 44, “Who Is My Neighbor?,” September 2, 2026. For John 4 and 13, see Marianne Meye Thompson, John: A Commentary, NTL (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2015).

9. François Bovon, Luke 3: A Commentary on the Gospel of Luke 19:28–24:53, Hermeneia (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2012), commentary on Luke 24:13–35; N. T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God, Christian Origins and the Question of God 3 (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2003). The interpretation here emphasizes the movement from mistaken expectation to scriptural understanding, recognition, and renewed witness. I could not independently locate the more recent X44 article specifically devoted to Emmaus, so I have not attributed unverified arguments to it.

10. Expedition 44, “The Message, the Method, and the Messenger,” June 2, 2026, written with Dr. Steve Cassell, especially the section titled “THINKTANK.”

11. Frank Thielman, Ephesians, BECNT (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2010), commentary on Eph 4:11–16; David G. Peterson, The Acts of the Apostles, PNTC (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2009), commentary on Acts 20:17–38; Karen H. Jobes, 1 Peter, BECNT (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2005), commentary on 1 Pet 5:1–4.

  1. Leaving the nets: How does the calling of the Twelve challenge contemporary models of church membership and the assumptions we make about the commitment involved in following Jesus?
  2. The pastor’s vocation: If preaching is one dimension of shepherding, what should actually occupy a pastor’s time throughout the week? How would this affect the way churches evaluate pastoral success?
  3. Long-term formation: If you were responsible for shepherding the same congregation for ten years, what biblical truths, theological disciplines, and kingdom practices would you want people to have encountered repeatedly?
  4. Shared preparation: How might a sermon think tank strengthen both the biblical integrity of a message and the discipleship of those involved in preparing it?

Ask students to imagine that they have accepted responsibility for a congregation of seventy-five people and expect to pastor them for the next five years. Rather than writing a sermon series, have them design a pastoral discipleship philosophy. What will they teach repeatedly? How will they mentor emerging leaders? Where will serious biblical study happen? How will people practice what they are learning? What role will homes, meals, small groups, and ministry participation play? Finally, what will they do personally to remain accessible as shepherds rather than functioning only as weekly speakers?

The exercise should close with one question: If Jesus visited your congregation for six months, would he recognize your approach to making disciples as something resembling his own?

Design a Five-Year Congregational Discipleship and Teaching Map

Imagine you are pastoring a congregation for the next five years. What theological and doctrinal foundations do you want your people to understand, and how will you intentionally develop and reinforce those teachings over time? Consider which subjects deserve an entire sermon series, which need regular revisiting, and how you will account for the reality that many congregants do not attend consistently.

Your plan should extend well beyond Sunday preaching. How will you incorporate weekly Bible studies, small groups, mentoring, conferences, and other opportunities for discipleship? How will you provide theological direction and oversight for these ministries, particularly when others are leading them?

The goal is not simply to plan five years of sermons, but to develop an intentional strategy for forming mature disciples who understand Scripture, live out their faith, and disciple others.

EXPEDITION 44 | BIBLICAL THEOLOGY & ANCIENT NEAR EASTERN STUDIES

PANTOKRATŌR: The God Who Rules the Cosmic Order

Rediscovering the Ancient Near Eastern World Behind “God Almighty”

Beyond the English Word “Almighty”

When modern Christians hear the title “God Almighty,” they typically imagine a God possessing unlimited power, capable of doing anything at any moment. Although divine omnipotence is an important theological consideration, this understanding can obscure the ancient worldview behind the biblical language. The Greek title Pantokratōr (παντοκράτωρ), appearing nine times in Revelation and once elsewhere in the New Testament (2 Cor 6:18), carries a rich inheritance from the Hebrew Scriptures, the Septuagint, and the cosmic kingship traditions of the ancient Near East (ANE). Derived from pas (“all”) and kratos (“might,” “dominion,” or “power”), the term identifies God as the sovereign ruler over all things. Yet the biblical emphasis is not merely on God’s ability to exercise power. It concerns his rightful authority over the entire created order, including the nations, heavenly beings, and powers that presume to challenge his reign.¹

YHWH Ṣĕbāʾôt: The Lord of Heaven’s Armies

One of the most significant and often overlooked connections is that Pantokratōr frequently appears in the Septuagint as a rendering of the Hebrew title YHWH Ṣĕbāʾôt (יְהוָה צְבָאוֹת), commonly translated “LORD of Hosts.” The Hebrew ṣābāʾ denotes an army, assembled force, or organized host. While this language can describe earthly armies, it also refers to the heavenly host surrounding God’s throne (1 Kgs 22:19; Ps 103:20–21). Consequently, “Lord of Hosts” is not simply another way of saying that God is powerful. It is a royal designation depicting YHWH as the supreme commander of the heavenly armies and sovereign over the cosmic realm.²

An intriguing connection emerges in Isaiah 6:3, where the seraphim proclaim, “Holy, holy, holy is YHWH of Hosts; the whole earth is full of his glory.” Revelation 4:8 echoes this heavenly liturgy but identifies God as Kyrios ho Theos ho Pantokratōr (“Lord God Almighty”). John’s vision draws upon Isaiah’s throne-room imagery while employing the Greek vocabulary of universal sovereignty. The earthly prophet is permitted to witness the heavenly court, where divine kingship is already established regardless of the political instability unfolding below.

El Shaddai: Was “Almighty” the Original Meaning?

Another fascinating linguistic connection concerns El Shaddai (אֵל שַׁדַּי), traditionally translated “God Almighty.” In Genesis 17:1, God introduces himself to Abraham using this designation, but the original meaning of Shaddai remains uncertain. Some scholars have investigated connections with Akkadian šadû, meaning “mountain,” suggesting a possible ancient association with a mountain deity or divine mountain imagery. Others propose connections with sufficiency, strength, or fertility. None of these explanations has achieved scholarly consensus.

Interestingly, the Septuagint does not consistently translate El Shaddai with Pantokratōr. The Greek association becomes especially prominent in Job, where Shaddai frequently appears as Pantokratōr. This suggests that the familiar translation “Almighty” reflects an important history of interpretation rather than an unquestionable original Hebrew etymology. The distinction matters because ancient divine titles often communicated identity, relationship, and royal authority before later theological traditions expressed them through abstract philosophical categories.³

The Divine Council: God’s Authority over the Elohim

The ANE background becomes particularly illuminating when we encounter the divine council. Ugaritic texts discovered at Ras Shamra describe a heavenly assembly associated with El, the senior deity of the Canaanite pantheon. Biblical authors employ comparable imagery while presenting YHWH’s sovereignty within their own developing theological framework. Psalm 82:1 declares that Elohim stands in the ʿadat El (עֲדַת־אֵל), the divine assembly, judging among the elohim. The vocabulary closely resembles West Semitic descriptions of heavenly councils. Similarly, Psalm 89:5–7 depicts an assembly of holy ones surrounding YHWH, while 1 Kings 22:19 portrays the heavenly host standing on either side of his throne.⁴

These passages are sometimes flattened into poetic descriptions of God’s greatness. Yet their ANE setting suggests something more substantial: the biblical writers envisioned a populated heavenly realm operating under divine authority. Precisely how individual council passages reflect the historical development of Israelite monotheism remains debated. Nevertheless, the broader literary connection is unmistakable. When Revelation calls God Pantokratōr, its language resonates with this ancient portrayal of supreme kingship. God is not struggling to secure a position within the heavenly hierarchy; the biblical narrative presents his authority as unrivaled.

An additional connection appears in Deuteronomy 32:8–9. While the Masoretic Text refers to the “sons of Israel,” the Dead Sea Scrolls preserve the reading “sons of God,” and Greek witnesses refer to divine sons or angels. This older textual tradition places the division of the nations within a heavenly framework, with Israel identified as YHWH’s particular inheritance. The passage does not directly employ Pantokratōr, but it contributes to the worldview inherited by later Jewish apocalyptic literature: the nations and their spiritual powers remain subject to the ultimate authority of God.⁵

Cosmic Warfare: When the King Confronts Chaos

Within Mesopotamian and West Semitic literature, divine kingship was frequently associated with victory over chaos. The Ugaritic Baal Cycle portrays Baal’s conflict with Yamm, the personification of the sea, within a larger struggle over cosmic kingship. Biblical authors likewise employ imagery of waters, sea monsters, and defeated enemies to describe YHWH’s sovereignty (Ps 74:12–17; 89:9–10; Isa 27:1). The Hebrew term tannîn (תַּנִּין), referring to a great serpent or sea creature, participates in this symbolic world, as does Leviathan, the twisting serpent. These images were not necessarily intended as straightforward descriptions of zoological creatures. They belonged to a larger literary vocabulary depicting disorder, rebellion, and forces hostile to God’s created order.⁶

Revelation draws heavily upon this imagery. The dragon, the beast arising from the sea, and Babylon’s imperial arrogance represent hostile powers seeking dominion that does not rightfully belong to them. Against these claims stands Pantokratōr, the sovereign whose kingship will ultimately be vindicated. The biblical drama is therefore not a contest between equally powerful divine rivals but a revelation of the Creator’s authority over powers that have corrupted the world.

The Lamb and the Throne: A Surprising Reversal of Ancient Kingship

Perhaps the most striking feature of Revelation is how John transforms the imagery of ANE conquest. In Revelation 5, John hears of the Lion of Judah who has conquered, but when he turns, he sees a Lamb standing as though slain. The expected royal conqueror is revealed through the imagery of sacrificial death. This is not the abandonment of divine kingship but its surprising revelation through Jesus.

The connection becomes even more compelling in Revelation 19:6, where the heavenly multitude announces that the Lord God Pantokratōr reigns. The proclamation occurs within a narrative celebrating the downfall of Babylon and anticipating the marriage supper of the Lamb. Divine victory is inseparable from the faithfulness of Jesus and the vindication of those who belong to him. Unlike ANE imperial ideologies that frequently legitimized domination through overwhelming military strength, Revelation presents a kingdom whose victory is disclosed through the slain and risen Messiah. The power of God is not absent from the cross; it is revealed through the cross.⁷

One final detail is worth considering. In Revelation 21:22, John declares that the New Jerusalem contains no temple because the Lord God Pantokratōr and the Lamb are its temple. In the ANE, temples functioned as earthly representations of divine dwelling and cosmic order. Revelation’s concluding vision moves beyond a sacred building altogether. God’s presence fills the renewed creation. The cosmic King no longer needs a localized sanctuary because heaven and earth have become the dwelling place of God with humanity.

Conclusion: The God Who Holds All Things Together

Recovering the ANE background of Pantokratōr changes how we hear this remarkable title. God is not merely the strongest being in a universe filled with competing powers. He is the rightful King of creation, Lord of the heavenly hosts, judge of rebellious authorities, and the One who will restore what sin, death, and corruption have disordered. Yet perhaps the most encouraging revelation is that this sovereign King has made himself known through Jesus, the Lamb who was slain.

For those walking through suffering, uncertainty, or the apparent triumph of evil, Pantokratōr offers something deeper than the reassurance that God possesses unlimited strength. It reminds us that the powers presently shaping our circumstances do not possess ultimate authority. The Lamb has overcome, and the kingdom is being restored. Our calling is not to secure God’s victory through coercion or fear, but to live faithfully beneath his reign, embodying the love, justice, mercy, and covenant faithfulness revealed in Jesus.

The One who rules the heavenly hosts is also the One who dwells among his people. And the kingdom he is restoring is marked not merely by the defeat of evil, but by the renewal of all things.

Endnotes

1. Walter Bauer, Frederick William Danker, William F. Arndt, and F. Wilbur Gingrich, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature, 3rd ed. (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000), s.v. “παντοκράτωρ”; Rev 1:8; 4:8; 11:17; 15:3; 16:7, 14; 19:6, 15; 21:22; 2 Cor 6:18.

2. Ludwig Koehler, Walter Baumgartner, and Johann Jakob Stamm, The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament, trans. and ed. M. E. J. Richardson, 2 vols. (Leiden: Brill, 2001), s.v. “צבא”; Isa 6:3; 1 Kgs 22:19; Ps 103:20–21.

3. David J. A. Clines, Job 1–20, Word Biblical Commentary 17 (Dallas: Word, 1989); see also the discussion of Shaddai in “Preliminary Ideas on a Substratum Text of Job and the Depiction of Šaddāy”⁠ (2023). The proposed Akkadian connection remains disputed.

4. E. Theodore Mullen Jr., The Divine Council in Canaanite and Early Hebrew Literature, Harvard Semitic Monographs 24 (Chico, CA: Scholars Press, 1980); Mark S. Smith, The Origins of Biblical Monotheism: Israel’s Polytheistic Background and the Ugaritic Texts (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001). For a recent alternative account of Psalm 82, see Shane M. Thompson, “Local Manifestations of YHWH within El’s Divine Council: Psalm 82 in the Context of Israelite Religion,” Journal of Biblical Literature 143, no. 2 (2024): 245–63.

5. Emanuel Tov, “The Sons of Israel or God?—Deuteronomy 32:8,”⁠ TheTorah.com, 2023. The textual witnesses include 4QDeutʲ and differing Septuagint readings.

6. John Day, God’s Conflict with the Dragon and the Sea: Echoes of a Canaanite Myth in the Old Testament, University of Cambridge Oriental Publications 35 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1985); Frank Moore Cross, Canaanite Myth and Hebrew Epic: Essays in the History of the Religion of Israel (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1973).

7. Richard Bauckham, The Theology of the Book of Revelation, New Testament Theology (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1993); Michael J. Gorman, Reading Revelation Responsibly: Uncivil Worship and Witness: Following the Lamb into the New Creation (Eugene, OR: Cascade Books, 2011).

Comments Off on EXPEDITION 44 | BIBLICAL THEOLOGY & ANCIENT NEAR EASTERN STUDIES Posted in ADVENTURE

The Epic of Eden: Recovering the Story We Were Never Meant to Forget

A Review of Sandra L. Richter’s The Epic of Eden: A Christian Entry into the Old Testament, Second Edition (IVP Academic, 2026)

There are books that inform our theological understanding, and there are those rare works that fundamentally change the way we read Scripture. For me, Sandra Richter’s The Epic of Eden belongs firmly in the latter category. It remains one of my favorite books on the Old Testament, and I am genuinely excited to see this newly revised edition. At The King’s Commission School of Divinity, we have used Richter’s work since its original publication in 2008, and I have consistently recommended it to students, pastors, and anyone seeking a more historically grounded understanding of the biblical narrative. Few introductory works have accomplished what Richter has managed to do: introduce the ancient world of Israel with academic credibility while remaining remarkably accessible to readers without formal theological training.¹

The enduring strength of The Epic of Eden is its insistence that the Old Testament must be understood as an interconnected historical and theological narrative rather than an anthology of disconnected religious stories. Richter recognizes that many Christians are familiar with Abraham, Moses, David, and the prophets yet struggle to locate these figures within the broader development of Israel’s covenant history. Her well-known illustration of organizing the Old Testament closet provides more than an effective teaching device; it identifies a genuine hermeneutical problem. Without an understanding of chronology, geography, covenant, and the cultural world of ancient Israel, readers often interpret Scripture through assumptions foreign to its original setting. Richter’s approach provides a coherent framework through which these historical and theological relationships become intelligible.

Particularly valuable is Richter’s examination of ancient Israel’s social organization, including the patriarchal, patrilineal, and patrilocal structures that governed household identity and communal life. The Hebrew bêt ʾāb (בֵּית אָב), the father’s household, represented considerably more than what modern Western readers understand as the nuclear family. It functioned as a network of economic responsibilities, inherited identity, land stewardship, and kinship obligations. These structures provide essential background for understanding inheritance, marriage, widowhood, and the responsibilities associated with the gōʾēl (גֹּאֵל), or kinship redeemer. Richter’s discussion becomes especially helpful when considering the narratives of Ruth and Naomi, where redemption involves the preservation of family, inheritance, and communal belonging. This cultural framework also enriches our understanding of theological redemption, which cannot be adequately reduced to an abstract legal transaction detached from restoration, relationship, and covenant loyalty. Importantly, understanding Israel’s patriarchal social organization does not require treating every element of that organization as a timeless divine prescription. Richter’s historical methodology helps readers distinguish the cultural environment of biblical revelation from the theological claims communicated within it.

Equally significant is her treatment of covenant as an organizing principle of redemptive history. Richter situates the Hebrew bĕrît (בְּרִית) within the diplomatic and political traditions of the ancient Near East, including the relationship between suzerain-vassal treaties and Israel’s covenant traditions. Her discussion of the Sinai covenant is particularly useful because it challenges the persistent Christian assumption that Israel’s relationship with YHWH was fundamentally established through obedience to religious law. Within the Exodus narrative, divine deliverance precedes the covenant stipulations, making obedience the appropriate response to an already established relationship rather than the mechanism by which Israel earns divine acceptance. This observation has considerable implications for Christian discussions of law, grace, faithfulness, and salvation. Meredith Kline’s covenantal studies provide an important scholarly precedent for this approach, although questions concerning the historical development of treaty forms and their relationship to biblical covenant literature remain debated.²

Richter’s treatment of Eden and the New Jerusalem also deserves particular attention. By locating creation, sanctuary, divine presence, and new creation within a unified theological narrative, she demonstrates that the biblical story concerns more than individual salvation. The movement from Eden toward renewed creation reflects God’s continuing purpose to dwell with humanity and restore what has been fractured through human rebellion. Her treatment of tabernacle and temple traditions helps illuminate the relationship between sacred space and divine presence, while the culmination in Revelation 21–22 emphasizes restoration rather than the abandonment of creation. Here Richter’s work intersects meaningfully with John Walton’s exploration of ancient Near Eastern cosmology and sacred space. Walton’s The Lost World of Genesis One offers a more specialized and sometimes contested reconstruction of the conceptual world of Genesis, whereas Richter’s contribution lies in integrating related themes into an accessible canonical framework.³

Richter’s scholarship also invites productive comparison with John Goldingay, Christopher J. H. Wright, and N. T. Wright. Goldingay’s Old Testament Theology gives sustained attention to the distinctive theological voices of Israel’s Scriptures, frequently resisting the tendency to organize their diversity too quickly around later Christian categories.⁴ Richter is more explicitly concerned with constructing a coherent Christian reading of the biblical narrative, making her particularly effective as an introduction, though Goldingay provides a helpful reminder that the Old Testament must first be heard within its own historical and literary horizons. Christopher Wright, particularly in The Mission of God, develops the ethical and missional implications of Israel’s covenant identity, demonstrating how election, covenant faithfulness, and the Abrahamic promise are inseparable from God’s purposes for the nations.⁵ N. T. Wright extends this conversation into Second Temple Judaism, emphasizing how Jesus’ kingdom proclamation and messianic vocation emerge within Israel’s continuing story of exile, restoration, and covenant expectation.⁶ Together, these scholars illustrate the importance of understanding Scripture as a developing narrative without neglecting the historical particularity of its individual voices.

The second edition retains the book’s fundamental twelve-chapter structure while updating historical and anthropological material and refining its maps, charts, and language. Richter’s acknowledgments describe these revisions as measured improvements intended to serve a new generation of readers rather than a wholesale reconstruction of her original thesis. This continuity is welcome. The book’s lasting value resides in its ability to bring geography, history, cultural anthropology, and covenant theology together into a coherent educational experience. It remains an exceptional starting point for biblical studies and an indispensable resource for theological educators seeking to cultivate historically responsible interpretation.

For nearly two decades, The Epic of Eden has helped students recognize that understanding the biblical world is not an academic luxury but an essential part of responsible interpretation. Richter succeeds in making that conviction both compelling and accessible. I cannot recommend this new edition highly enough, particularly for those who have inherited a fragmented understanding of the Old Testament or have been taught to regard Israel’s Scriptures as little more than preliminary background to the New Testament.

Conclusive Reflections

What I love most about this book is that it helps us remember whose story we have been invited into. Scripture tells the story of a God who has remained faithful through humanity’s repeated failures, through wandering and rebellion, through exile and restoration. From Eden to Abraham, from Israel’s deliverance to the ministry of Jesus, we encounter a God who has never abandoned his purposes for creation or his desire to dwell among his people.

And there is something deeply encouraging about that, particularly when we recognize how often our own lives resemble the struggles of those ancient communities. We experience disappointment, fractured relationships, misplaced allegiances, and seasons when God’s promises seem distant. Yet the biblical story continually calls us back to his faithfulness. The God who delivered Israel remains concerned with the broken, the vulnerable, the displaced, and those longing for restoration.

My hope is that readers will come away from Richter’s book with more than an improved understanding of biblical chronology or covenant terminology. I hope they will begin to recognize that following Jesus means participating in the story of God’s kingdom, becoming people who embody his character through faithfulness, justice, reconciliation, compassion, and love. We study the ancient world not simply to understand what God was doing thousands of years ago, but to better discern how we are called to live today.

That is why The Epic of Eden continues to hold such an important place in my teaching and ministry. Richter helps us recover the world of Scripture so that we might better understand the way of Jesus. And the more deeply we understand that story, the more faithfully we can live within it.

InterVarsity Press – The Epic of Eden

Dr. Will Ryan Expedition 44 | The King’s Commission School of Divinity

Endnotes

1. Sandra L. Richter, The Epic of Eden: A Christian Entry into the Old Testament, 2nd ed. (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2026), chaps. 1–4.

2. Richter, Epic of Eden, chap. 5; Meredith G. Kline, Treaty of the Great King: The Covenant Structure of Deuteronomy: Studies and Commentary (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1963).

3. Richter, Epic of Eden, chaps. 6–7; John H. Walton, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2009).

4. John Goldingay, Old Testament Theology, vol. 1, Israel’s Gospel (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2003).

5. Christopher J. H. Wright, The Mission of God: Unlocking the Bible’s Grand Narrative (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2006).

6. N. T. Wright, Jesus and the Victory of God, Christian Origins and the Question of God 2 (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1996).

Comments Off on The Epic of Eden: Recovering the Story We Were Never Meant to Forget Posted in ADVENTURE