Paradise, the Intermediate State, and the Restoration of Heaven and Earth
The Christian understanding of heaven has been shaped as much by centuries of religious imagination as by the biblical text itself. Images of departed believers entering an ethereal world, inhabiting celestial mansions, or spending eternity in an exclusively spiritual existence have become so familiar that they are rarely questioned. Yet when the biblical narrative is examined within its ancient Near Eastern setting, its Second Temple Jewish development, and the eschatological expectations of the earliest followers of Jesus, a considerably different picture begins to emerge. The biblical hope is not ultimately the abandonment of the earth for heaven, but the restoration of creation and the complete reconciliation of heaven and earth under the reign of God. This raises several important questions. What happens to believers immediately following death? Is that experience the same as the final resurrection? Will we recognize one another? Will our memories, personalities, relationships, and creative capacities continue? And perhaps most importantly, what does Scripture actually reveal about the eternal future of humanity?
N. T. Wright has been particularly influential in recovering the distinction between what he calls life after death and life after life after death. The former describes the intermediate condition of believers who have died in Christ, while the latter concerns bodily resurrection and participation in the renewed creation. Wright’s distinction is not an innovation but an attempt to recover the Jewish and early Christian framework in which resurrection was understood as God’s ultimate victory over death, rather than simply the survival of an immortal soul. [1] This distinction provides an important starting point for understanding the biblical hope.
Heaven and Earth in the Ancient Near Eastern World
The ancient Near Eastern world generally understood reality as encompassing divine and human domains, although the precise relationship between these realms varied considerably among cultures. Mesopotamian, Egyptian, and Canaanite traditions associated divine presence with particular cosmic regions, sacred mountains, temples, and heavenly assemblies. The distinction between the divine and human realms was not necessarily understood as a division between the material and the immaterial in the later philosophical sense. Sacred space provided points of intersection between the divine world and the ordinary world of humanity.
Israel’s understanding of creation both participated in and challenged these cultural frameworks. Genesis 1 presents the heavens and the earth as the comprehensive work of one sovereign Creator, while Genesis 2–3 depicts Eden as the place where humanity enjoys direct communion with God. The garden is not merely a primitive agricultural setting. Its sacred geography, divine presence, precious materials, and imagery of life anticipate features later associated with Israel’s tabernacle and temple. The cherubim guarding Eden in Genesis 3:24 find conceptual parallels in the cherubim associated with the ark and sanctuary. The movement from Eden to tabernacle, temple, and ultimately the New Jerusalem forms a significant biblical-theological trajectory. [2]
The resulting theological picture is important. Humanity’s original vocation was not to escape material existence but to live faithfully within creation in the presence of God. The rupture introduced by human rebellion affected relationships between God and humanity, human beings and one another, and humanity and the created order. Consequently, the biblical account of redemption is not simply concerned with relocating human souls after death. It concerns the healing of those ruptured relationships and the restoration of creation to its intended purpose.
This helps explain why the final vision of Revelation is not humanity ascending into heaven but the New Jerusalem descending from heaven. Revelation 21:3 announces the dwelling of God with humanity, echoing covenant promises throughout Israel’s Scriptures. The direction of the imagery is deliberate: God’s presence fills the renewed creation. Heaven and earth, previously distinguished, are brought into complete harmony.
Sheol, Death, and the Development of Israel’s Resurrection Hope
The Hebrew Bible does not present a fully developed doctrine of heaven as the immediate destination of every righteous person at death. Instead, the earlier texts frequently speak of Sheol, the realm of the dead. The Hebrew term sheʾol refers broadly to the condition or domain of the departed and should not automatically be equated with the later Christian concept of hell. Passages such as Psalm 88:3–12, Job 14:10–14, and Ecclesiastes 9:10 reflect the mystery, finality, and apparent silence associated with death.
Yet the Old Testament also contains important movements beyond this conception. Psalm 16:10 expresses confidence that God will not abandon his faithful one to Sheol, while Psalm 73:23–26 presents communion with God as more enduring than bodily life. These passages should not be treated as fully articulated descriptions of the intermediate state, but they establish the relational foundation from which later Jewish hope develops. The central confidence is that death cannot ultimately nullify God’s covenant faithfulness.
By the time of Daniel 12:2–3, resurrection hope becomes explicit. Those sleeping in the dust awaken, and the wise shine with heavenly brilliance. Isaiah 25:6–9 likewise anticipates the defeat of death itself, describing a future divine banquet and the removal of tears. These texts are not simply concerned with the continued existence of a soul. They envision divine action overcoming death and restoring life.
Second Temple Jewish literature reveals how these expectations developed in the centuries surrounding the emergence of Christianity. Wisdom of Solomon 3:1–9 places the righteous in God’s hands and anticipates their vindication. First Enoch 22 portrays differentiated places of waiting for the dead prior to judgment. Fourth Ezra 7:75–101 describes postmortem conditions preceding the final judgment, while Second Baruch 49–51 explores the transformation of resurrected bodies. These works do not speak with a unified voice, and some were composed after the New Testament period. Nevertheless, they demonstrate that Jewish thinkers could distinguish between the condition of the dead and the future resurrection. [3]
This distinction is essential when approaching Jesus and Paul. Their language emerged within a world already wrestling with the relationship between present death, continuing existence, divine judgment, and the ultimate restoration of creation. Christianity did not invent resurrection as a vague promise that life continues after death. Its distinctive proclamation was that Israel’s anticipated resurrection had already begun in Jesus the Messiah and would ultimately embrace those belonging to him.
Paradise and the Intermediate State: What Happens When Believers Die?
One of the clearest New Testament passages concerning the immediate condition following death appears in Luke 23:43. Jesus tells the repentant criminal that he will be with him in paradise. The Greek term paradeisos derives historically from an Iranian word associated with an enclosed garden or park and entered Jewish and Greek religious vocabulary as a way of describing an extraordinary place of life and blessing. In the Septuagint, the term is also used in connection with the garden of Eden. The significance is intriguing: Jesus does not provide a detailed geographical description of the afterlife but promises the dying man personal communion with himself in a place evoking the goodness of God’s garden.
Wright understands this paradise as an intermediate resting place rather than the final destination of the redeemed. His reasoning is grounded in the narrative sequence itself. Jesus promises paradise to the criminal, yet his own bodily resurrection occurs subsequently. Therefore, paradise and resurrection cannot simply be treated as identical experiences. In this reading, paradise is an expression of security, peace, and communion with Christ while awaiting the resurrection of the dead. [4]
Paul provides complementary language in Philippians 1:21–23, where he describes his desire to depart and be with Christ. The Greek expression syn Christō einai, meaning to be with Christ, places the emphasis upon relationship rather than geography. Similarly, 2 Corinthians 5:1–10 contrasts the fragility of present bodily existence with the enduring life God has prepared. Paul expresses confidence about being at home with the Lord, yet his imagery of being clothed rather than found naked also reveals a deeper longing for transformed embodiment.
The interpretation of 2 Corinthians 5 requires some caution. Scholars disagree about whether Paul’s heavenly dwelling refers to an immediate postmortem body, the future resurrection body, or the secure heavenly reality of the resurrection promise. His language cannot settle every question about the precise nature of intermediate existence. Nevertheless, Philippians 1 and 2 Corinthians 5 together provide substantial grounds for believing that death does not separate the faithful from Christ.
Revelation 6:9–11 offers another suggestive image. John sees the souls of those who have suffered martyrdom beneath the heavenly altar. They speak, receive white robes, and are instructed to rest while awaiting the completion of God’s purposes. The passage is apocalyptic rather than a literal architectural description of heaven, but its theological significance is considerable. The martyrs are remembered, their suffering has not been forgotten, and their vindication remains connected to God’s future judgment and renewal.
The intermediate state, then, may be understood as real communion with Christ in which the believer is secure, at rest, and awaiting the fullness of resurrection. Its exact experiential qualities remain largely undisclosed. Scripture does not provide enough detail to describe its physical surroundings, the ordinary passage of time, or the activities of departed believers with confidence. Alternative interpretations, including forms of unconscious waiting until resurrection, have also existed within Christianity. Yet the cumulative force of the passages concerning being with Christ gives substantial support to conscious fellowship with him beyond death.
The Christian hope is therefore not merely that believers survive dying. It is that those who belong to Christ remain his, and that death cannot prevent their future resurrection.
Isaiah 65 and the Creation of a New Heaven and Earth
Isaiah 65:17–25 is among the most important texts for reconstructing the biblical understanding of eternity. The passage announces God’s intention to create new heavens and a new earth and proceeds to describe a renewed Jerusalem characterized by joy, security, meaningful labor, abundant life, and harmony within the created order.
The Hebrew verb baraʾ, meaning to create, is particularly significant. It is the same verb prominent in Genesis 1 and appears repeatedly in Isaiah 65:17–18. The literary connection invites readers to understand the promised future as an act of divine creation. Yet Isaiah’s vision is not detached from the historical experience of Israel. Within the context of exile, imperial domination, dispossession, and threatened communal identity, the promise that people will build houses and inhabit them, plant vineyards and enjoy their fruit, and no longer labor in vain addresses recognizable human suffering.
Isaiah 65:21–23 presents a remarkable picture of restoration. The people are no longer displaced from their homes or deprived of the fruit of their labor. The covenant curses associated with oppression, insecurity, and the failure of agricultural life are reversed. The imagery recalls Deuteronomy 28, Leviticus 26, and Genesis 3. What was once characterized by frustrated labor and vulnerability is transformed into enduring peace and flourishing.
The theological implications are considerable. Isaiah’s future is not characterized by the rejection of ordinary human existence. It includes meaningful work, creativity, belonging, community, and the enjoyment of God’s material creation. The prophetic imagination does not regard houses, vineyards, land, and embodied life as temporary embarrassments to be discarded. Rather, these become expressions of God’s restored purposes.
However, Isaiah 65 also presents an exegetical difficulty that deserves careful attention. Verse 20 contains language concerning death at a hundred years of age. If this passage describes the final eternal state, why does death appear to remain possible? Some interpreters, particularly within premillennial traditions, understand the passage as referring to an intermediate messianic kingdom preceding the final elimination of death. Others argue that Isaiah employs familiar categories of human longevity to communicate a transformed reality that ultimately transcends death altogether.
G. K. Beale has defended the latter approach, arguing that Isaiah 65:20 should be understood within the broader context of eternal new creation rather than as evidence of a temporary kingdom in which death continues. His argument draws upon Isaiah’s creation imagery, the reversal of Genesis 3, the defeat of death in Isaiah 25:8, and the interpretation of Isaiah’s language in Revelation 21–22. [5]
This reading deserves serious consideration because prophetic literature frequently communicates realities beyond ordinary human experience through images drawn from the world known to its original audience. A prophet announcing the complete defeat of death to an ancient community devastated by infant mortality, warfare, famine, and premature death could communicate extraordinary restoration through the imagery of remarkably long life. At the same time, the original language of Isaiah 65:20 should not be dismissed simply because it complicates later theological formulations. Read within its own literary and historical setting, the verse describes longevity rather than explicitly declaring immortality. The movement toward a final state without death becomes clearer when Isaiah 25:8 is read alongside Revelation 21:4.
This represents a useful example of textured hermeneutics. The historical meaning of Isaiah, its prophetic literary form, its place within Israel’s developing eschatology, and its later reception in Revelation must all be considered without collapsing the distinctions between them. Isaiah’s immediate horizon concerns restoration in categories meaningful to Israel, while its canonical trajectory contributes to a larger vision of cosmic renewal.
Will We Remember Our Earthly Lives?
Isaiah 65:17 raises another important question by declaring that the former things will no longer be remembered or come to mind. Does this mean that believers will lose all recollection of their earthly existence? Will relationships, experiences, personal history, and even memories of loved ones disappear?
Such an interpretation faces several difficulties. The Hebrew term zakar, commonly translated to remember, frequently carries covenantal and relational significance beyond the simple retrieval of information. When God declares in Jeremiah 31:34 that he will remember sins no more, the statement does not imply a loss of divine knowledge. Rather, it concerns the termination of sin’s covenantal consequences. Likewise, Isaiah 43:18–19 calls Israel not to remember former things immediately before announcing God’s new work. The emphasis is not necessarily the destruction of historical memory but the arrival of a reality so transformative that the former conditions no longer define the community.
Randy Alcorn has made a similar argument regarding Isaiah 65:17, maintaining that the elimination of painful recollection is not equivalent to the erasure of personal history. He points to the continuity of redemptive memory within the biblical narrative, including the visible wounds of the risen Christ and the commemorative symbolism of the New Jerusalem. [6]
This distinction is especially important when considering personal identity. Christian resurrection theology presupposes some meaningful continuity between the person who dies and the person who is raised. Jesus’ resurrection provides the paradigmatic example. His glorified body is transformed, yet his identity remains recognizable. He remembers his disciples, refers to earlier events, and bears the wounds associated with his crucifixion (Luke 24:36–43; John 20:24–29).
Although these passages do not definitively describe the memory of every resurrected believer, they strongly suggest that transformation does not require the destruction of personal identity. It may therefore be more appropriate to distinguish between remembering suffering and remaining enslaved to suffering. The resurrection promise does not require God to erase the story of our lives. Rather, it anticipates the transformation of our relationship to that story. The sorrow attached to an experience need not remain the defining power of that experience. The redeemed person may remember loss without remaining captive to grief, recognize former wounds without continuing to suffer their destructive consequences, and understand past failures without being condemned by them. The biblical promise is not necessarily that we will forget everything that happened. It is that the former order of sorrow, evil, and death will no longer possess the power to govern our existence.
Resurrection, Embodiment, and the Continuity of Human Identity
One of the most persistent misunderstandings of the Christian afterlife involves the nature of the resurrection body. In 1 Corinthians 15, Paul contrasts the present psychikon body with the future pneumatikon body. These terms are frequently translated as natural and spiritual, leading some readers to conclude that the resurrection involves the abandonment of material existence.
Yet the contrast is not straightforwardly between a physical body and a nonphysical spirit. Paul’s argument concerns the transformation of human existence from its present mortal and corruptible condition into a form of life empowered by the Spirit. His agricultural analogy of the seed and plant emphasizes both continuity and discontinuity. The resurrected body is genuinely related to the present body, yet it is transformed beyond its present limitations. The risen Jesus demonstrates this tension. He is recognizable, speaks, interacts with others, and eats with his disciples, yet his resurrection life is no longer subject to the ordinary limitations of mortality. The Gospel narratives do not present his resurrection as mere resuscitation. They describe the inauguration of a transformed mode of embodied life.
This also raises questions concerning relationships, marriage, and biological identity. Jesus’ response to the Sadducees in Mark 12:18–27, Matthew 22:23–33, and Luke 20:27–40 indicates that marriage as presently constituted does not continue in the resurrection. However, the comparison with angels concerns the conditions of resurrection life, particularly freedom from death and the marital arrangements assumed by the Sadducees. It does not necessarily mean that resurrected humans lose their embodied humanity or become angels. Ian Paul has explored this question by examining early Christian reflection on bodily identity, sexual differentiation, marriage, and resurrection. His analysis draws attention to an important distinction between the continuity of human embodiment and the continuation of every social or biological function associated with mortal life. [7]
The New Testament does not provide a comprehensive description of resurrected biology. Speculation about reproduction, biological development, or the precise nature of bodily differentiation therefore needs to remain tentative. What appears considerably clearer is that resurrection restores rather than obliterates human personhood. We should expect transformation without assuming the loss of everything that makes us recognizably human.
The New Jerusalem: Temple, Eden, and the Dwelling of God
Revelation 21–22 brings several major biblical themes into a single eschatological vision. John sees a new heaven and new earth, the descent of the New Jerusalem, the removal of death and mourning, and the restoration of the river and tree of life. The imagery combines Isaiah 65–66, Ezekiel 40–48, Genesis 2–3, and numerous prophetic promises concerning Zion and the presence of God.
Particularly striking is the absence of a temple building in Revelation 21:22. This does not signify the abandonment of sacred space but its universalization. God and the Lamb are the temple, and the city itself participates in the divine presence. Its cubic dimensions recall the Holy of Holies, suggesting that the entire renewed dwelling of humanity has become sacred space.
Gregory Beale’s temple-centered interpretation of Revelation has been influential in understanding this imagery. The movement from Eden through the tabernacle and temple to the New Jerusalem reflects the expansion of God’s dwelling until creation itself becomes the setting of unhindered communion.
Raymond R. Hausoul’s interdisciplinary comparison of Karl Rahner, Jürgen Moltmann, and Beale provides a valuable contribution to this discussion. Hausoul examines the relationship between biblical and systematic theology in interpreting the new heavens and new earth, emphasizing the importance of both continuity and transformation. The new creation should not be reduced to the annihilation of the present world followed by an entirely unrelated replacement. Rather, the biblical vision points toward the glorification and consummation of God’s original creative purposes. [8]
The language of Revelation 21:1, particularly the declaration that the sea is no more, also requires attention to ancient symbolism. Throughout the Hebrew Bible and surrounding ancient Near Eastern literature, the sea can represent chaos, danger, hostile powers, and threats to God’s ordered creation. The imagery of the sea’s removal may therefore communicate the complete elimination of chaos and evil rather than the literal absence of every body of water in the renewed world. This interpretation is strengthened by the life-giving river flowing through the city in Revelation 22:1–2.
Similarly, the description of nations bringing their glory into the New Jerusalem (Revelation 21:24–26) suggests the redemption of human cultural life rather than its wholesale elimination. The imagery leaves room for understanding the diverse contributions of human society as purified and brought into the worship of God.
The final biblical vision is therefore neither an empty spiritual realm nor a return to ordinary mortal life. It is an embodied, relational, communal, and cosmic restoration in which God’s presence permeates creation.
Will There Be Work, Creativity, and Relationships in the Renewed Creation?
Isaiah 65:21–23 and Revelation 21–22 invite consideration of whether meaningful human activity continues within the eternal kingdom. The biblical evidence does not allow us to describe the precise occupations or ordinary routines of resurrected life. Nevertheless, the consistent affirmation of creation’s goodness provides grounds for questioning the assumption that eternity consists exclusively of passive contemplation.
Work itself precedes the fall. Genesis 2:15 presents humanity’s vocation in the garden through the language of service and care. The Hebrew verbs avad and shamar, commonly understood as working or serving and keeping or guarding, also appear in contexts associated with priestly responsibility. Humanity’s original task was therefore more than agricultural productivity. It involved faithful stewardship of sacred space.
Isaiah’s renewed creation includes the enjoyment of productive labor without exploitation or futility. Revelation presents the servants of God as engaged in worshipful service and reigning (22:3–5). While these descriptions should not be turned into speculative schedules of heavenly activity, they indicate that redeemed existence involves meaningful participation in God’s purposes.
Human relationships likewise appear within a transformed communal context. The New Jerusalem is populated, the nations are represented, and God’s people share a common life in the divine presence. The resurrection does not promise the permanent continuation of every institution that belongs to the present age, but neither does it present salvation as the isolation of individuals within private spiritual experiences.
There is considerable theological reason to anticipate recognition, fellowship, and a redeemed continuity of personal relationships. Yet questions concerning the precise form of those relationships should be approached with humility. Scripture provides the promise of communion more clearly than the details of its organization.
What emerges is a picture of eternity in which human life is neither diminished nor rendered meaningless. Creation, community, worship, and vocation reach their fulfillment in a world no longer governed by decay and death.
The Kingdom Already Present and the Creation Yet to Come
The distinction between the intermediate state and the final resurrection must also be placed within the New Testament’s inaugurated eschatology. The kingdom of God is not exclusively a future reality. Jesus announces its arrival, demonstrates its power through healing and deliverance, and identifies his resurrection as the decisive beginning of God’s victory over death.
Paul describes believers as participants in new creation in 2 Corinthians 5:17, while Romans 8:18–25 presents the entire created order as awaiting liberation from corruption. The Spirit is described as the firstfruits of the coming restoration. The Greek term aparchē, firstfruits, evokes the initial portion of a harvest that anticipates what is yet to come. The presence of the Spirit is therefore not merely evidence of individual spiritual experience but a foretaste of the future toward which creation is moving.
This means the present Christian life has an eschatological character. The church lives between the inauguration and consummation of the kingdom, participating already in a reality that will one day be fully revealed. Acts of mercy, reconciliation, hospitality, justice, faithful stewardship, and covenant love are not substitutes for the coming kingdom. They are expressions of the kingdom’s present reality.
Wright has repeatedly emphasized the implications of this understanding for Christian vocation. The promise of resurrection does not encourage indifference toward the present world. Instead, it establishes the significance of faithful work within God’s creation. First Corinthians 15 concludes its extended treatment of resurrection not with an invitation to withdraw from ordinary life but with an exhortation to remain steadfast in the work of the Lord, knowing that such labor is not in vain.
This provides an important corrective to forms of Christian eschatology that portray the future primarily as escape from a doomed world. The biblical story is not fundamentally one of divine abandonment but divine restoration.
Conclusion: Heaven Is Not the End of the Story
Perhaps the most beautiful aspect of the biblical hope is that death is neither the final word nor the ultimate destination of the believer. Those who die in Christ are not forgotten or abandoned. They belong to him, and nothing, including death itself, can separate them from his love. Yet even that extraordinary promise is not the conclusion of the Christian story. The resurrection of Jesus declares that God intends to do more than preserve our existence beyond the grave. He intends to restore what death has broken, heal what sin has wounded, and bring creation into the fullness of his presence. This changes how we understand grief, how we approach suffering, and how we live today. The relationships we nurture, the people we love, the mercy we extend, and the faithfulness we practice are not meaningless activities within a disposable world. They belong to a kingdom that has already begun breaking into the present. We may not know exactly what paradise looks like or how the renewed creation will feel beneath our feet, but we know the One who has promised to make all things new. Our hope is not simply that one day we will leave this world and go to heaven. Our hope is that God will finish what he began, and heaven and earth will finally become what they were always intended to be.
We are not waiting to escape creation. We are waiting for its restoration.
And until that day, we are called to live as people of the resurrection, bringing the life of the coming kingdom into the world around us.
Notes and References
N. T. Wright, Surprised by Hope: Rethinking Heaven, the Resurrection, and the Mission of the Church (New York: HarperOne, 2008), especially chapters 3, 7, and 11; Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003).
See Genesis 2:8–15; 3:24; Exodus 25:17–22; 1 Kings 6:18–35; Ezekiel 47:1–12; Revelation 21:1–22:5. For the broader temple theology, see G. K. Beale, The Temple and the Church’s Mission: A Biblical Theology of the Dwelling Place of God (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2004).
Wisdom of Solomon 3:1–9; 1 Enoch 22; 4 Ezra 7:75–101; 2 Baruch 49–51. These sources illustrate the diversity of Jewish eschatological reflection and should not be treated as a uniform doctrine or as possessing the same canonical status across Christian traditions.
Wright, Surprised by Hope, especially his discussion of paradise and the intermediate state. See also Luke 23:43; Philippians 1:21–23; 2 Corinthians 5:1–10; Revelation 6:9–11.
G. K. Beale, “An Amillennial Response to a Premillennial View of Isaiah 65:20,” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 61, no. 3 (2018): 461–484. Compare Isaiah 25:8; 65:17–25; Revelation 21:1–4. Interpretations differ concerning whether Isaiah 65 describes the final creation, a millennial kingdom, or prophetic restoration language subsequently expanded in the New Testament.
Randy Alcorn, “Does Isaiah 65:17 Mean We Won’t Remember Our Previous Lives When We’re in Heaven?” Eternal Perspective Ministries, November 20, 2020.
Ian Paul, “Will We Be Male and Female in the New Creation?” Psephizo, July 2016. See also Mark 12:18–27; Luke 20:27–40; 1 Corinthians 15:35–49.
Raymond R. Hausoul, The New Heaven and New Earth: An Interdisciplinary Comparison between Jürgen Moltmann, Karl Rahner, and Gregory Beale (Eugene, OR: Wipf and Stock, 2020), especially chapters 5–7.
For the Isaianic connections between exile, restoration, creation, and the reversal of the Genesis curses, see Isaiah 11:6–9; 25:6–9; 43:18–19; 65:17–25; 66:22. See also the discussions of Isaiah 65 in Working Preacher, Luther Seminary, particularly its treatments of the restoration of Jerusalem and Edenic imagery.
N. T. Wright, “Heaven Is Not Our Home,” Christianity Today, April 2008; and Wright, “Apocalyptic and the Beauty of God,” sermon delivered at Harvard Memorial Church, October 22, 2006. Both address the relationship between new creation, resurrection, and Christian participation in God’s restorative purposes.
Paul develops the already-and-not-yet character of new creation in Romans 8:18–25; 1 Corinthians 15:20–28, 42–58; and 2 Corinthians 5:1–21. These texts must be read within Paul’s wider understanding of the Spirit, resurrection, and the reign of Christ rather than as isolated descriptions of the afterlife.
N. T. Wright, “The Great Story of the Bible Is Not About Going to Heaven. It’s About God Coming to Us,” Bible Gateway, February 17, 2026. The essay develops the relationship between the divine dwelling, the New Jerusalem, and God’s intention to renew creation rather than abandon it.
Political Power, the Great Commission, and the Question of Christian Allegiance
I have written several times over the years about Christians and voting. My position has not always been particularly popular, especially among American evangelicals who have come to understand voting as something approaching a Christian obligation. Yet I have never been entirely convinced that Scripture requires Christians either to vote or to abstain. I suspect the answer is considerably more complicated, and perhaps more situational, than either position allows.
Recently, my good friend Dr. Steve Cassell preached a message concerning Christian responsibility in the political arena. I have tremendous respect for Steve, not only as a pastor and theologian, but as someone who has given considerable thought to what faithful Christian engagement with government should look like. In fact, I consider him one of the finest examples I know of someone attempting to approach political involvement through a genuinely Christian worldview. Whether Jesus would agree with all of our conclusions about politics is another question entirely, and perhaps part of the reason this conversation is worth having! Although Steve and I do not always see eye to eye on these matters, I believe his position is thoughtful, biblically motivated, and worthy of serious consideration.
We share an essential conviction: Jesus Christ is King, and our allegiance belongs to Him above every earthly institution. In his recent message, Steve argues that because Christians are commanded to love their neighbors, seek the welfare of their communities, and disciple the nations, they should participate in political processes that allow them to influence the laws governing those communities. He connects this responsibility particularly to Matthew 28, suggesting that voting can become one means through which Christians disciple their nation. You can watch Steve’s message here.
I appreciate his concern for justice and the welfare of our neighbors, and I agree that laws can profoundly influence the communities in which we live. However, I am less convinced that Scripture establishes voting as a Christian duty or that influencing legislation is necessarily an expression of discipling the nations. The question becomes particularly interesting when we consider the political world Jesus entered and the remarkable ways He refused the available models of power.
The Political Kingdoms Jesus Refused
First-century Judaism was anything but politically unified. The Jewish people had experienced centuries of foreign domination, and the memory of the Maccabean revolt against Seleucid oppression remained an important part of their national identity. Some Jewish leaders cooperated with Rome, while others sought greater separation from its religious and political influence. The Essenes, described by Josephus and often associated with the communities responsible for the Dead Sea Scrolls, cultivated distinctive covenantal communities that anticipated God’s judgment upon wickedness. Their relationship to the broader political resistance of the period remains debated, but their writings reveal an expectation that God would eventually confront the corrupt powers governing the world.[1]
Other movements were considerably more confrontational. Josephus describes Judas the Galilean, whose movement arose in opposition to Roman taxation during the census associated with Quirinius in 6 CE. Judas and his followers believed that recognizing Roman political mastery compromised their allegiance to God. Josephus explains that they insisted God alone was their rightful ruler and lord, maintaining this conviction even under the threat of suffering and death.[2]
I find this historical connection fascinating. The declaration that God alone is King was already a politically charged confession before the ministry of Jesus began. Yet Judas understood this conviction in ways that encouraged resistance to Roman domination, while Jesus announced the arrival of God’s kingdom without adopting the revolutionary methods associated with such movements. Their theological language could sound remarkably similar, but their approaches to earthly authority were profoundly different.
Jesus had opportunities to align Himself with the political expectations of His contemporaries. John 6:15 records that a crowd intended to seize Him and make Him king, yet He withdrew. He did not join a Maccabean-style liberation movement, identify His ministry with the separatist vision associated with Qumran, or pursue influence within the existing religious-political establishment. His refusal was not a rejection of His identity as King, but a rejection of the means through which people expected that kingship to be established.
John the Baptist provides another intriguing comparison. Josephus records that Herod Antipas feared John’s influence might produce an uprising, leading to his imprisonment and execution.[3] The Gospels emphasize John’s prophetic confrontation with Herod’s conduct rather than any revolutionary program, so we should not assume John was organizing political resistance. Nevertheless, it is striking that when John questioned Jesus from prison, Jesus pointed toward healing, restoration, and good news for the poor rather than political liberation (Matt 11:2–6). Jesus did not organize John’s release, although the text gives us no reason to conclude that He disapproved of John’s prophetic ministry. The kingdom was arriving, but its arrival did not mean that Jesus would overthrow every unjust ruler or immediately liberate every faithful person suffering beneath political authority.
Perhaps the most revealing event occurs in Luke 4:5–8, where the devil offers Jesus authority over the kingdoms of the world in exchange for worship. Within the narrative, the devil claims that this authority has been given to him, and Jesus refuses the offer without directly disputing that claim. Matt Mouzakis and I examine this passage extensively in our book Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, connecting it to the Deuteronomy 32 worldview, in which the nations exist amid rebellious spiritual powers and disordered political authority.[4]
The temptation offered Jesus an apparently efficient path toward possessing the nations without the suffering of the cross. He refused because His kingship could not be established through compromised allegiance. This does not make every form of governmental participation inherently evil, but it should challenge our assumption that acquiring political influence necessarily advances the kingdom of God.
Jesus later told Pilate that His kingdom was not ek tou kosmou toutou, not from this world (John 18:36). His point concerned the origin and character of His kingdom, as demonstrated by His explanation that His followers would otherwise fight to prevent His arrest. Likewise, in Mark 10:42–45, Jesus contrasted the rulers of the nations, who exercise domination over others, with the servant leadership expected of His disciples.
Jesus possessed legitimate authority over the nations while refusing the very methods by which earthly rulers ordinarily secured and exercised that authority. Surely that should inform how His followers think about political power.
Does the Great Commission Require Political Participation?
This brings me back to Steve’s argument concerning Matthew 28:18–20. Jesus declares that all authority in heaven and earth belongs to Him and commands His followers to make disciples of all nations. Steve reasons that because Christians possess opportunities to shape national legislation through voting, political participation can become an extension of the Great Commission.
While I understand the connection, I believe this interpretation moves beyond what the passage actually teaches. The primary imperative in Matthew 28:19 is mathēteusate, meaning to make disciples. The object of that command is panta ta ethnē, all nations or peoples. The accompanying participles describe baptizing and teaching these disciples to observe what Jesus commanded. The passage concerns the formation of people who follow Jesus, not the establishment of political structures that compel societies to observe Christian moral standards.[5]
This distinction matters because legislation and discipleship are fundamentally different activities. Civil laws may restrain harmful behavior, protect vulnerable people, and establish conditions that encourage social flourishing. Those are legitimate concerns, but governmental compliance does not produce covenantal allegiance to Jesus. Israel’s own history illustrates that possessing righteous laws did not necessarily produce a righteous people. The prophets anticipated a deeper restoration through transformed hearts and the work of God’s Spirit (Jer 31:31–34; Ezek 36:26–27).
There is also a historical difficulty with interpreting the Great Commission as a mandate for political influence. The earliest Christians received this command while possessing little opportunity to influence Roman legislation, yet Acts describes them faithfully fulfilling their calling through proclamation, baptism, teaching, hospitality, and the formation of distinctive communities. Their inability to control governmental policy did not prevent them from making disciples.
A Christian might reasonably view voting as one way of seeking justice or protecting neighbors, but that is a potential application of Christian ethics rather than an explicit command of the Great Commission. Christ’s authority over the nations does not automatically establish an obligation for Christians to govern those nations in His name.
Principalities, Powers, and the Question of Allegiance
In Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, Matt and I argue that the relationship between the church and earthly government must be understood within the broader biblical narrative rather than through isolated interpretations of Romans 13. Paul’s instruction to submit to governing authorities follows Romans 12, where Christians are commanded not to conform to the present age, to bless persecutors, to refuse retaliation, and to overcome evil with good. Romans 13 itself continues into the command to love one’s neighbor. The passage addresses how Christians should conduct themselves within existing political arrangements, not how they might acquire authority over those arrangements.
Revelation 13 introduces the other side of this theological tension. Drawing upon Daniel 7, John portrays imperial power through the imagery of a beast whose authority comes from the dragon. Within its first-century context, this imagery confronted Rome’s claims to political and religious allegiance. The contrast between the beast and the Lamb is not simply a distinction between immoral and moral leaders. It concerns competing kingdoms, each demanding the loyalty of those who belong to it.[6]
This is where the language of allegiance becomes essential. The question is not merely whether a Christian participates in society, pays taxes, or exercises certain civic responsibilities. It is whether those activities begin to redefine the believer’s identity and loyalty. The distinction becomes especially clear in Jesus’s response concerning taxation. When asked whether the imperial tax should be paid, Jesus pointed to Caesar’s image upon the coin and instructed His questioners to return to Caesar what belonged to Caesar while giving God what belonged to God (Mark 12:13–17).
The early Christian writer Tertullian recognized the deeper theological implications of this exchange. Caesar’s image appeared upon his coin, but humanity bears the image of God. The coin might be returned to Caesar, but the human person belongs to the Creator.[7] Jesus had transformed a political question into a question of ultimate allegiance.
I think this distinction is particularly important in modern American Christianity. Voting may begin as a thoughtful attempt to serve one’s community, yet political participation can gradually cultivate loyalties that compete with our identity in Christ. Political movements encourage believers to identify with their parties, defend their candidates, and view opposing groups as threats. Eventually, the church may become better known for its political commitments than for its embodiment of the teachings of Jesus.
The danger is not necessarily the act of casting a ballot. It is allowing political systems to shape our understanding of righteousness, community, enemies, and ultimately the kingdom of God. When Christians begin defending behavior they would otherwise condemn because it advances their political interests, the problem is no longer merely political disagreement. It has become a question of compromised allegiance.
Should Christians Vote?
Scripture also provides meaningful reasons why a Christian might choose to participate in government. Jeremiah 29:7 instructed Israel’s exiles to seek the shalom, or welfare, of Babylon, even though Babylon was responsible for their displacement. Joseph and Daniel exercised governmental responsibilities within foreign empires, demonstrating that participation in imperfect political institutions did not necessarily constitute spiritual compromise. Paul likewise called Christians to pray for rulers and pursue peaceful lives characterized by dignity and godliness (1 Tim 2:1–2).
These passages remind us that allegiance to Christ does not require indifference toward our neighbors. There may be circumstances in which voting provides a responsible opportunity to protect vulnerable people, restrain injustice, or contribute to the welfare of a community. A Christian may participate in these ways without imagining that political success establishes the kingdom of God.
However, these same biblical examples do not establish a universal obligation to participate. Jeremiah instructed the exiles to seek Babylon’s welfare without commanding them to acquire political authority. Daniel served faithfully within government while remaining prepared to suffer rather than violate his allegiance to God. The early church contributed to the welfare of Roman society while some Christian teachers maintained distance from forms of public service they regarded as incompatible with discipleship. Origen, responding to the pagan critic Celsus, even argued that Christians served society through the distinctive life and ministry of the church rather than necessarily occupying governmental office.[8]
I believe there is room for Christians to reach different conclusions concerning a particular election. One believer may prayerfully conclude that voting is a responsible way to serve the community under the circumstances. Another may conclude that participation would require an unacceptable compromise of conscience or an identification with political conduct contrary to the teachings of Jesus.
Neither conclusion should automatically become a measure of another person’s faithfulness. Romans 14 reminds us of the importance of conscience and humility in matters where believers may reach different practical judgments while remaining accountable to the same Lord. Although Paul was addressing different disputes, the principle cautions against transforming an application of Christian ethics into a universal command when Scripture has not done so.
A Pastoral Reflection for the Church Today
As another election approaches, I recognize how deeply these conversations affect our churches, families, and friendships. There are Christians who genuinely believe their participation in the political process is an expression of loving their neighbors. There are others who look at the character of political discourse, the compromises required by party loyalty, and the increasingly hostile spirit of public life and wonder whether their participation is drawing them away from the way of Jesus.
I think both concerns deserve serious consideration. What troubles me pastorally is how quickly we have allowed voting to become a test of Christian faithfulness. We sometimes speak as though a believer’s commitment to the kingdom can be measured by whether they enter a voting booth, or even by the particular choices they make once inside. Yet Jesus never established political participation as the defining evidence of discipleship. He spoke instead about love, mercy, reconciliation, holiness, faithfulness, and the willingness to lay down one’s life for others.
For those who choose to vote, I would encourage you to do so with humility and a conscience formed by the teachings of Jesus. Take seriously your responsibility to your neighbors, particularly those who are vulnerable or unable to defend themselves. But refuse to surrender your integrity to a candidate or party. Do not excuse dishonesty because it serves a cause you support, and do not allow political disagreement to become an excuse for withholding love from someone Christ has called you to serve.
For those who choose not to vote, I would offer a similar encouragement. Let your abstention emerge from conviction rather than apathy. Continue seeking the welfare of your community, caring for people in need, confronting injustice, and demonstrating the character of Christ in ordinary life. The kingdom has never depended upon the availability of a ballot, and the responsibility to love our neighbors does not disappear when we choose not to cast one.
Above all, I would ask each of us to consider what our political involvement is doing to our hearts. Are we becoming more gracious, more patient, more truthful, and more willing to love our enemies? Or are we becoming increasingly fearful, angry, suspicious, and convinced that everything depends upon the next election? If our political convictions are producing qualities that look increasingly unlike Jesus, perhaps we need to examine what has been discipling us.
I deeply appreciate Steve’s conviction that Christ alone is King. It is precisely because I share that conviction that I hesitate to make political participation a necessary expression of Christian discipleship. Jesus had opportunities to secure His kingdom through familiar mechanisms of earthly power, yet He consistently chose another way. His kingdom would be revealed through people who embodied His character, even when doing so placed them at odds with the authorities of their age.
My hope is that Christians on both sides of this question can recover that same confidence in Jesus. We do not need to question one another’s devotion to Christ simply because we reach different conclusions about an election. Our unity is not found in a candidate, a political party, or a shared strategy for influencing government. It is found in the One who has called us to follow Him.
And perhaps this is what I most want to leave with the church: Please do not allow the politics of this world to rob you of the people Jesus has called you to love. Do not sacrifice a friendship, divide a family, or wound a brother or sister in Christ over an earthly kingdom that will one day pass away. Speak truthfully, pursue justice, and act according to conscience, but remember that the person across the political aisle is still someone made in the image of God.
You may enter the voting booth believing it is an act of faithfulness, or you may refrain for precisely the same reason. Either way, when the election is over, the calling of Jesus remains. We will still be commanded to love our enemies, care for the poor, welcome the stranger, forgive those who wrong us, and bear witness to a kingdom unlike the nations surrounding us.
The kingdom of God has never needed an electoral victory to move forward. It has advanced through ordinary people who faithfully follow an extraordinary King.
Vote if you believe you should. Refrain if your conscience leads you otherwise. But do not confuse either decision with the fullness of Christian discipleship.
Jesus is already King. Let us make certain our lives reveal that we believe it.
Endnotes
Josephus, J.W. 2.119–161; Community Rule (1QS 1–9); War Scroll (1QM). See also Joan E. Taylor, The Essenes, the Scrolls, and the Dead Sea (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2012). The relationship between the Qumran community and the wider Essene movement remains a matter of scholarly discussion.
Josephus, Ant. 18.4–10, 23–25. Josephus associates Judas the Galilean’s movement with opposition to Roman taxation and a conviction that God alone was ruler and lord. His retrospective interpretation of revolutionary movements should be considered when evaluating the account.
Josephus, Ant. 18.116–119; cf. Mark 6:17–29; Matt 11:2–6. Josephus emphasizes Herod’s fear that John’s popular influence might lead to rebellion, while the Gospel accounts emphasize John’s prophetic confrontation with Herod’s marriage.
Matt Mouzakis and Will Ryan, Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances: Interpreting Romans 13:1–7, 1 Peter 2:13–17, and Revelation 13 within a Deuteronomy 32 Worldview (2025), chaps. 1–4, especially “Jesus and Empire.” The discussion of Luke 4 situates Jesus’s temptation within the wider biblical narrative of the nations and hostile spiritual powers.
Matt 28:18–20. See Daniel B. Wallace, Greek Grammar beyond the Basics: An Exegetical Syntax of the New Testament (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1996), 640–45, for discussion of the grammatical relationship between the main imperative and accompanying participles.
Mouzakis and Ryan, Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, chaps. 6–8. The authors interpret Romans 13:1–7 and Revelation 13 through the larger biblical narrative of exile, the nations, and the principalities and powers, emphasizing the distinction between responsible conduct beneath earthly authorities and ultimate allegiance to Christ.
Tertullian, Marc. 4.38. Tertullian connects Caesar’s image on the denarius with the image of God borne by humanity, drawing a distinction between civil obligations and divine ownership.
Origen, Cels. 8.73–75. Origen defends the Christian contribution to public welfare through prayer, ecclesial service, and the cultivation of a community ordered toward God’s purposes. See also Mouzakis and Ryan, Principalities, Powers, and Allegiances, introduction, discussion of patristic interpretations.
Beyond the Pulpit: Teaching, Mentorship, and the Formation of a People Who Follow Jesus
Introduction: Has the Modern Church Reversed the Model of Jesus?
One of the most significant questions facing contemporary homiletics is whether the modern church has gradually elevated one dimension of Jesus’ ministry—public proclamation—above the larger vocation that gave proclamation its purpose. In many congregations, the pastor’s primary responsibility has become the preparation and delivery of a weekly sermon. The congregation assembles, receives instruction from a platform, and returns to ordinary life until the following gathering. Spiritual growth is often measured through attendance, sermon engagement, and familiarity with biblical teaching. While public proclamation has an undeniable place within the biblical tradition, this arrangement deserves careful examination against the actual ministry of Jesus and the patterns of the earliest Christian communities.
Jesus certainly preached. The Gospels describe him teaching in synagogues (Mark 1:21–22), addressing crowds (Matt 5–7), and proclaiming the kingdom throughout Galilee (Mark 1:14–15). Yet the remarkable feature of his ministry is how little of his work can be adequately described by the modern concept of delivering a weekly sermon. Jesus called people to follow him, not merely to listen to him. He shared meals, traveled with his disciples, interpreted Scripture along the road, confronted their misplaced ambitions, involved them in ministry, corrected their misunderstandings, and eventually entrusted them with responsibility for others. His ministry was lived in proximity to those he was forming. The proclamation of truth was central, but proclamation belonged to a much larger process of discipleship.
The contrast becomes even more striking in Acts 2:42–47. Luke describes the first community of believers as devoted to the apostles’ teaching, fellowship, the breaking of bread, and prayer. The Greek verb proskartereō (προσκαρτερέω), expressed here as the participle proskarterountes, communicates sustained devotion or persistent participation. Teaching was essential, but it was embedded within a shared life characterized by meals, generosity, prayer, mutual responsibility, and daily fellowship. Public teaching and household gatherings operated alongside one another (Acts 2:46; 5:42). The earliest church was not simply an audience gathered around gifted communicators; it was a community being formed around the risen Messiah.¹
This does not mean the first-century church possessed no recognizable preaching ministry, nor does it establish that every congregation must reproduce the social arrangements of Jerusalem. The New Testament repeatedly emphasizes public instruction (Acts 20:7–12; 1 Tim 4:13; 2 Tim 4:2), and historical developments in Christian worship are considerably more complex than a simple movement from homes to auditoriums. Nevertheless, we should distinguish the biblical legitimacy of public preaching from the modern tendency to make sermon delivery the organizing center of pastoral ministry.
In some contemporary settings, the pastor has become an increasingly distant religious professional whose principal contact with the congregation occurs through a microphone. The congregation knows the preacher’s voice, illustrations, opinions, and theological positions, yet may have little opportunity to observe the preacher’s life, participate in ministry alongside that leader, or experience personal spiritual mentorship. We have become highly proficient at constructing platforms for teaching while sometimes neglecting the relationships through which teaching becomes embodied.
This raises a difficult but necessary question: If our model of pastoral ministry produces effective public speakers but few mature disciples capable of discipling others, have we preserved the form of proclamation while neglecting its intended purpose?
John Stott’s Between Two Worlds appropriately identifies the preacher’s responsibility to bridge the world of Scripture and the world of contemporary hearers. Yet the biblical picture suggests that the bridge cannot be constructed through communication alone. The shepherd must also be present among the sheep. Preaching should not become a substitute for the personal, relational, and communal formation that characterized the ministry of Jesus.²
The Biblical Foundation: God Dwelling Among an Image-Bearing People
The formation of disciples is not an innovation introduced by Jesus in the first century. It belongs to the larger biblical story of God’s intention to dwell among humanity and form a people who reflect his character within creation.
Genesis 1:26–28 describes humanity as created in the ṣelem (צֶלֶם), or image, and dĕmût (דְּמוּת), or likeness, of God. Ancient Near Eastern royal ideology frequently associated kingship with the representation of divine authority, while divine images could symbolize a deity’s presence and rule. Genesis places this representative vocation upon humanity itself, male and female alike. Rather than restricting divine representation to a particular earthly king, the narrative identifies human beings as those commissioned to reflect God’s purposes throughout creation.³
This vocation develops through Israel’s covenant calling. Exodus 19:5–6 identifies Israel as a treasured possession, a kingdom of priests, and a holy nation. The priestly imagery is significant because Israel’s calling was never exhausted by its own religious preservation. Israel was to embody Yahweh’s character among the nations, mediating knowledge of the true God through its worship, justice, covenant loyalty, and communal practices.
The theme of divine dwelling accompanies this vocation. Yahweh commands Israel to build a sanctuary so that he might dwell among them (Exod 25:8). Jeremiah anticipates a renewed covenant in which God’s instruction is written upon the hearts of his people (Jer 31:31–34). John’s Gospel identifies Jesus as the Word who became flesh and dwelt among humanity (John 1:14), employing the verb skēnoō (σκηνόω), which evokes the language of dwelling or tabernacling. Finally, Revelation 21:3 announces the consummation of this trajectory: God’s dwelling is with humanity.
The goal is not merely that people receive correct information about God. God forms a covenant people who know him, reflect his character, and participate in his purposes. Discipleship therefore belongs to the theological structure of the entire biblical narrative. It concerns the recovery and fulfillment of humanity’s vocation as God’s image bearers through Jesus Christ, the definitive image of God (Col 1:15).
Ancient Near Eastern Education and the Formation of Disciples
Ancient education was not ordinarily understood as the detached communication of information by an isolated lecturer. Mesopotamian scribal training involved memorization, copying, repetition, correction, and the progressive acquisition of practical competencies. Evidence from Old Babylonian scribal exercises indicates that education frequently operated through apprenticeship and household instruction, although more formal scribal settings also existed. Knowledge was transmitted through sustained relationships and repeated participation in the activities associated with a particular vocation.⁴
Israel’s covenant traditions likewise emphasize formation within ordinary life. Deuteronomy 6:4–9 instructs parents to teach Yahweh’s commandments to their children while sitting at home, traveling, lying down, and rising. The Hebrew šānan (שָׁנַן), used in Deuteronomy 6:7, communicates diligent instruction or impressing something upon another. The point is not that Israel should occasionally offer religious lectures to its children, but that covenant identity should permeate the daily rhythms of the household.
The prophetic narratives provide another analogy. The bĕnê hannĕbîʾîm (בְּנֵי הַנְּבִיאִים), or “sons of the prophets,” appear in communities associated with Samuel, Elijah, and Elisha (1 Sam 19:18–24; 2 Kgs 2:3–5; 4:38; 6:1). Although the expression “school of the prophets” may suggest more formal educational institutions than the texts warrant, the narratives reveal communities in which prophetic identity and vocation were cultivated through association with recognized prophetic leaders.
The succession of Elijah and Elisha is particularly illuminating. Elijah’s mantle, ʾadderet (אַדֶּרֶת), becomes a sign of Elisha’s calling (1 Kgs 19:19), while 2 Kings 2 describes the transmission of prophetic responsibility in the context of Elisha’s continuing allegiance to his master. Elisha requests a double portion of Elijah’s spirit, language that evokes the inheritance of a principal heir rather than simply a request to perform twice as many miracles. The mantle becomes a visible symbol of continuity, but the narrative ultimately emphasizes the presence and empowerment of Yahweh.
The theological relevance for pastoral ministry is considerable. Leadership was not simply the possession of specialized religious knowledge. It involved forming others who could continue the work after the mentor was gone. The measure of Elijah’s legacy was not how many people had heard him speak, but whether the prophetic vocation continued through Elisha.
Leaving the Nets: The Radical Call to Follow Jesus
The calling of the first disciples challenges some of the most comfortable assumptions of contemporary church life. In Mark 1:16–20, Jesus encounters Simon and Andrew while they are fishing and calls them to follow him. Mark records that they immediately leave their nets. Jesus then calls James and John, who leave their father Zebedee in the boat with the hired servants.
The Greek verb aphiēmi (ἀφίημι), used for their leaving, can convey releasing, abandoning, or leaving something behind. Mark employs the adverb euthys (εὐθύς), “immediately,” emphasizing the urgency of their response. Luke 5:11 strengthens the imagery, describing the disciples as leaving everything and following Jesus.
This is not merely a commitment to add religious instruction to an otherwise unchanged life. Jesus’ invitation reorganizes their vocational identity, daily schedule, social relationships, and future expectations. They are not signing up for a weekly Bible study. They are entering the life and mission of a rabbi whose calling will demand an entirely different ordering of their priorities.⁵
The language of discipleship in the Gospel tradition is important. The Greek mathētēs (μαθητής), “disciple,” identifies a learner or follower, while akoloutheō (ἀκολουθέω), “to follow,” frequently communicates the concrete act of accompanying Jesus and the deeper allegiance that accompaniment represents. The Hebrew term talmid (תַּלְמִיד), meaning student or disciple, provides a helpful Jewish conceptual parallel, although the detailed educational structures of later rabbinic Judaism should not simply be projected backward onto Jesus’ ministry.
Later rabbinic literature offers evidence of master-disciple relationships involving close association, observation, and the imitation of a teacher’s conduct. These materials illuminate broader Jewish traditions of learning but were compiled after the lifetime of Jesus and must be used with historical caution. The Gospel narratives themselves, however, offer sufficient evidence to establish that Jesus’ discipleship involved sustained personal participation rather than periodic attendance at formal instruction.⁶
The distinction becomes especially significant in Mark 3:13–15. Jesus appoints the Twelve so that they might be with him, hina ōsin met’ autou (ἵνα ὦσιν μετ’ αὐτοῦ), and so that he might send them out, hina apostellē autous (ἵνα ἀποστέλλῃ αὐτούς). Presence precedes mission. Their formation takes place through proximity to Jesus before they are commissioned to represent him publicly.
This raises a challenging comparison with contemporary theological education. A residential seminary or intentional discipleship community may, in some respects, resemble the immersive learning environment of the Gospel narratives more closely than a congregation organized almost exclusively around weekly attendance. Students study Scripture, share life, wrestle with theological questions, receive correction, and prepare for a vocation that reshapes their priorities.
Yet even seminary education can reproduce the very problem under consideration when it becomes primarily the accumulation of academic credits, detached from spiritual mentorship, communal life, and actual ministry practice. The greater challenge is not to turn every Christian into a full-time seminary student. It is to recover the seriousness of Jesus’ call to discipleship within the ordinary circumstances of Christian life.
Jesus did not explicitly require every follower to abandon their occupation. Some continued to maintain households, support his ministry, and serve within existing social relationships (Luke 8:1–3; 19:1–10). Peter himself appears fishing again in John 21. Therefore, the command to leave the nets should not be universalized into a prohibition against ordinary employment. Nevertheless, the underlying demand remains uncompromising: no occupation, possession, family obligation, or former identity may retain ultimate authority over the call of Jesus. Luke 9:57–62 and 14:25–33 make this especially clear. Following Jesus requires a willingness to relinquish competing allegiances. His teaching is not framed as a convenient religious supplement to an otherwise autonomous existence.
This also illuminates Jesus’ invitation in Matthew 11:28–30. He invites the weary to take his zygos (ζυγός), or yoke, upon themselves and learn from him: mathete ap’ emou (μάθετε ἀπ’ ἐμοῦ). The term zygos could signify a literal yoke, but it also functions metaphorically for obligation or submission to instruction. Jewish wisdom traditions offer important parallels, including Sirach 51:26, which invites learners to place their necks under the yoke of wisdom.
Jesus’ yoke is described as chrēstos (χρηστός), kind or well-suited, and his burden as elaphron (ἐλαφρόν), light. This does not mean discipleship requires little commitment. Matthew’s Gospel contains demanding teachings about self-denial, faithfulness, and costly allegiance. The distinction is that Jesus offers a form of discipleship grounded in his own character, authority, and provision of rest. The yoke is gracious, but the allegiance is comprehensive. Jesus does not invite disciples to attend his teaching occasionally while retaining their former way of life as the governing framework of their existence. He invites them to learn an entirely new way of being human.
The Pedagogy of Jesus: Questions, Experience, Correction, and Participation
Jesus’ methods of instruction reveal a remarkable integration of theological exposition and lived experience. His teaching was neither an uninterrupted lecture nor an unstructured series of religious encounters. The Gospel narratives suggest deliberate development in the understanding, character, and participation of his disciples. They observe Jesus, receive instruction, engage in ministry, misunderstand his intentions, experience correction, and are repeatedly brought back to the central realities of the kingdom.
Mark 4 provides an example of his use of parables. The Greek parabolē (παραβολή) refers broadly to a comparison, illustration, or figurative saying and shares conceptual territory with the Hebrew māšāl (מָשָׁל). Jesus employs familiar agricultural imagery to communicate the character and reception of the kingdom. Yet the parables do more than make complex theological concepts accessible. Mark 4:10–12 presents a tension between revelation and concealment, emphasizing that the hearer’s response is itself part of the narrative. Jesus subsequently explains the parables to his disciples (4:33–34), showing that public proclamation and more intimate theological instruction were complementary rather than competing practices.⁷
In Luke 10:25–37, Jesus demonstrates another form of pedagogical engagement. A legal expert asks what he must do to inherit eternal life. Jesus directs him back to Scripture, asking, Pōs anaginōskeis? (πῶς ἀναγινώσκεις), “How do you read?” The question is not merely whether the man possesses biblical information but how he understands and interprets it. After the lawyer correctly identifies love for God and neighbor as central to the law, Jesus tells the parable of the Samaritan.
The rhetorical movement is significant. The lawyer initially seeks to establish the boundaries of his obligation by asking who qualifies as his neighbor. Jesus reverses the question, identifying the one who acted as a neighbor through mercy. The concluding imperative, poreuou kai sy poiei homoiōs (πορεύου καὶ σὺ ποίει ὁμοίως), directs the hearer toward action: go and do likewise. The distinction between knowing the law and embodying its intent becomes the central pedagogical achievement of the exchange.⁸
John 4 illustrates another dimension of Jesus’ method. In his encounter with the Samaritan woman, Jesus engages questions of social identity, religious tradition, worship, and messianic expectation. The conversation develops through a series of responses and misunderstandings, allowing the woman’s assumptions to emerge before Jesus redirects her toward a more comprehensive understanding of worship. The encounter subsequently becomes the occasion for communal testimony, as others from the town come to hear Jesus for themselves (John 4:39–42). Teaching moves from conversation to revelation and then toward the participation of a wider community.
Jesus also teaches through embodied demonstration. In John 13:1–17, he washes the feet of his disciples and then explains the significance of his actions. The Greek hypodeigma (ὑπόδειγμα), used in John 13:15, identifies his action as an example or pattern. The disciples are not merely instructed to value humility. They encounter humility practiced by the one they recognize as Lord and Teacher, and they are called to imitate what they have witnessed.
Equally important is the way Jesus permits his disciples to participate in ministry before they fully understand it. Mark 6:7–13 describes the Twelve being sent out with authority to proclaim repentance and confront unclean spirits. When they return, they report what they have done and taught (Mark 6:30). The pattern resembles supervised participation more than conventional lecture-based instruction.
Even their failures become occasions for formation. The disciples repeatedly misunderstand Jesus’ identity, the meaning of his mission, and the character of greatness within the kingdom (Mark 8:14–21; 9:33–37; 10:35–45). Rather than abandoning them, Jesus revisits these themes through further teaching, correction, and demonstration.
This recurring pattern offers an important challenge to contemporary preaching. How often do pastors revisit a theological subject because the congregation has not yet learned to embody it? How frequently do leaders invite people into actual ministry, observe their development, and provide personal correction? Jesus’ teaching was repetitive not because he lacked additional material, but because the formation of disciples required more than a single encounter with truth.
Emmaus: The Master Teacher Reconstructs a Failed Theological Framework
The encounter on the road to Emmaus (Luke 24:13–35) provides one of the most compelling narratives of Jesus’ pedagogical approach. It also illustrates why correct information alone is insufficient for faithful biblical interpretation. The two disciples possess considerable information about Jesus. They know of his prophetic ministry, his crucifixion, the discovery of the empty tomb, and the reports of angelic witnesses. Yet they interpret these events through disappointed expectations concerning Israel’s redemption. Their confession in Luke 24:21, hēmeis de ēlpizomen (ἡμεῖς δὲ ἠλπίζομεν), “but we had hoped,” reveals the tension between their expectations and what has occurred.
Jesus begins with questions, allowing the disciples to articulate their understanding. He then challenges their failure to comprehend the prophetic witness and interprets the Scriptures concerning the Messiah’s suffering and glory (Luke 24:25–27). Luke uses the verb diermēneuō (διερμηνεύω), meaning to interpret or explain, to describe Jesus’ exposition of Moses and the Prophets. The significance is not simply that Jesus supplies additional proof texts. He reconstructs their understanding of Israel’s story around the necessity of the Messiah’s suffering and vindication. Their problem is hermeneutical. They possess biblical expectations, but those expectations have not adequately accounted for the shape of God’s redemptive purposes.
Recognition occurs when Jesus takes bread, blesses it, breaks it, and gives it to them (Luke 24:30–31). The narrative deliberately brings together scriptural exposition, shared hospitality, and recognition of the risen Lord. The breaking of bread recalls earlier Lukan meal scenes, particularly the feeding narrative and the Last Supper, without requiring the conclusion that Luke is describing a formal Eucharistic service. The disciples subsequently return to Jerusalem and bear witness to their encounter. Their explanation of Scripture has become inseparable from recognition, renewed hope, and communal testimony.
For homiletics, Emmaus is especially instructive because Jesus does not merely deliver a theological lecture to disappointed followers. He walks with them, listens to their confusion, engages their assumptions, interprets Scripture, shares a meal, and brings them into a renewed recognition of the Messiah. The primary theological claim remains the revelation of the risen Christ, but the narrative also demonstrates that biblical understanding often develops within relationships and experiences that extend beyond formal instruction.
A sermon may faithfully interpret the Scriptures, but discipleship asks what happens when the sermon concludes. Who walks with the people who remain confused? Who helps them reconsider assumptions that have shaped their theology for decades? Who sits with them in their grief, answers their questions, and helps them recognize the presence of Christ within their circumstances?
The preacher who understands Emmaus should not only aspire to explain Scripture with clarity but also cultivate a ministry where people are accompanied through the difficult process of learning to understand and inhabit the biblical story.⁹
Recovering a Congregational Scope and Sequence: Preaching Within a Larger Discipleship Strategy
If the purpose of pastoral ministry is the formation of disciples, then sermon preparation should be connected to a more intentional understanding of congregational development. Most pastors understandably plan their preaching in terms of individual messages or short sermon series. A biblical book may occupy several months, followed by topical series addressing marriage, prayer, spiritual disciplines, or the life of Jesus. While there is considerable value in these approaches, they can become disconnected from a larger vision of what a congregation needs to learn and practice over time.
Educational theory offers a helpful framework through the concepts of scope and sequence. Scope concerns the breadth of material to be addressed, while sequence considers the order and recurrence through which learning develops. These concepts should not turn the local church into a conventional classroom or impose an artificial timetable upon spiritual growth. They can, however, help pastors consider whether their teaching ministries are intentionally forming a mature community or simply producing a succession of individual sermons.
A pastor might begin by asking what a healthy congregation should understand and embody after three, five, or ten years of shared life. Such planning would consider the biblical narrative, the character of God, the Trinity, creation and image bearing, covenant, the kingdom, the person and work of Christ, the Holy Spirit, the church, reconciliation, spiritual formation, justice, suffering, prayer, mission, and the hope of renewed creation. The goal would not be to create a checklist of doctrines to be completed once, but to establish a framework of theological formation that is intentionally revisited and deepened.
The doctrine of the Trinity provides an illustrative example. A church might devote an entire sermon series to the biblical foundations and historical development of Trinitarian theology. Yet the subject should not disappear for the following decade simply because the series has been completed. The Trinity should continually inform teaching about prayer, worship, creation, salvation, Christian community, baptism, and the ministry of the Holy Spirit. Congregants encounter the doctrine repeatedly within different biblical and practical contexts, gradually developing a more integrated theological understanding.
This approach reflects the importance of repetition in the ministry of Jesus. The disciples encountered recurring themes of servanthood, kingdom greatness, faith, prayer, and the necessity of the cross. Their understanding developed over time as Jesus returned to these subjects in new circumstances.
For pastoral planning, I would recommend organizing a congregational teaching map around several recurring fields of formation rather than a rigid sequence of isolated courses.
A Pastoral Teaching and Discipleship Map
Illustrative rhythms for a congregation, not a mandatory curriculum or prescribed biblical schedule
Area of formation
Suggested recurrence
Biblical narrative and hermeneutics
Continuous exposition, with dedicated interpretive training annually
God’s character and the Trinity
Regular reinforcement, with substantial treatment every 2–3 years
Jesus, covenant, kingdom, and atonement
Integrated throughout the year, with periodic focused series
Holy Spirit, spiritual gifts, and discernment
Annual attention and recurring practical engagement
Spiritual practices, prayer, and worship
Continuous practice, with seasonal teaching and mentoring
Marriage, family, friendship, and reconciliation
Regular relational formation, with periodic focused teaching
Justice, generosity, vocation, and public witness
Integrated into exposition and revisited through service opportunities
Suffering, lament, death, and resurrection hope
Regular pastoral teaching alongside care for actual suffering
Mission, evangelism, and discipleship
Continuous participation, with annual equipping and assessment
Leadership development and mentoring
Ongoing apprenticeship with periodic evaluation
The purpose of such a map is not to displace expository preaching or force biblical passages into a predetermined topical system. Rather, it encourages pastors to recognize the cumulative theological and formational effect of their teaching over the life of a congregation. A pastor might discover, for example, that the church regularly addresses personal morality while rarely teaching the biblical story of covenant, kingdom, and new creation. Another congregation might possess extensive doctrinal knowledge while giving comparatively little attention to reconciliation, hospitality, or the care of vulnerable people.
A congregational teaching map makes these imbalances visible. It also helps pastors select sermon series with greater theological and pastoral intentionality.
The selection of a sermon series should therefore involve several considerations: What does the biblical text itself demand? What theological subjects have been neglected? What questions or misunderstandings are emerging within the congregation? What practices require renewed attention? Where is the Spirit directing the community toward repentance, growth, or mission? How does the proposed series contribute to the church’s larger understanding of Scripture?
These questions do not guarantee an ideal preaching calendar, but they provide a more intentional alternative to selecting messages primarily because a topic seems interesting, timely, or likely to attract an audience.
Discipleship Beyond Sunday: Recovering the Shepherd’s Full Vocation
The most important implication of an intentional teaching strategy is that preaching cannot be expected to accomplish the entire task of discipleship by itself. A sermon may introduce, clarify, challenge, and reinforce biblical truth, but the formation of Christian character ordinarily requires sustained participation within a community of faith.
The New Testament provides several complementary expressions of this ministry. Acts 2:42–47 integrates teaching with fellowship, prayer, shared meals, and generosity. Acts 20:20 describes Paul’s ministry as both public and house-to-house. Colossians 3:16 envisions believers teaching and admonishing one another, while Ephesians 4:11–16 identifies the purpose of ministry leadership as equipping the saints for the work of ministry and the growth of the whole body.
In Ephesians 4:12, the term katartismos (καταρτισμός), often translated “equipping,” points toward preparing God’s people for their responsibilities. The pastor is not simply the person who performs religious ministry on behalf of the congregation. Pastoral leadership helps others become capable participants in the life and mission of the church.
A congregation committed to this understanding will recognize the value of multiple environments of formation. Sunday preaching provides corporate proclamation and a common theological framework. Small groups allow believers to wrestle with biblical teaching, pray together, confess struggles, and practice mutual encouragement. Personal mentorship provides opportunities for mature disciples to accompany those who are developing in faith. Deeper Bible-study gatherings enable the exploration of historical context, biblical languages, theological questions, and matters that cannot be adequately addressed within a typical sermon. Retreats, conferences, and study intensives create opportunities for concentrated reflection and fellowship. Shared meals, hospitality, service projects, pastoral counseling, and opportunities to participate in ministry provide contexts in which theological convictions are tested and embodied.
These environments should not be treated as unrelated programs competing for attention. They are complementary expressions of a common discipleship vocation. A sermon on forgiveness might be followed by small-group conversations about reconciliation, pastoral support for those navigating painful relationships, and practical opportunities to cultivate peacemaking. A series on the kingdom of God might connect with deeper biblical studies on covenant and eschatology, opportunities for local service, and mentoring relationships that help believers discern their own vocation.
The objective is not to keep congregants perpetually occupied with religious activities. Excessive programming can undermine the ordinary household, vocational, and relational settings in which discipleship must also take place. Rather, the objective is to provide meaningful environments in which biblical teaching becomes practiced wisdom.
The pastor, then, must think beyond the sermon calendar toward the entire formative life of the community. The question is no longer simply what will be preached on Sunday, but how the church will help people understand, practice, and pass on what is being taught.
The Ministry Think Tank
Another practice worthy of recovery is the communal dimension of sermon preparation. The contemporary pastor often develops messages in relative isolation, moving from personal study to manuscript preparation and finally to public delivery. While solitude and careful exegesis are indispensable, the New Testament’s vision of the church as a body possessing diverse gifts challenges the assumption that one individual necessarily possesses every insight required for faithful and pastorally effective proclamation.
Ephesians 4:11–16, 1 Corinthians 12–14, and Colossians 3:16 portray a community in which teaching, wisdom, discernment, encouragement, and mutual edification extend beyond a single leader. This does not eliminate the responsibility of pastors and teachers to interpret Scripture faithfully. It does suggest that the congregation’s gifts can meaningfully contribute to the preparation and application of biblical teaching.
As discussed in our earlier Expedition 44 article, The Message, the Method, and the Messenger, a ministry think tank offers one practical expression of this principle.¹⁰
A pastor might gather a small group of trusted participants two or three weeks before a planned sermon or series. The group could include other pastors, teachers, elders, individuals with theological training, counselors, younger and older believers, and people whose life experiences offer perspectives that the primary preacher may not possess.
The discussion would begin with the biblical text rather than a predetermined message. Participants might examine the literary setting, historical context, difficult interpretive questions, competing theological perspectives, and possible applications. They might identify where a proposed sermon risks oversimplification, where an illustration may unintentionally alienate or harm listeners, or where a familiar passage has been interpreted through assumptions that deserve further scrutiny.
For example, a series addressing marriage and covenant might benefit from the perspectives of married and single believers, widows, counselors, and those who have experienced relational trauma. A message concerning poverty or generosity could be enriched by people who understand economic hardship firsthand. A sermon addressing the role of women in ministry should not be developed without serious engagement with women who have studied, practiced, and reflected upon their calling.
Such conversations can also reveal the questions a congregation is actually asking. The pastor may enter preparation intending to answer one theological problem only to discover that the text raises a more pressing question for the community.
The think tank should not become a committee that determines biblical truth through majority opinion. Sound exegesis remains essential, and the primary preacher retains responsibility for the message. Nor should pastoral confidentiality be sacrificed in the pursuit of relevant illustrations. Rather, the process encourages humility, collaboration, and the recognition that God has distributed gifts throughout the body.
This practice also models discipleship. Participants are not simply supplying material for a better sermon; they are learning to handle Scripture responsibly, listen across differing perspectives, and participate in theological discernment. Sermon preparation itself becomes an environment of formation.
A mature preaching ministry should therefore aspire to do more than produce fifty excellent sermons each year. It should increasingly develop people capable of studying Scripture, discerning truth, mentoring others, and participating in the ongoing work of the kingdom.
Conclusion: The Pastor as Shepherd, Teacher, and Disciple-Maker
Perhaps one of the most important recoveries needed in contemporary ministry is a renewed understanding of what it means to be a pastor. The Greek poimēn (ποιμήν), translated “shepherd,” is not primarily a title for a professional religious communicator. It describes one entrusted with the care, guidance, protection, and nurture of a flock. In John 21:15–17, Jesus charges Peter to feed and tend his sheep. In Acts 20:28, Paul instructs the Ephesian elders to shepherd the church of God, while 1 Peter 5:2–3 calls elders to exercise oversight willingly, not as domineering authorities, but as examples to the flock. These passages present pastoral ministry as a responsibility for people, not merely for the delivery of messages.
There is something deeply challenging about the distance that can develop between this biblical vocation and contemporary pastoral practice. A minister may become extraordinarily skilled at sermon preparation, public communication, organizational leadership, and theological explanation while remaining largely absent from the ordinary lives of the people entrusted to that ministry. Yet Jesus’ example consistently brings leadership back into relationship. He knew his disciples, shared their experiences, recognized their weaknesses, challenged their misplaced ambitions, and entrusted them with responsibilities they were still learning to carry. His disciples did not simply learn his teachings; they learned his way of life.
Recovering this model does not mean every pastor must personally mentor every congregant or abandon the necessary responsibilities of public proclamation. The New Testament’s emphasis upon a plurality of leaders, shared gifts, and mutual ministry provides a healthier vision than concentrating all spiritual formation in one individual. Nevertheless, the pastor must help establish and personally embody a culture of discipleship. Sermons, small groups, shared meals, mentoring relationships, theological studies, pastoral conversations, and opportunities for ministry should not function as disconnected programs. They should belong to a coherent vision of helping people grow into the likeness of Christ.
Ultimately, the question facing aspiring preachers is not simply whether they can hold the attention of a congregation for thirty minutes. It is whether they are willing to give themselves to the long, patient, frequently inconvenient work of forming disciples. Jesus invited fishermen to leave their nets, not to become spectators of his ministry, but to walk with him, learn his ways, and eventually participate in the same mission. His invitation remains profoundly demanding. The church does not need to abandon preaching; it needs to recover the larger life of discipleship within which preaching belongs. We need shepherds who open the Scriptures and open their homes, who teach from the platform and walk alongside people in their struggles, who proclaim the kingdom and demonstrate its character, and who measure the fruitfulness of their leadership not merely by those who gather to hear them but by those who are learning to follow Jesus and teach others to do the same. The church was never intended to become an audience gathered around a religious personality. It was called to become a people walking in the Way of Jesus. And perhaps the greatest legacy of any pastor is not the sermons remembered after their ministry is finished, but the disciples who continue walking in that Way long after the pastor is gone.
Endnotes
1. Eckhard J. Schnabel, Acts, ZECNT (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 2012), commentary on Acts 2:42–47; Wayne A. Meeks, The First Urban Christians: The Social World of the Apostle Paul, 2nd ed. (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003). See also Larry W. Hurtado, At the Origins of Christian Worship: The Context and Character of Earliest Christian Devotion (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1999).
2. John R. W. Stott, Between Two Worlds: The Challenge of Preaching Today (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1982); Thomas G. Long, The Witness of Preaching, 3rd ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2016). Both works underscore the pastoral and theological significance of proclamation, although the critique of contemporary sermon-centered ministry developed here is the present article’s argument.
3. J. Richard Middleton, The Liberating Image: The Imago Dei in Genesis 1 (Grand Rapids: Brazos, 2005); John H. Walton, The Lost World of Genesis One: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate (Downers Grove, IL: IVP Academic, 2009).
4. Niek Veldhuis, Religion, Literature, and Scholarship: The Sumerian Composition Nanše and the Birds, CM 22 (Leiden: Brill, 2004); Christopher A. Rollston, Writing and Literacy in the World of Ancient Israel: Epigraphic Evidence from the Iron Age, ABS 11 (Atlanta: Society of Biblical Literature, 2010). For prophetic associations, see Joseph Blenkinsopp, A History of Prophecy in Israel, rev. and enl. ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 1996).
5. R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark: A Commentary on the Greek Text, NIGTC (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2002), commentary on Mark 1:16–20 and 3:13–19; Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, AB 27 (New York: Doubleday, 2000).
6. Catherine Hezser, The Social Structure of the Rabbinic Movement in Roman Palestine, TSAJ 66 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 1997); Shmuel Safrai, “Education and the Study of the Torah,” in The Jewish People in the First Century, ed. S. Safrai and M. Stern, CRINT 1.2 (Assen: Van Gorcum, 1976), 945–70. Later rabbinic evidence should be distinguished from direct first-century documentation.
7. Klyne R. Snodgrass, Stories with Intent: A Comprehensive Guide to the Parables of Jesus, 2nd ed. (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2018); France, Gospel of Mark, commentary on Mark 4.
8. Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke, NICNT (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1997), commentary on Luke 10:25–37; Expedition 44, “Who Is My Neighbor?,” September 2, 2026. For John 4 and 13, see Marianne Meye Thompson, John: A Commentary, NTL (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2015).
9. François Bovon, Luke 3: A Commentary on the Gospel of Luke 19:28–24:53, Hermeneia (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2012), commentary on Luke 24:13–35; N. T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God, Christian Origins and the Question of God 3 (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2003). The interpretation here emphasizes the movement from mistaken expectation to scriptural understanding, recognition, and renewed witness. I could not independently locate the more recent X44 article specifically devoted to Emmaus, so I have not attributed unverified arguments to it.
11. Frank Thielman, Ephesians, BECNT (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2010), commentary on Eph 4:11–16; David G. Peterson, The Acts of the Apostles, PNTC (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2009), commentary on Acts 20:17–38; Karen H. Jobes, 1 Peter, BECNT (Grand Rapids: Baker Academic, 2005), commentary on 1 Pet 5:1–4.
TKC homiletics discussion
Leaving the nets: How does the calling of the Twelve challenge contemporary models of church membership and the assumptions we make about the commitment involved in following Jesus?
The pastor’s vocation: If preaching is one dimension of shepherding, what should actually occupy a pastor’s time throughout the week? How would this affect the way churches evaluate pastoral success?
Long-term formation: If you were responsible for shepherding the same congregation for ten years, what biblical truths, theological disciplines, and kingdom practices would you want people to have encountered repeatedly?
Shared preparation: How might a sermon think tank strengthen both the biblical integrity of a message and the discipleship of those involved in preparing it?
Ask students to imagine that they have accepted responsibility for a congregation of seventy-five people and expect to pastor them for the next five years. Rather than writing a sermon series, have them design a pastoral discipleship philosophy. What will they teach repeatedly? How will they mentor emerging leaders? Where will serious biblical study happen? How will people practice what they are learning? What role will homes, meals, small groups, and ministry participation play? Finally, what will they do personally to remain accessible as shepherds rather than functioning only as weekly speakers?
The exercise should close with one question: If Jesus visited your congregation for six months, would he recognize your approach to making disciples as something resembling his own?
Design a Five-Year Congregational Discipleship and Teaching Map
Imagine you are pastoring a congregation for the next five years. What theological and doctrinal foundations do you want your people to understand, and how will you intentionally develop and reinforce those teachings over time? Consider which subjects deserve an entire sermon series, which need regular revisiting, and how you will account for the reality that many congregants do not attend consistently.
Your plan should extend well beyond Sunday preaching. How will you incorporate weekly Bible studies, small groups, mentoring, conferences, and other opportunities for discipleship? How will you provide theological direction and oversight for these ministries, particularly when others are leading them?
The goal is not simply to plan five years of sermons, but to develop an intentional strategy for forming mature disciples who understand Scripture, live out their faith, and disciple others.
Introduction: The Character of God and the Problem of Divine Violence
Among the most difficult theological questions in Scripture is the apparent tension between the revealed character of YHWH and the repeated biblical accounts of divine judgment involving the destruction of entire populations, including children and others who bear no identifiable personal responsibility for the offenses being judged. Throughout Scripture, God is revealed as compassionate, merciful, patient, covenantally faithful, and committed to the restoration of his creation. Yet the same biblical canon contains accounts in which God not only permits catastrophic loss of life but is explicitly presented as its initiating agent. These narratives include the destruction of humanity in the flood (Gen 6–9), the annihilation of Sodom and Gomorrah (Gen 19), the death of Egypt’s firstborn (Exod 12), the destruction of households associated with Korah’s rebellion (Num 16), the conquest of Jericho (Josh 6), the command to destroy the Amalekites, including infants and nursing children (1 Sam 15:3), and the death of David’s infant son following the king’s transgression (2 Sam 12:15–18). Taken together, these accounts present something considerably more difficult than an isolated passage requiring historical clarification. They raise a sustained theological problem concerning the relationship between divine sovereignty, human innocence, covenant judgment, and the very nature of God.
The difficulty becomes especially pronounced when these narratives are read alongside YHWH’s self-revelation in Exodus 34:6–7. Following Israel’s rebellion with the golden calf, God reveals himself to Moses as רַחוּם וְחַנּוּן (raḥûm weḥannûn), compassionate and gracious; אֶרֶךְ אַפַּיִם (ʾerekh ʾappayim), slow to anger; and רַב־חֶסֶד וֶאֱמֶת (rav-ḥesed weʾemet), abounding in covenant loyalty and faithfulness. The language is not incidental. It becomes one of the most frequently recalled confessions of God’s character in Israel’s theological memory, appearing in various forms throughout Numbers 14:18, Nehemiah 9:17, Psalms 86:15 and 103:8, Joel 2:13, and Jonah 4:2. The Hebrew raḥûm, associated with the verbal root רחם (rḥm), carries the semantic field of compassion and deep tenderness, while ḥesed communicates enduring loyalty expressed through covenantal relationship. These qualities are not merely occasional divine behaviors; they belong to Israel’s foundational confession concerning who YHWH is.[1]
The same confession, however, includes the difficult declaration that God does not simply leave guilt unaddressed and that the consequences of ancestral iniquity may extend into subsequent generations. Exodus 34:7 employs the expression פֹּקֵד עֲוֹן אָבוֹת עַל־בָּנִים (poqed ʿawon ʾavot ʿal-banim), conventionally understood as visiting the iniquity of fathers upon children. The verb paqad can denote attending to, overseeing, reckoning with, or bringing an account into consideration. The text therefore holds divine mercy and intergenerational accountability together, but it does not explicitly explain why morally innocent children would be subjected to death because of the failures of their parents. Indeed, the problem intensifies when we encounter Deuteronomy 24:16, which expressly prohibits putting children to death for their fathers’ sins, and Ezekiel 18:20, which declares that a child shall not bear the iniquity of the parent. These texts cannot simply be dismissed as unrelated legal technicalities. They reveal that personal responsibility is itself a concern of covenant justice. While Deuteronomy addresses human judicial conduct and does not directly legislate divine action, it raises an unavoidable question: how are we to understand the moral consistency of the God who commands justice among his people when biblical narratives attribute to that same God the destruction of persons who appear innocent of the offenses being punished?
Numbers 16 illustrates this tension with particular clarity. When Moses confronts the rebellion of Korah, Dathan, and Abiram, the narrative places the wives, sons, and little children of Dathan and Abiram at the entrances of their tents (Num 16:27). The Hebrew טַפָּם (ṭappām) refers to their little ones or dependents, emphasizing individuals who cannot reasonably be assumed to share the informed culpability of the rebellious leaders. Shortly afterward, the earth opens and swallows the households. Moses himself had already raised the moral question when he and Aaron appealed to God: would the sin of one man provoke divine anger against the entire congregation (Num 16:22)? The narrative then describes a judgment that appears to reach beyond the guilty. Numbers 26:11 subsequently clarifies that Korah’s sons did not die, an important qualification to any overly comprehensive reading of the destruction, but it does not establish that the children of Dathan and Abiram survived. The theological question remains whether the death of innocent dependents can properly be identified as an expression of the compassionate character revealed in Exodus 34.[2]
This difficulty is not overcome by distinguishing the God of the Hebrew Scriptures from the God revealed in Jesus Christ. Such a distinction would be foreign to the theological claims of the New Testament. Jesus identifies himself with the mission and purposes of Israel’s God, while the apostolic writings present him as the definitive revelation of the Father. Hebrews 1:1–3 describes the Son as the exact representation of God’s being, and John 1:18 presents the Son as the one who makes the unseen Father known. Jesus’ declaration in John 14:9, that whoever has seen him has seen the Father, places considerable interpretive weight upon his life and ministry. His treatment of enemies, children, outsiders, sinners, and the religiously excluded must therefore inform Christian reflection upon divine character. Jesus welcomes little children, commands love for enemies, rebukes disciples who wish to summon destructive fire upon a Samaritan village, and prays for those responsible for his execution (Luke 9:51–56; 18:15–17; 23:34). Nevertheless, the New Testament also preserves stern warnings of judgment, including sayings attributed to Jesus himself. A Christological hermeneutic cannot resolve the difficulty merely by identifying violence with the Old Testament and mercy with the New. The theological task is to understand how judgment and mercy coexist within the revelation of the one God whose character is made known in Christ.
This has long been, in my personal estimation, the most difficult theological problem to reconcile in the biblical canon. The problem is not primarily the existence of divine judgment. A God who never confronted evil, oppression, or covenant unfaithfulness could hardly be described as just. Rather, the difficulty concerns the destruction of those who are not themselves morally accountable for the rebellion being judged. A newborn Egyptian firstborn cannot meaningfully be assigned Pharaoh’s culpability. An Amalekite nursing infant cannot be treated as an informed participant in generations of hostility against Israel. David’s child cannot reasonably be held responsible for the king’s adultery and orchestration of Uriah’s death. The seriousness of human sin does not settle the question of the innocence of those who suffer because of it. Nor does a future benefit automatically establish the moral legitimacy of an earlier harm.
One may affirm that Scripture is coherent in its ultimate theological witness without claiming that every text is immediately reconcilable at the level of surface description. The challenge, then, is not to announce a contradiction within Scripture and abandon the question, nor to force the texts into agreement through assertions that leave their moral implications unexplored. It is to investigate whether the biblical canon itself provides categories for understanding divine judgment within a larger redemptive horizon. Traditional Christian theology has offered several important explanations, many of which preserve genuine biblical truths. Three approaches in particular deserve careful consideration. Yet, in my estimation, each leaves an unresolved difficulty and can require considerable theological maneuvering to reconcile the destruction of innocent people with God’s confessed compassion. I wish to explore another possibility, rooted in ancient Jewish understandings of death, the intermediate state, Christ’s proclamation to the dead, and the possibility that divine judgment, even when involving physical death, does not necessarily represent God’s final disposition toward those who perish.
Traditional Theological Explanations and Their Limitations
Divine Sovereignty and the Creator’s Prerogative over Life
The first traditional explanation appeals to the absolute sovereignty of God as creator and sustainer of life. Since life originates in God and remains dependent upon his sustaining will, God possesses authority over its beginning and termination in a manner that human beings do not. Deuteronomy 32:39 declares that YHWH kills and makes alive, wounds and heals, while 1 Samuel 2:6 similarly attributes both death and life to divine agency. Job’s confession that YHWH gives and takes away is frequently invoked to emphasize creaturely dependence upon divine providence. Within classical Christian theology, this account has often been developed through the distinction between divine authority over life and the moral limitations imposed upon human creatures. Human beings may not take innocent life because they do not possess unrestricted sovereignty over another person’s existence. God, however, as the giver of life, is understood to possess an authority that transcends ordinary human jurisdiction.[3]
There is considerable theological force in this argument. Any serious doctrine of creation must acknowledge that humanity does not exist autonomously and that divine authority cannot simply be reduced to human categories of legal ownership or moral jurisdiction. Yet sovereignty, by itself, establishes authority rather than demonstrating the goodness of a particular exercise of authority. The question is not whether God has the power to terminate physical life but why terminating the life of an innocent child would constitute an expression of divine justice or compassion. To argue that an action is morally good solely because God performs it risks making divine goodness indistinguishable from unrestricted power. Scripture, however, repeatedly invites reflection upon God’s actions according to recognizably moral categories. Abraham’s question in Genesis 18:25—whether the Judge of all the earth will do justice—presupposes that divine judgment is meaningfully connected to justice rather than exempt from its evaluation. Moses’ intercession in Numbers 16:22 similarly appeals to the apparent injustice of indiscriminate destruction.
A more developed doctrine of sovereignty therefore needs to distinguish between God’s rightful authority over human life, his moral purposes in the exercise of that authority, and the particular means through which his judgment is accomplished. Without these distinctions, the argument effectively becomes that God is necessarily just even where the reasons for his action remain inaccessible. Such an appeal may be consistent with certain understandings of providence, but it does not fully reconcile the moral tension. It relocates the tension into an assertion of unknowable divine prerogative. Moreover, the God revealed in Exodus 34 is not described merely as sovereign but as compassionate, patient, and faithful. A sufficient theological account must explain how sovereignty is exercised in accordance with those attributes rather than treating sovereignty as an answer that renders further moral inquiry unnecessary.
Corporate Solidarity and the Consequences of Covenant Rebellion
The second traditional explanation appeals to the corporate character of ancient Israelite society and the broader ancient Near Eastern understanding of household, kinship, and covenant identity. In this worldview, moral action was rarely conceived as affecting only the isolated individual. The Hebrew בַּיִת (bayit), meaning house or household, could encompass children, extended relatives, servants, possessions, and successive generations. The behavior of a household’s representative could affect the social, economic, political, and religious welfare of the entire group. Biblical narratives frequently operate within this corporate framework, particularly where rebellion threatens covenant identity or communal holiness. The account of Achan in Joshua 7, the destruction of the households in Numbers 16, and the judgment upon Egypt’s firstborn all reflect, in different ways, the collective dimensions of ancient covenant life. Such accounts should not be interpreted as though they were written within the individualistic moral assumptions of modern Western society.[4]
Corporate solidarity, however, describes the social framework within which the narratives operate; it does not independently demonstrate the moral legitimacy of every consequence experienced by members of the group. There is a meaningful distinction between recognizing that children suffer because of their parents’ decisions and affirming that those children deserve punishment for decisions they did not make. Indeed, the Torah itself complicates a simplistic corporate model. Deuteronomy 24:16 rejects substituting one generation for another in judicial execution, while Ezekiel 18 challenges the assumption that ancestral wrongdoing establishes the guilt of descendants. Jeremiah 31:29–30 similarly anticipates an understanding of responsibility in which individuals answer for their own wrongdoing. These texts need not eliminate every form of corporate consequence to establish the important principle that inherited consequences and inherited moral culpability are not synonymous.
The problem is particularly apparent where the narrative depicts God as directly initiating destruction rather than merely allowing a community to experience the foreseeable consequences of collective decisions. Children may suffer famine because of a king’s policies, but the moral question becomes more difficult when the text portrays God as intentionally destroying those children as part of judgment upon the king. The claim that the household constituted a single covenantal unit helps us understand why an ancient narrator might describe the event corporately. It does not explain why the God who prohibits the judicial execution of children for parental wrongdoing would enact a judgment involving their deaths. Corporate solidarity remains an indispensable historical consideration, but it cannot function as a complete theological reconciliation.
Progressive Revelation, Ancient Literary Conventions, and Divine Accommodation
A third approach locates the difficulty in the historical and literary character of biblical revelation. Ancient Near Eastern literature often attributed political, military, and natural events to divine agency, interpreting national victories and catastrophes through the theological assumptions of the communities preserving those traditions. Accounts of conquest could also employ sweeping destruction formulas, describing the elimination of entire populations in language that did not always correspond to literal demographic annihilation. Biblical texts participate in this literary environment while also revising its theological assumptions. The apparent tension between Joshua’s descriptions of comprehensive conquest and Judges’ accounts of surviving Canaanite populations illustrates why ancient victory rhetoric requires careful examination. Likewise, Numbers 16 displays literary complexities concerning the interwoven accounts of Korah and the Reubenite rebels, while Numbers 26:11 explicitly preserves the survival of Korah’s sons.[5]
This approach becomes more theologically significant when combined with progressive revelation. It proposes that divine revelation was received, narrated, and interpreted within the developing historical understanding of Israel, culminating in the revelation of God through Jesus Christ. The differing attributions of David’s census in 2 Samuel 24:1 and 1 Chronicles 21:1 provide a particularly interesting example: the former attributes the incitement to YHWH, while the latter attributes it to Satan. This difference does not necessarily establish that the earlier author was mistaken, since traditions of primary and secondary causation provide another plausible explanation. Nevertheless, it demonstrates that biblical texts may describe divine agency through differing theological perspectives. A Christocentric approach can therefore distinguish the inspired theological significance of a narrative from the assumption that every ancient description of divine causality constitutes an exhaustive explanation of God’s involvement.
The limitation is that this solution becomes increasingly difficult when applied universally to the biblical accounts of destructive judgment. We are not dealing with a single disputed metaphor or one ambiguous historical tradition. Across multiple literary genres and historical settings, Scripture repeatedly and explicitly associates YHWH with catastrophic destruction. To claim that these attributions consistently reflect inadequate ancient understandings of God places a considerable burden upon the doctrine of inspiration and upon the reliability of the narratives themselves. Literary conventions can help explain the language of total destruction but cannot be used indiscriminately to deny the deaths of children who are explicitly included within the accounts. Nor can progressive revelation become a convenient mechanism for rejecting every earlier text that challenges a preferred theological formulation. Although this model has substantial interpretive value, I remain unconvinced that it adequately resolves the cumulative moral problem. It may explain how the texts were written without fully addressing what their testimony implies about divine character.
Toward Another Possibility: Divine Judgment Within a Larger Redemptive Horizon
An alternative approach begins not by diminishing divine agency in the judgment narratives but by questioning whether physical death represents the termination of God’s redemptive dealings with those who die. Much traditional discussion assumes that the destruction of a person within a biblical judgment constitutes that individual’s final encounter with divine justice, or at least fixes irreversibly the person’s eternal condition. Yet this assumption deserves examination. The Hebrew Scriptures, Second Temple Jewish literature, and early Christian writings preserve an extensive range of traditions concerning the realm of the dead, the intermediate condition of departed persons, future resurrection, judgment beyond physical death, and the possibility of divine activity among those who have already died. Although these traditions do not establish a uniform doctrine of postmortem repentance, they provide a conceptual framework in which death and final judgment need not be understood as identical events.
The importance of this distinction becomes apparent when we return to the innocent victims of divine judgment. If physical death ends the possibility of any further encounter with divine grace, then the death of an innocent child appears not only tragic but potentially an irreversible exclusion from the fulfillment of that child’s created purpose. If, however, the dead remain within God’s redemptive horizon and await a resurrection in which justice, restoration, and reconciliation may yet be realized, the theological implications change considerably. A child killed during the destruction of Jericho or in the judgment upon Egypt would not necessarily have been rejected by God, even if the narrative attributes the catastrophe to divine judgment. This does not establish that the child’s death was morally necessary or justified. It does, however, challenge the assumption that temporal destruction and eternal condemnation must be understood as inseparable.
Such a proposal must avoid confusing three distinct claims. The first is that the dead exist in an intermediate condition before final resurrection and judgment. The second is that God may act redemptively toward persons in that condition, including through proclamation, revelation, or purification. The third is that all persons will eventually respond positively and experience complete reconciliation. The first has substantial support within Jewish and Christian eschatological traditions. The second is more contested but possesses important textual and historical witnesses. The third constitutes the much larger claim associated with universal reconciliation and remains a disputed question within Christian theology. My proposal does not depend initially upon affirming all three. It begins by asking whether the first two provide a more adequate framework for approaching the deaths of those who appear innocent within the biblical judgment narratives.
Sheol and the Intermediate State in Ancient Israelite Thought
The principal Hebrew designation for the realm of the dead is שְׁאוֹל (šĕʾôl), usually transliterated Sheol. Within the Hebrew Scriptures, Sheol is not consistently presented as the equivalent of later Christian conceptions of hell. It is the domain associated with the dead, the grave, darkness, silence, and separation from ordinary participation in earthly life. Jacob anticipates descending to Sheol in grief over Joseph (Gen 37:35), while Job describes Sheol as a place to which human beings descend irrespective of their earthly prosperity or suffering (Job 3:11–19; 7:9). Psalm 88 presents the realm of the dead as a place of profound darkness and abandonment, whereas Psalm 139:8 strikingly declares that even Sheol lies within the reach of God’s presence. These portrayals do not amount to a developed doctrine of the afterlife, but they resist the assumption that physical death necessarily constitutes a final judicial verdict concerning eternal destiny.[6]
The ancient Israelite conception of the person is also important. The Hebrew נֶפֶשׁ (nepeš) generally denotes a living being, life, or the person understood as a whole, rather than functioning consistently as the Greek philosophical concept of an independently immortal soul. Likewise, רוּחַ (rûaḥ) can refer to breath, wind, spirit, or the life-giving activity associated with God. Biblical anthropology is therefore not adequately summarized through a rigid separation between an immortal soul and a disposable material body. Resurrection, especially as it develops in later biblical literature, concerns the vindication and restoration of embodied human existence. Daniel 12:2 is particularly significant because it anticipates the awakening of those who sleep in the dust, some to everlasting life and others to shame and contempt. Isaiah 26:19 similarly expresses the hope that the dead shall live and rise. These passages establish that death does not necessarily exhaust the possibility of future divine judgment or restoration.
The idea of an intermediate condition becomes more developed in Second Temple Jewish literature. First Enoch 22 presents a visionary account of the souls of the dead gathered within distinct compartments while awaiting an appointed day of judgment. The angel Raphael explains that these places have been prepared to receive the dead until the great judgment. Particularly notable is the portrayal of Abel, whose spirit continues to appeal for justice after his murder. Here the dead are not simply absent from divine concern. Their condition remains connected to unresolved justice, and their final disposition lies in the future. However, this passage should not be overstated. First Enoch 22 does not clearly teach universal postmortem repentance; indeed, its different compartments include severe expectations for the wicked. Its significance for the present argument is more limited but still substantial: death and final judgment are differentiated, and the dead await an eschatological resolution beyond their earthly circumstances.[7]
A related but somewhat different picture appears in 4 Ezra 7:75–101, a Jewish apocalypse written in the aftermath of the destruction of Jerusalem. The text describes the experiences of departed spirits before the final renewal of creation, distinguishing the condition of the righteous from that of the wicked. The dead are conscious of their moral history and of the judgment that awaits them. Yet this witness also exposes a significant obstacle to any easy doctrine of a second opportunity, since 4 Ezra 7:82 expressly describes the wicked as unable to repent in order to obtain life after death. This evidence is important because Second Temple Judaism was not theologically uniform. Some Jewish traditions imagined an intermediate realm in which the dead awaited judgment, while others strongly emphasized the irreversible consequences of earthly decisions. An appeal to Jewish eschatology must therefore acknowledge diversity rather than treating the entire period as though it possessed a single, established doctrine of postmortem conversion.[8]
The parable of the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16:19–31 reflects this larger world of Jewish eschatological imagination. The dead are depicted as conscious, differentiated in their circumstances, and awaiting a larger eschatological fulfillment. Lazarus rests in Abraham’s bosom, while the rich man experiences anguish in Hades. The Greek ᾅδης (hadēs), regularly used in the Septuagint for Hebrew Sheol, designates the realm of the dead and does not necessarily carry every later theological association attached to the English term hell. The narrative also describes a great chasm separating the two conditions, a detail that must be taken seriously by any proposal concerning postmortem repentance. Whether this parable should be interpreted as a literal geography of the intermediate state remains disputed; its primary rhetorical concern is the reversal of earthly status and the responsibility to heed Moses and the prophets. Nevertheless, it confirms that Jesus could employ a recognizable Jewish conceptual framework in which death did not immediately eliminate consciousness, moral differentiation, or expectation.
Christ’s Descent to the Dead: The Gospel Beyond the Grave
The Christian confession that Jesus descended to the dead introduces a potentially decisive development. Within early Christian theology, the death and resurrection of Jesus were not merely events occurring among the living but constituted a victory extending into the realm of death itself. The Apostles’ Creed eventually articulated this conviction through the confession that Christ descended to the dead, traditionally expressed in Latin as descendit ad inferos. This formulation should not automatically be equated with the claim that Jesus entered the place of final condemnation or suffered additional punishment there. Rather, in important strands of historic Christian interpretation, the descent signifies that Christ truly entered the condition of the departed and that his redemptive victory extends beyond the boundaries of earthly life. The precise nature of that descent, its beneficiaries, and the content of Christ’s activity there have been debated throughout Christian history.[9]
First Peter 3:18–20 is central to the discussion. Following the statement that Christ suffered for sins, the righteous for the unrighteous, the author declares that Christ was put to death in the flesh but made alive in the spirit, ἐν ᾧ καὶ τοῖς ἐν φυλακῇ πνεύμασιν πορευθεὶς ἐκήρυξεν (en hō kai tois en phylakē pneumasin poreutheis ekēryxen), commonly rendered as a proclamation made to the spirits in prison. The verb κηρύσσω (kēryssō) means to proclaim or herald and does not by itself establish that the message offered repentance or salvation. The reference to the days of Noah is especially intriguing because it connects Christ’s proclamation to one of the most devastating accounts of corporate destruction in the Hebrew Scriptures. If the imprisoned spirits are interpreted as deceased human beings from the flood generation, the text would appear to demonstrate that those who experienced catastrophic judgment were not thereby beyond the reach of Christ’s proclamation.
There are, however, substantial interpretive disagreements. Some understand the spirits as the rebellious heavenly beings associated with Genesis 6 and the Watchers traditions preserved in First Enoch 6–15. In this interpretation, Christ announces his victory over imprisoned cosmic powers rather than extending salvation to deceased human beings. Others understand Christ to have preached through Noah to people who were alive before the flood but are now described as imprisoned spirits. A third interpretation, prominent in portions of early Christian tradition, understands the passage as Christ’s proclamation to the human dead during his descent. These possibilities cannot be collapsed into a single uncontroversial reading. The Enochic context provides strong support for the angelic interpretation, while the broader history of interpretation demonstrates that a proclamation to the human dead was an early and influential Christian understanding.[10]
First Peter 4:6 presents an equally important and perhaps more promising passage: εἰς τοῦτο γὰρ καὶ νεκροῖς εὐηγγελίσθη (eis touto gar kai nekrois euēngelisthē), commonly translated, “For this reason the gospel was preached even to the dead.” Unlike the verb employed in 3:19, εὐαγγελίζομαι (euangelizomai) explicitly denotes the proclamation of good news. The passage continues by describing a purpose in which people, though judged according to human standards in the flesh, might live according to God in the spirit. The central disagreement concerns whether the recipients were already dead when the gospel was proclaimed or whether they heard the gospel during earthly life and subsequently died. David Horrell has argued that the former interpretation remains more defensible than many modern commentators acknowledge. If so, the passage provides meaningful textual grounds for investigating the possibility that the redemptive proclamation of Christ reaches beyond physical death.[11]
The importance of this possibility should not be minimized, particularly when considering the flood narrative. If those who died during Noah’s generation remained subjects of divine concern and encountered the proclamation of Christ, then their physical destruction did not necessarily constitute God’s final word concerning them. A judgment that terminated their historical existence could still be followed by an opportunity to encounter divine truth. Such an interpretation would not establish that all responded favorably, nor would it demonstrate that the deaths themselves were morally justified. Nevertheless, it would significantly modify the assumption that divine destruction and eternal exclusion must coincide. The God revealed as compassionate in Exodus 34 might continue to extend mercy even beyond the temporal judgments attributed to him within Israel’s historical narratives.
Paradise, Abraham’s Bosom, and the Thief on the Cross
Jesus’ exchange with the repentant criminal in Luke 23:39–43 provides another important dimension. As one of the crucified men appeals to Jesus to remember him when he comes into his kingdom, Jesus responds that the man will be with him in paradise. The Greek παράδεισος (paradeisos) derives from an older Iranian term associated with an enclosed garden or park and appears in the Greek Scriptures in connection with garden imagery, particularly Eden. Within Jewish and early Christian eschatological discourse, paradise could designate a place or condition of blessedness associated with the righteous dead and the anticipated renewal of creation. Jesus’ promise therefore suggests fellowship with him beyond the immediate event of physical death, even though the thief will not live to participate in the earthly ministry of the emerging church.
This passage is commonly joined with the traditions of Abraham’s bosom and Christ’s descent to suggest that the righteous dead awaited the fulfillment of redemption within a blessed intermediate condition. Such an association is theologically plausible, though the relevant texts do not explicitly identify paradise and Abraham’s bosom as identical locations. Nor does Luke 23 independently demonstrate that the thief descended with Jesus into precisely the same realm described in 1 Peter 3. The account primarily establishes that the thief’s death does not prevent his participation in the saving presence of Jesus. The familiar debate concerning the placement of the comma in Jesus’ statement also deserves mention, since the earliest Greek manuscripts did not contain modern punctuation. The conventional reading attaches “today” to Jesus’ promise of companionship, and this remains the most natural reading in the immediate Lukan context, although alternative punctuation has been proposed.
The broader theological implication concerns the ability of Christ’s presence to transcend physical death. If the thief can enter into communion with Christ beyond the grave, and if Christ’s descent involves the proclamation of divine victory or good news among the dead, then the intermediate state may need to be understood not merely as passive waiting but as a domain reached by the Messiah’s redemptive accomplishment. This is compatible with the historic Christian confession of Christ’s descent, but a crucial distinction must be retained: the descent of Christ to liberate the righteous dead is a historically orthodox Christian teaching; the assertion that all deceased persons receive a new opportunity for repentance is a further, disputed theological proposal. The Roman Catholic Catechism, for example, explicitly affirms Christ’s descent to the realm of the dead while distinguishing his liberation of the righteous from the deliverance of the damned. It therefore supports the larger doctrine of Christ’s activity among the dead without endorsing an unrestricted postmortem offer of salvation.[12]
This distinction is essential for the argument. It would be historically inaccurate to describe universal postmortem conversion as the established orthodox doctrine of the early church. Yet it would be equally inaccurate to suggest that Christian tradition uniformly imagined death as a boundary beyond which Christ exercised no further redemptive activity. The descent tradition stands as an important witness that the victory of Jesus extends into the realm of those who died before his historical ministry. The question is whether this reality should be understood as an exceptional event associated with the transition between the covenants or as the disclosure of something enduring about the redemptive character of God.
Prayer for the Dead and the Possibility of Postmortem Reconciliation
A further dimension emerges from Jewish practices associated with the remembrance of the dead and the expectation of resurrection. The clearest pre-Christian Jewish textual witness to prayer on behalf of the dead appears in 2 Maccabees 12:38–46. Following a battle in which Jewish soldiers were killed, Judas Maccabeus and his companions discovered forbidden objects associated with idolatry among the possessions of the fallen. The community prayed that the offense might be forgiven, and Judas collected funds to provide an offering at Jerusalem. The narrator explicitly connects this action to the expectation of resurrection, arguing that prayer for the dead would be meaningless if the fallen were not expected to rise again. This is a remarkable witness to the conviction that the moral and eschatological condition of the deceased remained within the concern of the living covenant community.[13]
The historical setting needs to be understood accurately. The passage describes a collection for a purification offering in Jerusalem, not the construction of individual altars over the graves of the dead. Although burial sites, memorial practices, and care for ancestors were known throughout the ancient Near East, the Hebrew Bible does not establish a normative system of erecting altars to pray deceased Israelites into reconciliation. Indeed, the Torah sharply restricts ritual engagement with the dead, particularly where necromancy and the consultation of departed spirits are concerned (Deut 18:10–12). The intercession described in 2 Maccabees belongs to a different category from the forbidden attempt to obtain information or power from the dead. Its theological concern is that those who have died remain persons for whom forgiveness and future resurrection are meaningful realities.
The canonical status of 2 Maccabees differs among Christian traditions. It is received as Scripture in Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox contexts, while most Protestant traditions classify it among the Apocrypha rather than the canonical books of the Old Testament. Regardless of one’s canonical commitments, the account provides important evidence for the theological imagination of Second Temple Judaism. It also became significant for later Christian discussions of prayer for the dead, purification, and the intermediate state. The Catholic doctrine of purgatory should not simply be identified with universal reconciliation or an unrestricted second chance after death. Within Catholic theology, purgatory concerns the purification of those already destined for salvation, not a general postmortem conversion of the finally unrepentant. Nevertheless, the practice of praying for the dead reflects the broader conviction that the departed are not beyond God’s concern and that the living community continues to participate in hope for their eschatological well-being.
The language of reconciliation provides an important theological framework for interpreting such practices. If persons who died in sin may still be objects of prayer, and if the efficacy of those prayers is associated with future resurrection, then the community’s relationship to the dead is not defined exclusively by the finality of earthly circumstances. They remain brothers, sisters, ancestors, and members of a history that God has not yet fully brought to completion. This does not establish that every deceased person can repent after death, but it demonstrates that portions of Jewish and Christian tradition have refused to regard the boundary of physical death as the termination of every meaningful relationship between the departed and God’s redemptive purposes.
Judgment, Refinement, and the Destruction of Evil
Any account of postmortem restoration must also consider whether divine judgment is fundamentally retributive, corrective, restorative, or some combination of these. The Hebrew Scriptures employ a variety of metaphors for judgment, including fire, refining, cleansing, and purification. Malachi 3:2–3 describes YHWH as a refiner’s fire and fullers’ soap, purifying the descendants of Levi so that their offerings may once again be acceptable. Isaiah 1:25 similarly depicts divine action as the removal of dross, while Isaiah 4:4 associates cleansing with a spirit of judgment and burning. These passages reveal an important biblical pattern: the purpose of divine judgment may be the removal of impurity rather than the annihilation of the person or community undergoing purification. Judgment, in such contexts, serves covenant restoration.
This restorative dimension is also reflected in texts concerning the nations. Isaiah 19:22 declares that YHWH will strike Egypt, striking and healing, and that the Egyptians will return to YHWH, who will respond to their pleas and heal them. The Hebrew pairing of נָגַף (nāgap, to strike) and רָפָא (rāpāʾ, to heal) is theologically arresting. Egypt, the nation associated with Israel’s oppression and the death of the firstborn, is nevertheless imagined as a people capable of returning to YHWH and receiving divine healing. Isaiah 19:23–25 extends the vision further, presenting Egypt and Assyria alongside Israel within an extraordinary oracle of blessing. Such passages make it difficult to regard national judgment as necessarily synonymous with irrevocable national rejection. The prophetic imagination is capable of envisioning the restoration of peoples previously subjected to divine destruction or condemnation.
Hosea 11:8–9 likewise portrays YHWH’s compassion in striking tension with impending judgment. God’s heart recoils at the prospect of delivering Ephraim to destruction, and the declaration that God is divine rather than human becomes the reason for restraint rather than a justification for unlimited wrath. Lamentations 3:31–33 similarly declares that the Lord will not reject forever and that affliction does not arise willingly from his heart. The Hebrew expression מִלִּבּוֹ (millibbô), literally “from his heart,” is particularly significant. The passage acknowledges divine affliction while distinguishing it from God’s fundamental disposition toward his people. Although these texts concern particular covenant communities and should not automatically be universalized to every human being, they establish a genuine prophetic pattern in which judgment is situated within a larger movement toward compassion, healing, and restoration.
The New Testament expands this imagery through its account of judgment by fire. First Corinthians 3:13–15 describes the testing of human works, some of which are consumed while the person is saved through fire. Paul is addressing the work of Christian builders and ministers, so the passage should not be treated as a direct exposition of universal postmortem purification. Nevertheless, it demonstrates that destructive fire and personal salvation are not necessarily mutually exclusive theological categories. Hebrews 12:5–11 likewise portrays divine discipline as ordered toward holiness, though its immediate concern is God’s formation of his children during their earthly lives. These passages provide conceptual resources for distinguishing the destruction of what is evil from the ultimate destruction of those in whom evil has taken root.
A significant historical development of this understanding appears in the theology of Gregory of Nyssa. In his reflections on the soul, resurrection, freedom, and the final restoration of creation, Gregory develops a conception of purification in which evil is removed so that the created person may be restored toward the goodness for which humanity was intended. His thought participates in a larger early Christian discussion concerning ἀποκατάστασις (apokatastasis), or restoration, associated also with Origen and later theological debates. The precise relationship between Gregory’s thought and modern universalism requires careful qualification, but his work demonstrates that the relationship between judgment, purification, and ultimate restoration was a serious concern within patristic theology rather than merely a modern attempt to soften difficult biblical texts.[14]
The moral implications for the present discussion are significant. If judgment is understood as restorative rather than exclusively retaliatory, then those who die under divine judgment may not necessarily be understood as permanently excluded from the possibility of communion with God. Yet an essential distinction must again be maintained concerning innocent children. A child killed as part of a corporate judgment does not require purification from the guilt of a rebellion in which the child did not participate. Any account of restoration must therefore recognize the difference between the correction of genuine moral evil and the healing of innocent persons who suffered through the actions of others. The former may involve repentance and refinement; the latter requires vindication, resurrection, and the restoration of a life prematurely interrupted. A theology that subjects innocent children to punitive purification for ancestral offenses would merely recreate the original moral problem in the afterlife.
Universal Reconciliation and the Scope of Christ’s Victory
The possibility that God’s redemptive activity continues beyond physical death naturally leads to the larger question of universal reconciliation. Within Christian theology, this view is often called universal reconciliation, Christian universalism, or, in certain historical contexts, apokatastasis. Although these expressions are not always interchangeable, they share an interest in whether God’s ultimate victory over evil includes the eventual restoration of every human person. This differs from the narrower claim that Christ proclaimed good news to some of the pre-Christian dead. Universal reconciliation proposes that divine judgment, however severe, does not finally defeat God’s restorative purposes and that the consummation of redemption results in the reconciliation of all persons to God.
Several Pauline passages provide significant material for this discussion. Romans 5:18–19 establishes a sweeping correspondence between Adam’s trespass and Christ’s righteous act. The Greek expression εἰς πάντας ἀνθρώπους (eis pantas anthrōpous), “to all human beings,” appears within Paul’s contrast between condemnation through Adam and justification leading to life through Christ. Universalist interpreters emphasize the parallel scope of these statements, arguing that the redemptive work of Christ is presented as no less comprehensive than the consequences of Adam’s transgression. Other interpreters maintain that the universal language describes the extent or availability of Christ’s saving accomplishment without necessarily asserting the salvation of every individual. The interpretive question concerns whether Paul’s parallelism implies an identical final population on both sides or whether the broader argument introduces distinctions concerning those who receive the gift of grace.
First Corinthians 15:22–28 offers a related but distinct argument. Paul declares that as all die in Adam, so all will be made alive in Christ, before describing the defeat of every opposing rule and authority and the destruction of death itself. The eschatological culmination occurs when the Son subjects all things to the Father so that God may be πάντα ἐν πᾶσιν (panta en pasin), “all in all.” The Greek vocabulary is expansive, although interpreters debate whether being made alive in Christ refers to universal resurrection or universal salvific participation. It is also necessary to distinguish the subjection of hostile powers from their reconciliation. Yet the passage unquestionably places the destruction of death within the larger accomplishment of Christ’s reign. Death is not presented as God’s final victory over humanity but as the last enemy overcome by the Messiah.
Colossians 1:19–20 may provide an even more direct theological statement concerning the scope of reconciliation. The text declares God’s purpose to reconcile τὰ πάντα (ta panta), “all things,” through Christ, making peace through the blood of his cross, whether things on earth or things in heaven. The verb ἀποκαταλλάσσω (apokatallassō) denotes reconciliation, and the cosmic scope of Paul’s language has generated considerable discussion regarding whether the final renewal encompasses the restoration of every rational creature or the comprehensive ordering of creation under Christ’s victorious lordship. Philippians 2:9–11 likewise anticipates every knee bowing and every tongue confessing the lordship of Jesus Christ, echoing Isaiah 45:23. The confession may be understood as willing worship or as universal acknowledgment of divine sovereignty, depending upon the interpreter’s broader theological commitments. Acts 3:21 adds the expression χρόνων ἀποκαταστάσεως πάντων (chronōn apokatastaseōs pantōn), referring to the times of restoration of all things spoken through the prophets. In context, this concerns the promised restoration of God’s purposes; whether it includes the eventual salvation of every individual is debated.
The universalist reading must also account for passages that appear to establish the possibility of definitive exclusion or destruction. Matthew 25:46 contrasts eternal punishment with eternal life, employing αἰώνιος (aiōnios) in both expressions. The word is related to αἰών (aiōn), meaning an age, but its contextual usage can express enduring or everlasting duration. It is therefore linguistically inadequate simply to assert that aiōnios always means temporary or age-limited. Second Thessalonians 1:9 speaks of everlasting destruction, while Revelation 20:11–15 portrays a final judgment involving the lake of fire and the second death. Hebrews 9:27 describes death followed by judgment, a sequence that provides little direct support for an unrestricted series of postmortem opportunities. These texts constitute substantial challenges to universal reconciliation and cannot be dismissed merely by appealing to divine love.
My own position remains one of cautious theological hope rather than settled universalist conviction. I find the universal scope of Christ’s victory, the prophetic anticipation of restored nations, and the early Christian traditions of divine activity among the dead compelling enough to resist confidently declaring that God’s redemptive purposes necessarily terminate at physical death. At the same time, I do not believe the biblical evidence establishes with sufficient clarity that every person will ultimately repent or that all eschatological judgment must be understood as temporary purification. The strength of hopeful universal reconciliation lies in its insistence that God’s mercy and Christ’s victory may possess a greater eschatological reach than conventional theological systems sometimes allow. Its weakness arises when a legitimate theological hope is presented as an exegetically certain conclusion despite the serious counterevidence.
The Central Unresolved Question: Did Christ’s Descent Establish a Pattern for All Humanity?
The most important issue for this proposal is therefore not simply whether Jesus descended to the dead, but whether the redemptive significance of that descent extends beyond those who died before his historical incarnation. Within traditional Christian interpretation, the descent is frequently understood as the liberation of the righteous who awaited the fulfillment of God’s promises. This raises an important historical distinction. Those who lived before the death and resurrection of Christ could not have responded to the gospel in precisely the same historical circumstances as those who encountered its proclamation afterward. The descent tradition thus provides a theological account of how Christ’s saving accomplishment reaches backward into human history. But does the same redemptive logic reach forward to those who die after the resurrection without having adequately encountered, understood, or responded to the Christ and His gospel?
The question is sharpened by the universal scope of Christ’s work. If his death and resurrection constitute the decisive defeat of sin, death, and the hostile powers, it is reasonable to ask whether the boundaries of physical existence restrict the reach of that victory. Romans 8:38–39 insists that neither death nor life can separate believers from the love of God in Christ Jesus, although the immediate promise concerns those already participating in that relationship. Revelation 1:18 presents the risen Jesus as possessing the keys of Death and Hades. The imagery communicates authority over the realm that previously held humanity captive. Yet authority over death does not, by itself, establish that every person within that realm will eventually experience reconciliation.
One theological possibility is that the descent of Christ discloses something enduring about God’s relationship to the dead: that judgment is not necessarily the cessation of divine address, and that the revelation of Christ may reach persons whose earthly lives ended before they possessed a meaningful opportunity to respond. Such a possibility is especially relevant to the innocent victims of biblical catastrophe, including infants and young children whose developmental condition renders the categories of conscious rebellion, repentance, and informed covenant allegiance inapplicable. In their case, the central issue is not necessarily a second opportunity for repentance but the fulfillment of a created destiny that earthly death prevented them from experiencing. Any coherent account must preserve the distinction between those who knowingly resist the good and those whose lives end before such a response is possible.
A further question concerns the scope of divine knowledge and human freedom. If God desires all people to be saved and to come to the knowledge of the truth, as 1 Timothy 2:4 declares, does the divine provision of saving grace necessarily cease at the moment of physical death? Conversely, if Scripture warns that judgment follows death, what grounds exist for asserting that opportunities for repentance remain available afterward? Neither question can be answered merely through an appeal to sovereignty. A robust theological account must explain how God’s desire for reconciliation, the reality of human response, the seriousness of evil, and the finality of eschatological judgment belong together. The possibility of postmortem proclamation should not be employed to diminish the urgency of discipleship, repentance, reconciliation, or participation in the kingdom of God during earthly life.
This brings the discussion back to the destruction of the innocent. Suppose the narratives of the flood, the Egyptian firstborn, Jericho, Amalek, and Numbers 16 describe genuine historical acts of divine judgment. Suppose also that those who perished were not universally or individually guilty of the offenses that precipitated the judgments. If the dead remain within the possibility of divine restoration, then physical destruction and final condemnation need not be identified. Those who died might yet encounter the righteous judgment and reconciling presence of Christ. For morally guilty persons, this could involve exposure, repentance, and transformation. For innocent victims, it would involve vindication, healing, and resurrection. Yet the possibility of such an outcome does not demonstrate that the initial deaths were necessary, proportionate, or morally justified. Any eventual reconciliation would need to address the original harm rather than merely render it insignificant.
The emerging theological proposal, then, is neither a denial of the biblical judgments nor an unqualified endorsement of universalism. It is an investigation into whether the biblical distinction between death and final judgment, the Second Temple expectation of an intermediate state, the Christian confession of Christ’s descent, and the possibility of eschatological restoration provide a more coherent framework for understanding divine violence. The central question remains whether temporal judgment can be distinguished from ultimate divine intention without weakening the moral force of the suffering described in the narratives. If God’s ultimate purpose is reconciliation, how does that purpose govern our understanding of judgments that appear to destroy the innocent? And if Christ’s victory reaches into the realm of the dead, what theological grounds exist for limiting that victory to those who died before his resurrection?
These are questions that require further examination before a conclusion concerning divine violence and ultimate reconciliation can responsibly be drawn.
Conclusion
Perhaps the greatest challenge in wrestling with these passages is not whether we can develop a theological framework capable of explaining every difficult act attributed to God, but whether we can emerge from that examination with greater confidence in the character of the One we worship. I have spent much of my life studying Scripture, teaching theology, and seeking to understand the nature of God through the Hebrew Scriptures, the world of Second Temple Judaism, and the revelation of Jesus Christ. Yet few questions have challenged me more deeply than the apparent destruction of innocent lives within the biblical accounts of divine judgment. I remain convinced that we do neither Scripture nor the character of God any service when we attempt to resolve these difficulties with simplistic appeals to sovereignty or assertions that whatever God does must necessarily be good, regardless of whether we can recognize goodness in the action itself. Biblical faith invites something more substantial. Abraham appealed to the justice of God, Moses appealed to his mercy, and the prophets repeatedly called Israel to understand YHWH through his covenant faithfulness. Their confidence was not rooted in the absence of difficult questions but in the conviction that God’s character was worthy of their deepest trust.
What encourages me most is that the biblical story does not end in the grave, nor does it culminate in the triumph of judgment over mercy. It culminates in Jesus Christ, who entered our suffering, embraced our mortality, descended into death, and emerged victorious over the very enemy that has held humanity captive since Eden. Whatever conclusions we ultimately reach concerning the intermediate state, postmortem repentance, or universal reconciliation, we cannot overlook the extraordinary significance of a God who refuses to leave his creation abandoned to death. The resurrection declares that death does not possess the final authority over human existence. This is particularly meaningful when considering those whose lives were interrupted through violence, catastrophe, injustice, or circumstances beyond their control. If our theology leaves us imagining that the innocent have somehow slipped beyond the reach of God’s compassion, I believe we have not yet taken seriously enough the implications of the resurrection.
I find myself increasingly drawn to the possibility that God’s redemptive work is far more extensive than the boundaries we have traditionally placed around it. I remain cautiously hopeful concerning universal reconciliation, though not convinced that Scripture permits us to declare it an inevitable outcome. Nevertheless, I am deeply convinced that the God revealed in Jesus has not surrendered his commitment to justice, mercy, or the restoration of creation. His judgments must ultimately be understood within that larger purpose, even where we lack the information necessary to explain their particular historical expression. I cannot confidently tell someone why an innocent child died in the judgment upon Egypt, in the conquest of Jericho, or in the destruction described in Numbers 16. Nor am I willing to suggest that such a child deserved death simply because the narrative associates the event with divine judgment. What I can affirm is that the same biblical witness which confronts us with those troubling accounts also reveals a God who hears the cries of the oppressed, remembers the forgotten, defends the vulnerable, and ultimately defeats death through the resurrection of his Son.
This understanding has profound implications for the way we live. Our theology of judgment inevitably shapes our posture toward those we believe have failed, rebelled, or wandered from the purposes of God. If we imagine divine holiness primarily through destruction, we may begin to regard condemnation, exclusion, and punishment as the highest expressions of faithfulness. But when we understand holiness through the life of Jesus, we encounter a different pattern. Jesus does not minimize evil or deny the seriousness of sin. He confronts it relentlessly, yet he moves toward the sinner with the possibility of repentance, healing, and restoration. His response to human brokenness is neither indifference nor a sentimental dismissal of accountability. It is a costly and courageous commitment to reconciliation. If this is how God has made himself known, then those who claim to follow him should be recognized not by their eagerness to announce judgment but by their willingness to participate in the ministry of reconciliation.
For the church, this means that we must recover a confidence in the goodness of God that produces goodness within us. We should be the first to defend the innocent, protect children, pursue justice for the vulnerable, and resist every temptation to justify suffering simply because it can be incorporated into a theological system. We should approach those who are spiritually wounded with compassion rather than suspicion, those who have rebelled with a genuine invitation to return, and those who are grieving with the hope that no tragedy is beyond God’s capacity to redeem. This is not a diminished view of divine judgment. It is a conviction that judgment, properly understood, must never be detached from the righteous and compassionate character of the Judge. The God who calls his people to practice mishpat, love ḥesed, and walk humbly with him (Mic 6:8) cannot be honored by a theology that treats justice and mercy as opposing interests.
I also believe this conversation should produce a deeper humility concerning the eternal destiny of others. We are frequently more confident about the boundaries of God’s mercy than Scripture authorizes us to be. We sometimes speak as though we possess exhaustive knowledge of what occurs beyond death, who has received a sufficient opportunity to respond to God, and precisely how divine judgment will unfold in the age to come. Yet the apostolic witness repeatedly directs our attention away from human mastery of these mysteries and toward the faithfulness of Christ. Our responsibility is to proclaim the gospel, call people to repentance, embody the kingdom, and participate in God’s reconciling work here and now. We need not diminish the urgency of that calling in order to hope that God’s mercy extends further than our present understanding. Christian hope is not a substitute for discipleship; it is one of the reasons discipleship can be pursued with such confidence and joy.
Ultimately, I return to the confession of Exodus 34 with a deeper appreciation for its theological significance. When YHWH revealed himself to Moses as compassionate and gracious, slow to anger, and abounding in covenant faithfulness, he gave Israel something far more enduring than an abstract definition of divine goodness. He disclosed the character upon which an entire covenant relationship could be established. That revelation finds its fullest Christian expression in Jesus, who demonstrates what divine faithfulness looks like when confronted with human violence, betrayal, rejection, and death. The cross does not reveal a God reluctantly persuaded to become merciful. It reveals the costly depths of the mercy that has always belonged to him. The resurrection then declares that neither human evil nor death itself can ultimately overthrow God’s redemptive purposes.
I may never possess a completely satisfying explanation for every biblical account of the destruction of the innocent. I am increasingly comfortable acknowledging that limitation without surrendering my confidence in Scripture or the character of God. Theological maturity does not require us to defend every difficult passage with equal certainty. It requires us to remain faithful to what God has made known while continuing to wrestle with what we do not yet understand. And what God has made known most clearly in Jesus is that his heart is directed toward the healing of the broken, the recovery of the lost, the reconciliation of enemies, and the restoration of his creation.
My hope, therefore, rests not in my ability to explain every divine judgment but in the One who has conquered death. I trust that the Judge of all the earth will indeed do what is right, not because justice is whatever divine power declares it to be, but because righteousness, compassion, and covenant faithfulness belong to the very character of God. I cannot tell you with certainty how every innocent life lost within the biblical narratives will be accounted for in the age to come. But I can hope, with substantial biblical and theological reason, that not one of those lives is forgotten, that resurrection places them within the reach of God’s final justice, and that the mercy revealed in Jesus is more profound than our present understanding of judgment allows us to comprehend.
And perhaps that is where this difficult theological journey should leave us: not with diminished concern for justice, not with indifference toward judgment, and certainly not with an unwillingness to ask difficult questions, but with a renewed determination to become people who reflect the character of the God we confess. People who love mercy because God is merciful, who pursue reconciliation because Christ has reconciled us, who protect the vulnerable because every human life bears the dignity of God’s creation, and who refuse to surrender hope because the tomb is empty.
Until every mystery is brought into the light of God’s final restoration, we will continue to walk in the Way of Jesus, trusting that the compassion revealed in his life is not an exception to the Father’s character, but its clearest and most faithful expression.
Notes
[1] See Exod 34:6–7; Num 14:18; Neh 9:17; Ps 103:8; Joel 2:13; Jonah 4:2. For the Hebrew vocabulary, consult Ludwig Koehler, Walter Baumgartner, and Johann Jakob Stamm, The Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament, trans. and ed. M. E. J. Richardson, 2 vols. (Leiden: Brill, 2001), s.vv. רחם, חסד, פקד.
[2] Num 16:22, 27–33; 26:9–11. For the textual distinction between the deaths of the rebels and the survival of Korah’s descendants, see the broader discussion of Numbers 16–17 in Jacob Milgrom, Numbers, JPS Torah Commentary (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1990). See also Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1–20: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, AB 4A (New York: Doubleday, 1993).
[3] Deut 32:39; 1 Sam 2:6; Job 1:21. For classical discussions of divine providence and moral authority, see Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologiae 1.22 and 2–2.64.5–6. Aquinas’s treatment should be distinguished from the simpler assertion that divine power alone establishes moral goodness.
[4] See Deut 24:16; Ezek 18:1–32; Jer 31:29–30. For the relationship between corporate identity, covenant responsibility, and Israelite legal traditions, see Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy 1–11: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, AB 5 (New York: Doubleday, 1991), alongside the pertinent laws in Deuteronomy 24.
[5] Compare Josh 6–12 with Judg 1; 2 Sam 24:1 with 1 Chr 21:1. For the ancient Near Eastern context of conquest language, see K. Lawson Younger Jr., Ancient Conquest Accounts: A Study in Ancient Near Eastern and Biblical History Writing, JSOTSup 98 (Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1990).
[6] Gen 37:35; Job 3:11–19; Pss 88; 139:8; Isa 26:19; Dan 12:2. See Philip S. Johnston, Shades of Sheol: Death and Afterlife in the Old Testament (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity Press, 2002).
[7]1 Enoch 22:1–14, especially 22:3–4 and the presentation of Abel’s appeal. See George W. E. Nickelsburg and James C. VanderKam, 1 Enoch: A New Translation (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2012). The existence of differentiated intermediate conditions should not be conflated with a doctrine of universal postmortem repentance.
[8]4 Ezra 7:75–101, especially 7:82. For the text and historical context, see Michael E. Stone, Fourth Ezra: A Commentary on the Book of Fourth Ezra, Hermeneia (Minneapolis: Fortress, 1990).
[9] See 1 Pet 3:18–22; 4:6; Acts 2:27–31; Eph 4:8–10. For the historical development of the descent tradition, see J. N. D. Kelly, Early Christian Creeds, 3rd ed. (London: Longman, 1972). Not all of these biblical texts independently require the doctrine of a descent to the realm of the dead.
[10] Chad Pierce, Spirits and the Proclamation of Christ: 1 Peter 3:18–22 in Its Tradition-Historical and Literary Context, WUNT 2/305 (Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck, 2011). See also D. N. Campbell and Fika J. van Rensburg, “A History of the Interpretation of 1 Peter 3:18–22,” Acta Patristica et Byzantina 19 (2008): 73–96.
[11] David G. Horrell, “Who Are ‘The Dead’ and When Was the Gospel Preached to Them? The Interpretation of 1 Pet 4.6,” New Testament Studies 49 (2003): 70–89. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0028688503000055.
[12]Catechism of the Catholic Church §§632–37. The document affirms Christ’s descent to the realm of the dead and liberation of the righteous who preceded him but explicitly distinguishes this from delivering the damned.
[13]2 Maccabees 12:38–46. See Jonathan A. Goldstein, II Maccabees: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, AB 41A (Garden City, NY: Doubleday, 1983). The passage describes prayers and funds for a purification offering at Jerusalem, not the erection of memorial altars over graves.
[14] Gregory of Nyssa, On the Soul and the Resurrection. See Ilaria L. E. Ramelli, “Gregory of Nyssa on the Soul (and the Restoration): From Plato to Origen,” in Exploring Gregory of Nyssa: Philosophical, Theological, and Historical Studies, ed. Anna Marmodoro and Neil B. McLynn (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018), 110–41.
Additional Sources
Eric A. Seibert, Disturbing Divine Behavior: Troubling Old Testament Images of God (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2009).
Christian Hofreiter, Making Sense of Old Testament Genocide: Christian Interpretations of Herem Passages (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2018).
Thomas Talbott, The Inescapable Love of God, 2nd ed. (Eugene, OR: Cascade, 2014).
Robin A. Parry, The Evangelical Universalist, 2nd ed. (Eugene, OR: Cascade, 2012).
David Bentley Hart, That All Shall Be Saved: Heaven, Hell, and Universal Salvation (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2019).
Ilaria L. E. Ramelli, The Christian Doctrine of Apokatastasis: A Critical Assessment from the New Testament to Eriugena (Leiden: Brill, 2013).
Alan E. Bernstein, The Formation of Hell: Death and Retribution in the Ancient and Early Christian Worlds (Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press, 1993).
Few practices have shaped the life of the Church more profoundly than preaching. From the public reading of Torah in ancient Israel to the apostolic proclamation of the Gospel throughout the Roman world, the people of God have always been formed by the spoken Word. Yet despite its centrality, preaching often suffers from a crisis of identity. In some contexts, it has been reduced to theological information transfer. In others, it has become motivational speaking wrapped in biblical language. Still elsewhere, preaching is treated primarily as a platform for personality, charisma, or cultural commentary. The result is that many aspiring preachers learn how to construct sermons before they ever wrestle with the deeper theological question of what preaching actually is or the faithful understanding of the text itself. A biblical theology of proclamation requires a more foundational approach. Before discussing outlines, illustrations, delivery techniques, or sermon structure, one must first ask what the preacher has been entrusted to proclaim. The recovery of faithful homiletics begins not with technique but with theology. It begins with understanding the relationship between the message, the method, and the messenger.
The Priority of the Message
Biblical proclamation begins with the conviction that God speaks. This seemingly simple assertion stands beneath the entire biblical narrative. Scripture is not merely a record of religious experiences or theological reflections; it is the testimony of a God who reveals Himself, enters covenant, and addresses His people. The authority of preaching, therefore, does not derive from the giftedness of the preacher, the expectations of the congregation, or the cultural relevance of the sermon. It derives from the God who has spoken and continues to speak through Scripture by the Holy Spirit.¹
This understanding distinguishes biblical preaching from virtually every other form of communication. The preacher does not stand before the congregation primarily as a lecturer, motivational speaker, storyteller, or religious commentator. Rather, the preacher stands as a steward under authority. The task is not to create a message but to faithfully proclaim a message already given. As Paul exhorts Timothy, the charge is remarkably simple and yet profoundly demanding: “Preach the Word” (2 Tim. 4:2).²
This reality places significant constraints upon the preacher. The sermon cannot be governed primarily by personal preference, cultural trends, political ideology, or popular opinion. Scripture itself must govern the sermon. The preacher is called to submit to the text before proclaiming the text. As Haddon Robinson famously observed, biblical preaching derives both its substance and authority from Scripture rather than from the ingenuity of the communicator.³ For this reason, faithful proclamation requires more than isolated proof texts or devotional reflections. It demands serious engagement with authorial intent, literary structure, historical setting, canonical context, and theological meaning. The biblical text must be allowed to speak on its own terms before it can be applied to contemporary hearers.⁴
From Information to Transformation
One of the persistent temptations within theological education is to confuse explanation with proclamation. Exegesis is indispensable. Careful interpretation matters. Historical and literary context matter. Yet a sermon is not complete simply because a passage has been explained correctly. Throughout Scripture, proclamation consistently presses toward transformation. The reading of Torah under Ezra in Nehemiah 8 did not merely increase knowledge; it produced conviction, worship, repentance, and renewed covenant identity. The preaching ministry of Jesus consistently called for response. The sermons of Acts repeatedly moved listeners toward repentance, faith, obedience, and participation in the life of the Kingdom. Biblical proclamation aims not merely at understanding but at formation.⁵
This movement might be summarized as:
Text → Meaning → Theology → Proclamation → Transformation
Each movement matters. A sermon that skips theological reflection often becomes shallow moralism. A sermon that neglects application becomes an academic lecture. A sermon that focuses exclusively on application without careful interpretation often descends into subjective spirituality detached from the text. Faithful preaching requires movement through each stage in order that hearers may encounter not merely biblical information but the living God who addresses them through Scripture.⁶ This transformational emphasis also explains why preaching cannot be reduced to intellectual persuasion alone. Paul reminds the Corinthians that his proclamation did not rest merely upon “plausible words of wisdom” but upon a demonstration of the Spirit’s power (1 Cor. 2:4). Biblical preaching occupies a unique space where careful study and spiritual dependence converge. The preacher labors diligently with the text while simultaneously depending upon the Holy Spirit to illuminate, convict, heal, and transform.
The Necessity of Method
If the message concerns what is proclaimed, the method concerns how the preacher moves responsibly from text to sermon. Throughout church history, faithful preachers have recognized that Spirit-led proclamation does not eliminate the need for disciplined preparation. Rather, preparation becomes an act of stewardship. The false dichotomy between study and Spirit remains one of the most damaging assumptions in modern preaching culture. Some preachers lean so heavily upon spontaneity that careful exegesis is neglected. Others become so consumed with academic precision that little room remains for pastoral warmth, spiritual discernment, or Spirit-sensitive application. Scripture consistently calls for both discipline and dependence.⁷
A responsible homiletical method begins with observation. Before asking what a text means, the preacher must first learn to see what is actually present within the text itself. Repeated themes, literary structures, key words, narrative movements, and theological tensions all deserve careful attention. Interpretation then seeks to understand the meaning of those observations within their historical, literary, and canonical contexts. Only after this work has been completed can the preacher move toward theological reflection and contemporary application.⁸ This process is particularly important because the Bible contains multiple literary genres, each requiring distinct interpretive sensitivities. Narrative texts function differently than prophetic oracles. Wisdom literature communicates differently than apocalyptic visions. Epistles differ from psalms. Failure to recognize these distinctions often results in misapplication or theological distortion.⁹
Equally important is the identification of the central burden of the text. Every faithful sermon should emerge from the primary theological claim of the passage rather than from a collection of disconnected observations. Bryan Chapell refers to this as the “fallen condition focus,” while Robinson describes it as the “big idea” of the sermon.¹⁰ Whatever terminology one adopts, the principle remains the same: a sermon should move coherently from the text’s central claim toward the response God seeks from His people. The goal of method, therefore, is not to create rigid formulas but to provide a faithful pathway from biblical text to pastoral proclamation.
The Messenger and the Embodied Word
Perhaps the most neglected dimension of homiletics in contemporary ministry is the formation of the messenger. Modern conversations about preaching often focus almost exclusively upon content or communication techniques. Yet Scripture repeatedly emphasizes that proclamation flows through a person whose life either reinforces or undermines the message being proclaimed.
The New Testament consistently holds life and doctrine together. Paul instructs Timothy to “watch your life and doctrine closely” (1 Tim. 4:16). Peter exhorts elders to shepherd willingly and honorably (1 Pet. 5:1–4). James warns that teachers will be judged more strictly (Jas. 3:1). These passages reveal a sobering truth: the preacher cannot be separated from the proclamation.¹¹ This does not mean that preachers must achieve perfection before they are qualified to speak. Scripture itself presents deeply flawed leaders such as Moses, David, Peter, and Paul. Yet it does mean that character formation matters. Holiness matters. Humility matters. Integrity matters. Emotional health matters. The messenger does not create the authority of the message, but the messenger can certainly obscure it.
In many respects, contemporary ministry culture often rewards giftedness more quickly than character. Charisma can attract attention. Communication skills can generate influence. Yet Scripture consistently prioritizes faithfulness over platform. The greatest dangers facing preachers are not merely theological error but pride, hypocrisy, manipulation, performance identity, and the temptation to use ministry for self-exaltation rather than service.¹² This is why spiritual formation must remain central to homiletical training. Prayer is not a supplement to sermon preparation; it is part of sermon preparation. Dependence upon the Holy Spirit is not an optional charismatic addition to preaching; it belongs to the very nature of biblical proclamation. The preacher is called not merely to explain the Word but to embody its transforming power through a life increasingly conformed to Christ.
A Holistic Vision for Biblical Proclamation
The healthiest vision of preaching emerges when the message, the method, and the messenger remain properly integrated. When the message is emphasized without attention to method, sermons often become disorganized or inaccessible. When method is emphasized without theological depth, preaching becomes technique-driven. When both message and method are present without spiritual formation, preaching risks becoming professionally competent yet spiritually hollow.
The biblical vision is far richer.
The message must remain governed by Scripture and centered upon Christ. The method must move responsibly from text to proclamation through careful interpretation and pastoral application. The messenger must continually submit to the transforming work of the Holy Spirit so that life and doctrine remain joined together. Only when these three dimensions converge does preaching become what it was always intended to be: a sacred act of stewardship through which God addresses His people, forms disciples, builds His Church, and advances His Kingdom.
THINKTANK
One additional practice that deserves far more attention in modern preaching is the role of community in sermon formation. While the final responsibility of proclamation rests with the preacher, the healthiest sermons are often shaped long before the preacher steps into the pulpit. Too many ministers prepare in isolation when God has already surrounded them with gifted people within the Body of Christ. Pastors, elders, teachers, musicians, creatives, counselors, intercessors, and ministry leaders each bring unique perspectives that can enrich the development of a message.
In many ministry contexts, sermon preparation benefits from functioning more like a think tank than a solitary exercise. Weeks before a message is delivered, trusted voices can help identify theological tensions, pastoral concerns, cultural blind spots, practical applications, and potential red flags. Others may contribute research, historical insights, illustrations, testimonies, or ministry implications that the primary communicator might otherwise overlook. Worship leaders often help identify themes that can be reinforced through music. Creative teams can envision visual elements and storytelling opportunities. Pastoral teams can anticipate how different groups within the congregation may hear and respond to the message. This collaborative process not only strengthens the sermon itself but also creates greater unity across the ministries of the church.
Such collaboration reflects a deeply biblical vision of the Church. Paul reminds us that the Body consists of many members, each contributing distinct gifts for the common good. The preacher remains responsible for stewarding the final message, yet wisdom often emerges through the collective discernment of Spirit-filled believers working together. In this sense, sermon preparation becomes an act of communal discipleship rather than merely an individual task.
When practiced intentionally, this process also allows church leaders to think beyond a single sermon and toward the larger formation of the congregation. Through thoughtful planning, scope and sequence, sermon series development, and long-range discipleship goals, leaders can begin to map how individual messages contribute to the overall spiritual development of the church. Rather than treating each sermon as an isolated event, preaching becomes part of a larger strategy of Kingdom formation, helping people move steadily toward maturity in Christ. In many ways, the most effective preaching ministries are not built on great sermons alone, but on communities of leaders prayerfully discerning together what God is saying to His people and how best to shepherd them toward faithful obedience.
Conclusion: Bearing the Weight and Wonder of the Call
At the end of the day, homiletics is not ultimately about sermons. It is about people.
It is about men and women made in the image of God who are longing for hope, truth, healing, direction, reconciliation, purpose, and life. It is about weary souls carrying burdens they cannot articulate, families navigating hardship, prodigals searching for home, disciples seeking maturity, and communities longing to encounter the living Christ. Every week, those people gather before the people entrusted with the ministry of proclamation, and the question remains: will they merely hear a speech, or will they encounter the Word of God? That is the sacred privilege and responsibility of the preacher.
The calling to preach has never been about building platforms, gathering followers, crafting polished presentations, or becoming a religious personality. The preacher is first and foremost a steward. We are entrusted with something that does not belong to us. The message is His. The people are His. The Church is His. The Kingdom is His. Our task is simply to handle the Word faithfully, proclaim it courageously, embody it authentically, and leave the results in the hands of the Holy Spirit.
This is why the message matters. This is why the method matters. This is why the messenger matters.
The message must remain anchored in Scripture because people need more than our opinions. They need a Word from God. The method matters because faithful stewardship requires diligence, discipline, and careful handling of the text. The messenger matters because people are not merely listening to what we say; they are observing the life through which the message is being delivered. Long after many sermons are forgotten, people will often remember whether they encountered a humble servant of Christ whose life reflected the Gospel being proclaimed. For those called to preach, teach, shepherd, disciple, and lead, the challenge is not simply to become better communicators. The challenge is to become people who dwell deeply with Christ. Fruitfulness in ministry has always flowed from abiding before it flows from activity. Before Jesus sent His disciples into the world, He first called them to be with Him. Before there was proclamation, there was formation. Before there was ministry, there was relationship.
The Church does not ultimately need more celebrities, influencers, performers, or experts. The Church needs faithful servants who know the Scriptures, hear the voice of the Spirit, love people deeply, and are willing to spend their lives helping others follow Jesus. It needs shepherds who can handle truth with conviction and people with tenderness. It needs proclaimers who can move responsibly from text to transformation and who understand that every sermon is an opportunity to participate in God’s ongoing work of redemption. If God has entrusted you with this calling, receive it with humility, but also with confidence. The same Spirit who inspired the Word still empowers its proclamation. The same Christ who commissioned His disciples still builds His Church. The same God who called prophets, apostles, pastors, teachers, and evangelists continues to raise up laborers for His harvest field.
So study diligently. Pray fervently. Shepherd faithfully. Preach courageously. Love deeply. Remain teachable. Stay near to Christ. And never forget that the goal is not simply to preach sermons, but to make disciples who embody the life and mission of the Kingdom.
May your message be biblical. May your method be faithful. May your life reflect the Gospel you proclaim.
And may the Lord use your words, your witness, and your obedience to bear much fruit for the glory of Christ and the advancement of His Kingdom.
Written with Dr. Steve Cassell
Endnotes
John Stott, Between Two Worlds (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 1982), 89.
Thomas G. Long, The Witness of Preaching, 3rd ed. (Louisville: Westminster John Knox, 2016), 13.
Apocalyptic Anxiety, Prophetic Imagination, and Faithful Christian Eschatology
Introduction: Living Faithfully in an Age of Apocalyptic Noise
In every generation, the people of God have wrestled with headlines, celestial events, wars, and rumors of wars. In our moment, images of blood-red moons, renewed interest in the red heifer ritual, Purim framed through geopolitical conflict, and even portrayals of a militarized Jesus circulate rapidly across Christian media. These phenomena are frequently interpreted as decisive indicators that “we are in the last days.”
As followers of Christ committed to careful biblical theology, we must ask: What is faithful eschatological attentiveness, and what drifts toward speculation? How do we distinguish biblical prophecy from patterns that more closely resemble divination? And how do we guard against subtly weaponizing Jesus in the service of national or ideological agendas?
This essay proposes that much contemporary apocalyptic rhetoric conflates symbolic prophetic language with predictive sign-reading, misapplies temple typology, and risks distorting the cruciform nature of Christ’s kingship. I ask you to consider a better theology, one that is deeply rooted, Christ-centered eschatology that cultivates hope without hysteria.
Cosmic Imagery and the Language of Blood Moons
The phrase “the moon will be turned to blood” appears in Joel 2:31 and is echoed in Acts 2:20 and Revelation 6:12.¹ Yet within prophetic and apocalyptic literature, such imagery functions symbolically to describe covenantal upheaval and divine intervention, not necessarily astronomical forecasting.²
When Peter cites Joel at Pentecost (Acts 2:16–21), he interprets the prophecy as fulfilled in the outpouring of the Spirit.³ The early church did not await literal lunar phenomena; they recognized that the decisive turning point in redemptive history had already occurred in Christ’s death, resurrection, and exaltation.⁴
Scholars such as John Walton remind us that in the Ancient Near East, celestial events were commonly interpreted as omens.⁵ Israel’s Torah, however, explicitly forbids divinatory practices tied to signs and portents (Deut 18:10–14).⁶ When modern Christians assign predictive significance to eclipses in ways that mirror ancient omen-reading, the hermeneutical posture begins to resemble the very practices Scripture warns against.⁷
Apocalyptic imagery unveils theological realities—it does not invite astrological decoding.
Red Heifers, Temple Expectation, and the Finality of Christ
The red heifer ritual of Numbers 19 concerns purification under the Mosaic covenant.⁸ Contemporary movements anticipating a Third Temple sometimes treat the reintroduction of this ritual as a necessary eschatological trigger.⁹
Yet the New Testament consistently reinterprets temple theology christologically. Jesus declares himself the true temple (John 2:19–21).¹⁰ Paul extends temple identity to the gathered people of God (1 Cor 3:16).¹¹ The epistle to the Hebrews insists that Christ’s priestly work is once-for-all and surpasses the sacrificial system (Heb 9–10).¹²
To frame renewed animal sacrifice as a prophetic necessity risks implying insufficiency in Christ’s atoning work.¹³ As Steve Gregg has argued in his engagement with Revelation’s various interpretive frameworks, much apocalyptic expectation misunderstands the covenantal transition already accomplished in the first century.¹⁴
Looking for a rebuilding of the Temple is a slap in the face to Jesus; it is essentially saying you don’t believe He was enough.
The trajectory of Scripture moves from shadow to substance—not from substance back to shadow.
Purim, Empire, and the Danger of Weaponizing Jesus
The book of Esther recounts Jewish survival within imperial Persia and culminates in the celebration of Purim (Esth 9).¹⁵ It is a narrative of providence and covenant preservation—not a blueprint for Christian militarization.
Revelation 19 portrays Christ as a rider on a white horse, yet the sword proceeds from his mouth—symbolizing the power of his word.¹⁶ Earlier, Revelation presents the conquering Messiah as the slain Lamb (Rev 5:6).¹⁷ The Lamb’s victory comes through self-giving sacrifice.
Shane J. Wood argues that Revelation functions as an unveiling of how empire masquerades as ultimate power while the Lamb redefines kingship through suffering love.¹⁸ The book calls believers to faithful witness, not violent triumphalism.¹⁹
When Jesus is draped in national symbolism or framed primarily as a military figure aligned with geopolitical agendas, the church risks conflating the kingdom of God with earthly power structures—precisely the confusion Revelation critiques.²⁰
The Lamb conquers not by coercion, but by cruciform allegiance.
Prophecy and Divination: A Crucial Distinction
Biblical prophecy is covenant proclamation rooted in God’s revealed purposes.²¹ Divination, by contrast, seeks hidden knowledge through decoding signs, omens, or speculative patterns.²²
Jeremiah warns against prophets who speak “visions of their own minds” (Jer 23:16).²³ Ezekiel rebukes those who practice “lying divination” (Ezek 13:6–9).²⁴ Jesus himself cautions his disciples against alarmism: “See that you are not alarmed” (Matt 24:6).²⁵
The apostolic exhortation is vigilance without panic (1 Thess 5:1–8).²⁶ When Christian rhetoric becomes dominated by chronological speculation tied to celestial events or ritual developments, it begins to mirror the divinatory impulse Scripture explicitly forbids.²⁷
Eschatology as Unveiling: Living in the Already and Not Yet
Christian eschatology has long been described as “already and not yet.”²⁸ Christ has decisively inaugurated the kingdom, yet its fullness awaits consummation.
Wood’s “thin veil” metaphor captures apocalyptic literature’s purpose: heaven’s perspective breaks into earthly history, revealing who truly reigns.²⁹ Revelation is not primarily a timetable but a theological unveiling of allegiance, empire, and worship.³⁰
Thus, blood moons need not provoke fear. Red heifers need not signal regression. Wars and rumors of wars do not require sacralized nationalism. The church’s vocation remains steadfast: faithful witness shaped by the Lamb.³¹
Peter reminds believers that they are a holy nation—not defined by geopolitical boundaries, but by covenant identity in Christ (1 Pet 2:9–12).³²
Our eschatological posture is hopeful watchfulness grounded in the finished work of Jesus.
Conclusion: Hope Without Hysteria
The final word of Revelation is not dread but invitation: “The Spirit and the Bride say, ‘Come’” (Rev 22:17).³³
Apocalyptic texts unveil hope, not panic. They expose empire, not empower it. They center the Lamb, not lunar cycles.
To remain faithful in an age of apocalyptic noise is not to disengage from current events, but to interpret them through the crucified and risen Christ. We do not decode eclipses; we embody the kingdom. We do not weaponize Jesus; we witness to him.
In a world prone to sensationalism, the church’s steadiness becomes its testimony.
Footnotes
Joel 2:31; Acts 2:20; Rev 6:12.
G. K. Beale, The Book of Revelation.
Acts 2:16–21.
Richard Bauckham, The Theology of the Book of Revelation.
John H. Walton, Ancient Near Eastern Thought and the Old Testament.
Deut 18:10–14.
Michael S. Heiser, The Unseen Realm.
Num 19.
Randall Price, The Temple and Bible Prophecy.
John 2:19–21.
1 Cor 3:16.
Heb 9–10.
David Peterson, Hebrews and Perfection.
Steve Gregg, Revelation: Four Views.
Esth 9.
Rev 19:15.
Rev 5:6.
Shane J. Wood, Thinning the Veil.
Rev 12:11.
Rev 13; Bauckham.
Walter Brueggemann, The Prophetic Imagination.
Deut 18:10–14.
Jer 23:16.
Ezek 13:6–9.
Matt 24:6.
1 Thess 5:1–8.
Heiser, The Unseen Realm.
George Eldon Ladd, The Presence of the Future.
Wood, Thinning the Veil.
Eugene H. Peterson, Reversed Thunder.
Rev 12:11.
1 Pet 2:9–12.
Rev 22:17.
Bibliography
Bauckham, Richard. The Theology of the Book of Revelation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Beale, G. K. The Book of Revelation. New International Greek Testament Commentary. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.
Brueggemann, Walter. The Prophetic Imagination. 2nd ed. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
Gregg, Steve. Revelation: Four Views. Nashville: Thomas Nelson.
Heiser, Michael S. The Unseen Realm: Recovering the Supernatural Worldview of the Bible. Bellingham, WA: Lexham Press.
Ladd, George Eldon. The Presence of the Future. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans.
Peterson, David. Hebrews and Perfection. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Peterson, Eugene H. Reversed Thunder: The Revelation of John and the Praying Imagination. San Francisco: HarperCollins.
Price, Randall. The Temple and Bible Prophecy. Eugene, OR: Harvest House.
Walton, John H. Ancient Near Eastern Thought and the Old Testament. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic.
Wood, Shane J. Thinning the Veil: Revelation and the Kingdom of Heaven. Cincinnati: Standard Publishing.
I have never cared much for politics—or, frankly, for either of the personalities involved in the Tucker Carlson–Mike Huckabee exchange. But I am interested in what their conversation exposes at a deeper level: the ease with which modern political arguments recruit Scripture, and the interpretive assumptions that often go unexamined when “the Bible says…” becomes a stand-in for careful exegesis.
In the exchange, Huckabee spoke as though Genesis 15:18 functions as a present-tense title deed—stretching from “the river of Egypt” to “the Euphrates”—while Carlson challenged the leap from an ancient covenant text to modern entitlement: if that’s the standard, why are borders negotiable, who counts as a rightful heir, and how does any of this become a binding obligation for Christians today? Beneath the soundbites is a question that actually matters: are we reading the biblical text on its own terms, in its Ancient Near Eastern and canonical context, or are we using it to baptize conclusions we already prefer?
This article takes Carlson’s line of questioning as an opportunity for theological and exegetical clarity rather than partisan reaction. My aim is not a political manifesto, but a canonical inquiry into what “Israel” means in the Bible’s own grammar—and what changes when Israel’s story reaches its climax in Jesus the Messiah. I will argue that modern Israel is not identical to covenant Israel in the sense that governs Christian obligation; that land-promise texts cannot be severed from Torah’s covenantal sanctions and the prophets’ ethical indictments; and that the New Testament’s Christological redefinition of the people of God relocates covenant identity from ethnicity and territory to union with Christ. On that basis, Christians should resist treating unconditional support for the modern State of Israel as a biblical mandate, while still rejecting antisemitism, refusing the dehumanization of Palestinians, and pursuing a kingdom ethic of truth, justice, and peacemaking for all image-bearers in the land.
1. The presenting controversy: a text, a nation-state, and the temptation to baptize policy
In his filmed exchange with U.S. Ambassador Mike Huckabee, Tucker Carlson pressed a question that many American Christians have often assumed rather than exegeted: when Genesis describes land promised to Abram’s descendants “from the river of Egypt…to the great river, the Euphrates,” what exactly is being claimed—and how (if at all) does that claim translate into modern geopolitical obligations? In the interview transcript, Carlson repeatedly returns to the logic of appeal: if “God gave this land to this people,” then what land, and which people, and on what principled basis should modern states underwrite that claim?
The exchange became headline news precisely because the “Bible as real-estate deed” framing is not merely an internal church dispute; it can be invoked to justify maximalist territorial imagination. Associated Press reported that Huckabee responded to Carlson’s “Nile to Euphrates” framing with, “It would be fine if they took it all,” even while adding that Israel was not currently seeking that expansion. This is exactly the kind of moment where Christian theological speech must slow down: not to evade political realities, but to avoid treating Scripture as a rhetorical accelerant.
What follows is an academic-style theological argument—biblically grounded, historically attentive, and hermeneutically explicit—contending that (1) modern Israel is not “biblical Israel” in the covenantal sense that matters for Christian identity and obligation, and (2) the New Testament does not authorize a blanket Christian duty to support the modern nation-state of Israel as a theological absolute, even while (3) Christians remain morally bound to oppose antisemitism, to pursue justice and mercy for all image-bearers in the land (Jewish and Palestinian alike), and to pray for peace.
2. Method: what “biblical Israel” means (and what it does not mean)
A responsible theological reading begins by distinguishing at least four “Israels,” which are too often collapsed:
Israel as an ethnos (a people group with genealogical continuity).
Israel as a covenant polity constituted at Sinai (and held accountable to Torah).
Israel as a landed theocratic project under Yahweh’s kingship (and later monarchic compromise).
Israel as an eschatological people reconstituted in and around the Messiah in the New Covenant.
Much popular Christian Zionism treats #1 and #2 as if they are stable across redemptive history and then maps them directly onto #3 in modern political form. But the Bible itself complicates every step of that move.
Chosen” in the Hebrew Bible is not primarily a synonym for “saved” but a vocation—a commissioned role “to be a light to the nations.” That vocational election is real. Yet vocation can be resisted, judged, exiled, and reconfigured within God’s larger redemptive purpose (a theme threaded through the prophets and then re-read christologically in the New Testament).
In short: the Bible itself does not permit a simplistic, trans-historical equivalence between “Israel” in Genesis, “Israel” in Deuteronomy, “Israel” in Second Temple politics, and “Israel” as a twentieth-century nation-state. That does not mean Jewish continuity is unreal. It means that covenant categories are not identical to modern nation-state categories—and Christian ethics cannot pretend they are.
3. The Abrahamic texts in their Ancient Near Eastern texture: promise, sign, and the grammar of gift
3.1 Genesis 12:1–3 is not a blank-check for foreign policy
The most common “Christian pro-Israel” proof-text in the American imagination is Genesis 12:3 (“I will bless those who bless you…”). But three exegetical observations matter.
First, the “you” addressed is Abram, not “Israel” as a later national polity. Second, the promise culminates in a universal horizon: “in you all the families of the earth shall be blessed.” Third, the New Testament repeatedly reads Abraham’s promise Christologically—not as an everlasting political entitlement but as a redemptive trajectory that reaches its telos in the Messiah and then spills outward to the nations. The “seed” is ultimately Christ and that union “in Christ” becomes the decisive identity marker.
Even many evangelical defenses of “bless Israel” concede the text is not reducible to modern state patronage.
3.2 Genesis 15:18 and the “Nile to Euphrates” claim: what is being promised?
Carlson’s pressure point is Genesis 15: if the land boundary is maximal, why are modern borders “shrunk,” and if the right is covenantal, why not identify rightful heirs by lineage or conversion status? Whatever one thinks of Carlson’s rhetoric, his question exposes a weakness in the “Bible as title deed” argument: it often wants the authority of literalism without the cost of literalism.
But the biblical narrative itself supplies the missing complexity.
Genesis 15 is divine promise framed by covenant ritual. The “cutting” scene belongs to a broader Ancient Near Eastern world of covenant-making and self-maledictory symbolism (the “may it be to me as to these pieces” logic). The point is not that Abram receives a modern cartographic deed; it is that Yahweh binds himself to a promissory path that will unfold through judgment, deliverance, and covenant schooling.
The Pentateuch itself embeds conditionality alongside gift. Deuteronomy’s covenant structure makes clear that land “rest” and land “retention” are tethered to fidelity; exile is not a surprise glitch but a stipulated covenant outcome (Deut 28–30). The gift is real; the possession is morally charged.
The boundary language functions typologically and theologically. “From Wadi Egypt to the Euphrates” becomes a way of expressing fullness and security under Yahweh’s reign—yet the historical narratives show fluctuating control, partial possession, and continual threat. Even in the so-called “golden age,” the biblical writers do not present Israel as a simple imperial machine but as a morally accountable people whose kings can be indicted by prophetic speech.
This is why proof-texting Genesis 15 to justify “it would be fine if they took it all” is not exegesis; it is ideological ventriloquism.
4. “Fulfilled” land, fractured obedience: Joshua, Kings, and the prophets against naïve maximalism
A major interpretive fault-line is whether the land promise is (a) already fulfilled in Israel’s early history and then refigured in Christ, or (b) postponed into a future political restoration.
Those who argue (a) often appeal to texts like Joshua 21:43–45 (“the LORD gave to Israel all the land…not one word…failed”), while dispensational writers contest that conclusion by insisting the promise requires fuller geographical realization. The point here is not to adjudicate every sub-debate, but to notice what the canonical shape presses on us:
The Deuteronomistic history (Joshua–Kings) depicts land as covenant theater: blessing and curse play out in real time; kings can lose the plot; exile arrives as covenant consequence.
The prophets do not treat land as an unconditional permanent possession immune to ethics. They treat it as a stage upon which injustice can bring expulsion (cf. Amos; Jeremiah; Ezekiel).
So even if one holds that future restoration themes remain (a debated question), the prophetic corpus blocks the move from “promise” to “unconditional endorsement of any state behavior.” The Bible does not give Israel a moral “get out of judgment free” card; it gives Israel more accountability.
5. The New Testament’s reconfiguration: Jesus as faithful Israel, and the people defined “in him”
The New Testament does not merely add Jesus onto Israel’s story; it claims that Jesus fulfills Israel’s vocation and embodies Israel’s identity as the faithful covenant keeper. Matthew’s application of Hosea (“out of Egypt I called my son”) to Jesus and Paul’s emphasis that the inheritance is shared only “in Christ.”
That is not “replacement theology” in the crude sense of “God discards Jews.” It is a christological claim about where covenant identity is now located: in the Messiah and those united to him by faith.
Several New Testament moves matter for the present debate:
The redefinition of kinship and peoplehood. Jesus relativizes bloodline as the defining marker of belonging (e.g., “Who are my mother and my brothers?”). Paul can say “not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel” (Rom 9:6), and he can describe Gentiles being “grafted in” to the covenantal olive tree (Rom 11). The people of God become a multi-ethnic body whose unity is cruciform rather than nationalistic.
The relocation of “promised land” hope into eschatological new creation. The Expedition44 “Israel & the Jesus Kingdom” essay argues that the New Covenant’s “promised land” is fundamentally eschatological—recreated heavens and earth—rather than a mandate for a modern territorial project, and that Christian allegiance is primarily to the kingdom of Jesus.
The ethic of the kingdom as interpretive control. The Sermon on the Mount is not an optional “private spirituality” track; it is the Messiah’s charter for his people. If one tries to use Scripture to underwrite policies that produce indiscriminate harm or permanent domination, that reading must be confronted by the Messiah’s own ethic.
This is the theological center of gravity: Christian Scripture culminates not in land expansion but in a crucified and risen Messiah who forms a trans-national people and teaches them to love enemies.
6. Why many Christians do argue for continuing “biblical support” of modern Israel—and what to do with those arguments
To be fair and academically responsible, we should state the strongest versions of the Christian pro-Israel claims.
6.1 Argument from covenant permanence (“forever” language)
Many argue that because covenants are described as “everlasting,” the land promise must remain politically operative. Dispensational systems tend to separate “Israel” and “Church” as distinct peoples with distinct destinies, thereby preserving a future national role for ethnic Israel.
Response: “Forever” in covenant idiom must be read within canonical and covenantal context: the same covenant documents specify exile as consequence; prophetic judgments speak of being “not my people” in covenant rupture (Hos 1:9–11). A dispensational attempt to preserve unconditionality by sidelining covenant sanctions does violence to the Torah’s own logic. (Even writers sympathetic to Israel-church distinction acknowledge Hosea’s “not my people” language as covenantal crisis.)
6.2 Argument from Genesis 12:3 (“bless those who bless you”)
Many popular teachers treat this as a timeless mechanism: bless modern Israel materially/militarily and you will be blessed.
Response: The Abrahamic promise is read by the New Testament as culminating in Christ and opening to the nations; “blessing” cannot be reduced to state patronage. Even within evangelical discussions, careful treatments note that Genesis 12 is addressed to Abram and that “Israel” is not in view as a modern polity.
6.3 Argument from prophecy fulfillment (1948 as “sign”)
Some interpret the modern state’s founding (1948) as prophetic fulfillment and therefore as a theological anchor for Christian support.
Response: Even if one grants “providential significance,” providence is not identical to covenant mandate. Moreover, the New Testament regularly treats “sign” language as Christ-centered; political events cannot simply be baptized as eschatological necessity without robust textual argument. Steve Gregg’s approach—evaluate the modern state biblically and be wary of dispensational narratives—pushes against the “1948 = automatic theology” reflex.
6.4 Argument from “apostolic concern for Israel” (Rom 9–11)
Some argue Paul’s anguish and hope for Israel implies a continuing special status requiring Christian political alignment.
Response: Paul’s concern is evangelistic and doxological, not a directive for modern foreign policy. Romans 9–11 is about God’s fidelity and the mystery of unbelief and mercy—not a command to underwrite a state.
7. Why unconditional Christian support for modern Israel is not biblically required (and is often theologically confused)
Pulling the threads together, there are several main biblical reasons a Christian is not obligated—as a matter of theological necessity—to support the modern state of Israel “in general” or “no matter what.”
7.1 Category error: covenant people ≠ modern nation-state
“The modern nation-state of Israel is not the covenant people of the Bible,” because covenant membership is now defined by faith in the Messiah rather than ethnicity or passport status.
That doesn’t settle every question about Jewish identity or God’s providence, but it does block the simplistic move: “Bible says Israel → therefore Christians must support modern Israel.”
7.2 Canonical ethic: God’s promises never authorize injustice
The Hebrew Bible constantly holds Israel accountable for injustice; the prophets do not hesitate to indict Israel more severely because of her calling. Therefore it is hermeneutically incoherent to say, “because of promise, Israel gets unconditional endorsement.” Promise does not erase prophetic ethics; it intensifies them.
7.3 Christological control: the telos is Messiah and new creation, not territorial maximalism
Even within your own framework, the “promised land” is ultimately eschatological, and the kingdom’s geography is the renewed creation—not a modern territorial ideology.
7.4 Political theology: the New Covenant does not create sacral nation-states
The church is not a nation-state; it is a trans-national body. When Christians treat any state as if it carries covenant holiness, they risk reintroducing a form of sacral nationalism the New Testament consistently relativizes.
7.5 Moral realism: “Israel’s policies” cannot be the basis for blanket theology (and the abortion claim is not decisive)
To be totally transparent, some Christians support reasons to not support Israel such as “they support abortion” and “they largely aren’t Christians.” Even if those claims were uniformly true (they are more complex than social media summaries), they still wouldn’t function as the primary argument, because Christian theology does not grant blanket moral endorsement to any state based on religious purity tests. Still, it is fair to note that Israel’s legal framework includes state-regulated access to abortion through termination committees. The deeper point, though, is this: Christian foreign policy ethics should be grounded in justice, the protection of the vulnerable, truthful speech, and peacemaking—rather than a mythic covenant entitlement narrative.
8. Returning to Carlson’s central challenge: “blood,” conversion, and the instability of ethno-theological politics
Carlson’s sharpest theological question in the interview is not about ancient boundaries but about the moral logic of an ethnic land-claim. He presses: if the right is covenantal and genealogical, why not genetic testing? How does conversion (to Judaism or to Christianity) affect right of return? Huckabee appears to oscillate between “biblical/ethnic/historical” claims and pragmatic border talk, but Carlson’s critique lands: a nation-state founded on ethnic criteria invites moral confusion when theologized as divine decree.
From a New Testament perspective, this critique is theologically fruitful: the Messiah’s people are not determined by DNA but by covenantal faithfulness expressed as allegiance to Jesus. “In Christ” is the dominant boundary marker and that blessing is tied to honoring the Messiah rather than underwriting national projects.
Thus, ironically, Carlson’s “America First” skepticism can function as a negative aid to Christian exegesis: it exposes how quickly Christians can drift into a quasi-biblical ethno-politics that the apostolic writings resist.
9. Constructive conclusion: what Christians can say (and do) without making Scripture a weapon
Reject antisemitism categorically. Jewish people are not “the problem,” and Christian history contains grievous sins against Jews.
Refuse to sacralize any state. No modern nation bears covenant holiness.
Read land, people, and promise through the Messiah. If Jesus is the faithful Israelite, then the story’s center is him, and the people are those “in him.”
Seek justice and peace for all who dwell in the land. Christian ethics does not permit indifference toward Palestinian suffering or Jewish fear; both must be taken with full seriousness.
Advocate principled, conditional political reasoning. If one supports Israel politically, it should be on the same moral grounds one uses for any state: proportionality, protection of noncombatants, truthful diplomacy, restraint, and the pursuit of genuine peace—not “because Genesis.” If one withholds support, it should likewise be principled, not tribal.
The primary allegiance of the Christ-follower is to the Jesus Kingdom, and the church must resist being “yoked” to worldly power projects that distort the kingdom’s witness.
Conclusion
The Carlson–Huckabee exchange ultimately exposes not a political dilemma, but a hermeneutical one. When the biblical text is read within its Ancient Near Eastern covenant context and through the New Testament’s Christological fulfillment, it becomes clear that Scripture does not grant modern nation-states a standing theological entitlement. The covenant promises to Israel find their telos in the Messiah, and the people of God are now defined by union with Him rather than by ethnicity, geography, or political sovereignty.
For that reason, Christians are not biblically obligated to offer unconditional support to the modern State of Israel as if such support were a covenantal requirement. Our allegiance is not to any geopolitical entity but to Jesus Christ, the true Israel and King of the kingdom that transcends every border. From that allegiance flows a consistent ethic: we reject antisemitism, we refuse to dehumanize Palestinians, and we pursue justice, truth, and peace for all who dwell in the land.
In the end, the question is not whether Christians will take a political side, but whether we will read Scripture faithfully and embody the kingdom it proclaims.
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS
1. Covenant, Land, and Conditionality
How should the land promises in Genesis (e.g., Gen 12; 15; 17) be interpreted in light of the covenantal conditions articulated in Deuteronomy 28–30 and the prophetic indictments that led to exile?
In what sense are the promises “everlasting,” and in what sense are they historically administered under covenant fidelity?
Does the canonical shape of the Old Testament itself invite a non-literal or typological expansion of the land promise?
2. The Reconfiguration of Israel in the New Testament
To what extent do New Testament texts (e.g., Rom 9–11; Gal 3; Eph 2; 1 Pet 2:9–10) redefine the identity of Israel around Christ and the Church?
Do these passages suggest continuity, replacement, fulfillment, or expansion?
How should one evaluate the claim that “not all Israel is Israel” (Rom 9:6) in relation to modern ethnic or national identity?
3. Hermeneutics and Political Theology
What hermeneutical principles should govern the use of biblical texts in modern geopolitical discussions, such as those raised in the Carlson–Huckabee exchange?
Is it legitimate to apply ANE covenant language directly to contemporary nation-states?
What criteria distinguish faithful theological application from ideological proof-texting?
4. Christological Fulfillment and the Kingdom of God
How does the New Testament presentation of Jesus as the fulfillment of Israel’s vocation (e.g., Matt 2; John 15; Heb 11) reshape the theological significance of land, peoplehood, and covenant identity?
In what sense is the “promised land” reinterpreted as new creation (Matt 5:5; Rom 4:13)?
What implications does this have for Christian allegiance and identity in a global, multi-ethnic Church?
5. Ethics, Justice, and Christian Responsibility Today
If Christians are not biblically mandated to support the modern State of Israel unconditionally, what ethical framework should guide their posture toward Israel, Palestine, and the broader Middle East?
How should biblical themes of justice, mercy, and reconciliation (e.g., Mic 6:8; Matt 5–7; 2 Cor 5:18–20) inform Christian political engagement?
What does it look like to reject both antisemitism and anti-Palestinian dehumanization while maintaining fidelity to the gospel?
Note: Because this is formatted for a blog post rather than a print journal, some citations are consolidated (multiple works per note) to keep the apparatus readable despite the 140 citations.
“Mike Huckabee’s Interview @ Tucker Carlson Show (Transcript),” The Singju Post, February 20, 2026.
Sam Mednick and Samy Magdy, “US ambassador causes uproar by claiming Israel has a right to much of the Middle East,” Associated Press, February 21, 2026.
Expedition44, “Is Israel Still God’s Chosen people?” October 16, 2025.
Expedition44, “Israel & the Jesus Kingdom,” October 29, 2023.
Steve Gregg, “The Modern State of Israel” (lecture summary), OpenTheo.
Steve Gregg, “What Are We to Make of Israel?” (series index/summary), OpenTheo.
The Narrow Path, “Topical Lectures: Israel—What Are We to Make of Israel (12 Lectures).”
Aaron Sobczak, “No, Christians shouldn’t give unconditional support to Israel,” Libertarian Christian Institute, January 27, 2025.
“Rethinking Support for Israel: A Biblical Approach Beyond Politics,” Bible Mysteries Podcast (blog), n.d.
Brian Collins, “Kevin T. Bauder, ‘Israel and the Church: Is There Really a Difference,’ in Dispensationalism Revisited,” Exegesis and Theology, June 14, 2024.
Ministry of Health (Israel), “Induced Abortion,” government information page.
State of Israel, gov.il, “Apply to Terminate a Pregnancy (Induced Abortion).”
One for Israel, “What Does it Mean to Bless Israel According to Genesis 12…,” July 17, 2024.
“At the roots of evangelical Christians’ support for Israel,” Le Monde, April 11, 2024.
“Evangelicals’ support for Israel is dropping…,” Washington Post, January 3, 2026.
The question of whether Adam and Eve spoke Hebrew in the Eden narrative has persisted within both popular and academic discussions of early Genesis. While the biblical text depicts the first humans engaging in meaningful, structured speech, it does not explicitly identify the linguistic form of that speech. This study examines the question from a philological, literary, and theological perspective, arguing that while Hebrew wordplay in Genesis is theologically significant, it does not necessitate the conclusion that Hebrew was the primordial human language.
The Genesis narrative presents humanity as linguistically capable from the outset. In Genesis 2:19–20, Adam exercises dominion through naming the animals. Naming in the Ancient Near Eastern context is not merely descriptive but also ontological, reflecting authority and classification.
Genesis 11:1 later affirms that “the whole earth had one language and the same words,” indicating a primordial linguistic unity prior to the Babel event (Genesis 11:7–9). However, the text remains silent regarding the identity of this language.
One of the most common proposals is that Hebrew was the original language of humanity. This argument is typically grounded in the semantic transparency of key names in Genesis: Adam is connected to ground, and Eve to life. These connections create compelling literary and theological wordplay within the Hebrew text. However, the Book of Genesis was composed and transmitted in Hebrew, making it methodologically plausible that the inspired author employed Hebrew lexical connections to communicate theological truths to a Hebrew-speaking audience.
Alternative models include the possibility of a lost proto-human language, a unique Edenic language, or narrative accommodation where the Genesis author presents primordial events through the linguistic and conceptual framework of Hebrew.
The biblical text affirms that Adam and Eve used meaningful language, early humanity shared a unified language, and the specific identity of that language is not disclosed. The Hebrew hypothesis remains a reasonable inference but not an exegetical conclusion.
Discussion Questions
To what extent should Hebrew wordplay in Genesis be understood as literary theology rather than historical linguistic evidence?
How does the concept of naming in Genesis 2 reflect Ancient Near Eastern understandings of authority and ontology?
What hermeneutical risks arise when later linguistic forms are retrojected into primeval history?
How does Genesis 11 (Babel) inform our understanding of linguistic diversity in relation to divine sovereignty?
In what ways does the presence of language in Eden contribute to a doctrine of the image of God?
Bibliography
Alter, Robert. Genesis: Translation and Commentary. W.W. Norton, 1996.
Barr, James. The Semantics of Biblical Language. Oxford University Press, 1961.
Cassuto, Umberto. A Commentary on the Book of Genesis. Magnes Press, 1961.
Hamilton, Victor P. The Book of Genesis: Chapters 1–17. Eerdmans, 1990.
Heiser, Michael S. The Unseen Realm. Lexham Press, 2015.
Kidner, Derek. Genesis: An Introduction and Commentary. IVP, 1967.
Sailhamer, John H. The Pentateuch as Narrative. Zondervan, 1992.
Walton, John H. The Lost World of Genesis One. IVP Academic, 2009.
Wenham, Gordon J. Genesis 1–15. Word Biblical Commentary, 1987.
Every February 14 many Christians and non-Christians alike pause to celebrate love—often through candy, flowers, heart-shaped cards, and candlelight dinners. But beneath the commercial veneer lies a rich tapestry of history, cultural adaptation, and theological meaning that invites careful reflection for the church—one rooted not simply in sentiment, but in Scripture and the long witness of Christian faith.
1. The Historical Palimpsest of Valentine’s Day
Some scholars would identify at least three such figures known in martyrologies, with one tradition holding that a Roman priest named Valentine in the third century defied an imperial edict against Christian marriage to marry couples in secret—a testament to his defense of Christian marriage and pastoral courage.
By the fifth and sixth centuries, February 14 was established in the liturgical calendar as the feast of St. Valentine, though the medieval church did not associate this date with romantic love until much later. In time, festivals of courtly love and poetic traditions such as Chaucer’s Parliament of Fowls would fold romantic symbolism into the date long after its ecclesiastical origins ended.
It is essential sociologically to recognize that Valentine’s Day—as celebrated today—is a layered cultural artifact: part hagiographic remembrance, part medieval romance, part commercialized modern ritual. None of these layers originate in biblical revelation, yet all reflect ways humans seek to articulate love within their cultural context.
2. Scripture and the Semantics of Love
Most people are aware that the Bible does not mention Valentine’s Day; nowhere is it regarded as a holy day per se. Its absence places the observance in the category of Christian freedom described in Romans 14:5–6, where Paul writes that believers may regard certain days differently, and whether one observes them or not, it should be “in honor of the Lord.”
What Scripture does offer is a rich, nuanced theology of love. In biblical Greek there are multiple terms for love—agapé (self-giving, covenantal love), philia (brotherly affection), eros (romantic desire, depicted especially in Song of Songs), and storge (familial love). While eros itself does not appear in the New Testament theological lexicon, the Song of Songs—a book of the Hebrew Bible—celebrates sensual and relational love within the covenant of marriage.
The apostle Paul’s famous discourse in 1 Corinthians 13 reframes love as a moral and spiritual virtue defined not by transient feeling but by patient covenantal commitment, self-giving service, and endurance. Jesus Himself states the core of the law: to love God with all one’s heart and to love one’s neighbor as oneself (Mark 12:30–31).
This emphasis locates the core of biblical discourse not in romantic expression alone, but in covenantal fidelity, sacrificial love, and the self-giving love revealed supremely in Christ’s death and resurrection.
3. Early Church and the Appropriation of Culture
From a socio-rhetorical perspective, the early church was adept at incarnating its message within existing cultural frameworks without compromising its core message. The apostle Paul became “all things to all people” to win some to Christ (1 Corinthians 9:22).
Christian appropriation of certain dates or customs has always been contested. The church’s decision to commemorate saints and martyrs on specific feast days was not intended to canonize secular customs, but to sanctify memory in ways that pointed beyond worldly spectacle to Christ’s kingship and the communion of saints.
In this light, Valentine’s Day can serve as a cultural locus for Christians to articulate biblical love — not simply by embracing its commercial trappings uncritically, nor by rejecting all contact with culture out of fear of syncretism, but by discerning how Christ’s love reshapes human practices. As Paul counsels, “Test everything; hold fast to what is good.” (1 Thessalonians 5:21)
4. Theological Reframing: Love as Witness
Rather than delegating Valentine’s Day to either celebration or avoidance, Christians can use the occasion as an invitation to reflect on biblical love as witness—not only within marriage, but within the body of Christ and the broader world.
A socio-rhetorical reading invites us to see Valentine’s Day less as an externally mandated Christian feast and more as a rhetorical opportunity—a moment when society’s focus on love can be redirected toward the love that God enacts in Christ. Such love is measured not by roses and chocolates, but by the sacrificial gift of Christ and the mutual love of believers that testifies to His presence (John 13:35).
Conclusion: Love in Context
Valentine’s Day is not inherently Christian because it emerged from early church commemoration or medieval romantic tradition. Nor is it inherently pagan because of its layered history. It is imperatively a moment for Christians to practice discernment, to ask how the gospel reframes the season of love, and to embody sacrificial, covenantal love in ways that reflect God’s love for the world.
As we remember St. Valentine—a figure united by courage and fidelity to Christ—and reflect on the biblical narrative of love from Genesis to Revelation, may our practice of love be shaped by agapé above all else, rooted in Scripture and enacted in service.
Discussion Questions
How does an awareness of the historical development of Valentine’s Day influence (or not) how we celebrate love as Christians?
In what ways does the biblical concept of agapé challenge modern expressions of romantic love?
How can Christians use cultural observances like Valentine’s Day as platforms for gospel witness without syncretizing their faith?
What does Song of Songs teach us about the place of romantic love within God’s broader design for relationships?
How might Paul’s teaching in Romans 14 apply to disagreements within the church over celebrating Valentine’s Day?
Bibliography
Armstrong Institute. “Valentine’s Day—in the Hebrew Bible?” (ArmstrongInstitute.org)
BibleInspire.com. “Valentine’s Day Biblical Meaning: What Christians Need to Know.”
“Valentine’s Day.” Wikipedia (overview of historical development).
Song of Songs. Wikipedia (literary and canonical context).
Covenant Intimacy: Cultivating Oneness in Marriage
Marriage in the biblical sense is not merely a social contract or a partnership; it is a sacred covenant—a divinely instituted bond that mirrors God’s covenant love with His people. The Hebrew term berith (בְּרִית) denotes a solemn, binding agreement, marked not only by promises but by loyalty, faithfulness, and mutual self-giving. In the New Testament, this covenantal reality is deepened through Christ, who embodies sacrificial love (agape, ἀγάπη) that calls spouses to serve one another in humility and grace (Ephesians 5:21–33).
At the heart of covenant intimacy is oneness. Genesis 2:24 provides the foundational paradigm: “Therefore a man shall leave his father and his mother and hold fast to his wife, and they shall become one flesh” (yada’, יָדַע). This “knowing” is both relational and sexual, reflecting the full depth of emotional, spiritual, and physical unity. The Hebrew concept carries intentionality: to truly know is to commit, to enter into the mystery of the other in trust and vulnerability.
1. Emotional and Spiritual Intimacy: Grounded in Discipleship
Intimacy begins in the soul. Couples are called to cultivate mutual transparency, confession, and encouragement, echoing the pastoral model of discipleship. Paul’s admonition in Ephesians 4:32—“Be kind to one another, tenderhearted, forgiving one another, as God in Christ forgave you”—offers a template for relational healing.
Practical Steps:
Regular Spiritual Check-ins: Set aside time weekly to share personal spiritual victories, struggles, and prayers. This mirrors the Jewish practice of hevruta, spiritual partnership, applied to marriage.
Scripture Sharing: Read passages together that emphasize covenant faithfulness, such as Hosea 2:19–20 or Song of Solomon 2:16. Discuss what it means to love sacrificially in the context of God’s covenant.
Example: A husband and wife may take a Psalm each week, reflecting on God’s steadfast love (chesed, חֶסֶד), and share how it encourages them to act faithfully toward one another.
2. Physical Intimacy as Covenant Expression
Sexual intimacy in marriage is not a mere physical act but a profound covenantal sign. Paul’s instruction in 1 Corinthians 7:3–5 emphasizes mutual authority over one another’s bodies, highlighting consent, desire, and attentive love. The Greek word soma (σῶμα) underscores the body as integral to relational unity, not separate from spiritual or emotional connection.
Practical Steps:
Intentional Touch and Affection: Beyond sexual encounters, daily gestures of touch—holding hands, gentle hugs, and affirming kisses—strengthen the sense of oneness.
Sexual Rhythm and Communication: Like cultivating agape, sexual intimacy benefits from intentionality, listening, and mutual understanding rather than routine or obligation.
Example: A couple may schedule regular “covenant nights” where the focus is on emotional closeness first, leading into physical intimacy, emphasizing the full scope of knowing (yada’) one another.
3. Reconciliation and Covenant Repair
Covenantal intimacy is tested in conflict and broken trust. The Hebrew Scriptures often illustrate covenant repair through rituals of atonement, dialogue, and restoration (e.g., Numbers 5:5–10). In a marriage, bitterness or resentment acts as a barrier to oneness. Forgiveness is the vessel through which intimacy is restored.
Practical Steps:
Transparent Apologies: Use “I statements” to express hurt without blame. Example: “I felt distant when…”
Counseling as Shepherding: Pastoral or Christian counseling can provide structured guidance in rebuilding trust.
Example: After a major disagreement, a couple may intentionally pray together, verbally affirming mutual commitment to repair and trust, creating a spiritual as well as relational healing.
4. Covenant Rituals and Symbolic Practices
Hebrew and Christian traditions often employ ritual as a tangible expression of covenant faithfulness. Small but intentional practices cultivate relational memory and reinforce unity.
Practical Steps:
Weekly Covenant Meals: Sharing intentional meals without distraction, reflecting on God’s covenant with each other, mirrors the covenantal feasts of Israel.
Anniversary Reflections: Beyond gifts, reflecting on God’s faithfulness through marriage fosters gratitude and spiritual depth.
Shared Devotional Practices: Singing, prayer, or journaling together enhances both spiritual and emotional oneness.
Example: A couple may light a candle each week, reading Song of Solomon 8:6–7, symbolizing love as a flame strengthened by trust and God’s covenant presence.
Conclusion
Covenant intimacy in marriage is a dynamic, God-centered pursuit. It is not achieved merely through techniques but through a sustained commitment to oneness—emotional, spiritual, and physical—modeled on Christ’s sacrificial love. Couples who approach marriage as a covenant discover that intimacy grows from shared vulnerability, forgiveness, and disciplined love. As shepherds of one another’s hearts, husbands and wives reflect the divine covenant in ways that are both deeply relational and spiritually formative.
Discussion Questions
Oneness and Covenant Theology
Genesis 2:24 emphasizes the couple becoming “one flesh” (yada’, יָדַע). How does this Hebrew concept of “knowing” inform our understanding of emotional, spiritual, and physical intimacy in marriage?
In what ways can modern couples cultivate “oneness” beyond physical intimacy, reflecting covenant faithfulness in daily life?
Discuss practical ways to apply the biblical model of covenant to repair relational breaches or build deeper trust.
Spiritual Intimacy and Discipleship in Marriage
Ephesians 5:21–33 and Colossians 3:12–14 call for mutual submission, forgiveness, and love. How does viewing marriage as a context for mutual discipleship transform conflict resolution, emotional vulnerability, and spiritual growth?
Share examples of habits, practices, or rituals that encourage spiritual intimacy and accountability within your marriage.
Physical Intimacy as Covenant Expression
1 Corinthians 7:3–5 presents the body as a shared authority (soma, σῶμα) within marriage. How does this concept challenge or expand contemporary cultural understandings of sexual intimacy?
Discuss how intentionality, communication, and mutual consent can enhance covenantal physical intimacy, making it both relational and spiritual.
Forgiveness, Reconciliation, and Covenant Repair
Reflect on biblical examples of covenant restoration (e.g., Hosea’s marriage as metaphor, Numbers 5:5–10). How do forgiveness and transparent apology function as practical and spiritual tools to rebuild intimacy?
What are the barriers in your own context to practicing “record-free” covenant-keeping, and how might couples cultivate an environment of grace and restoration?
Ritual, Memory, and Symbolic Practices
How do small, intentional practices (shared meals, anniversary reflections, devotional rituals) reinforce covenantal intimacy?
Explore the relationship between symbolic acts and emotional memory. How can couples adapt biblical ritual principles (berith, בְּרִית) to cultivate ongoing intimacy in their marriage today?
Bibliography
Brueggemann, Walter. Genesis: A Bible Commentary for Teaching and Preaching. Westminster John Knox Press, 2010.
Longman III, Tremper. Song of Solomon: An Introduction and Commentary. IVP Academic, 2001.
Fee, Gordon D., and Douglas Stuart. How to Read the Bible for All Its Worth. 5th ed., Zondervan, 2014.
Perrotta, Kevin, and Louise Perrotta. Oneness: Jesus’ Vision of Marriage. 2024.
Gregoire, Sheila, and Dr. Keith Gregoire. The Marriage You Want: Moving Beyond Stereotypes for a Relationship Built on Scripture, New Data, and Emotional Health. 2025.
Reynolds, Adrian, and Celia Reynolds. Closer: A Realistic Book About Intimacy for Christian Marriages. 2021.
Konzen, Dr. Jennifer. The Art of Intimate Marriage: A Christian Couple’s Guide to Sexual Intimacy. 2016.
Westermann, Claus. Genesis 12–36: A Commentary. Augsburg Fortress, 1985.
Packer, J. I. Knowing God. IVP, 1973. (for theological foundations of covenant love)
Recommended Reading
Kevin and Louise Perrotta, Oneness: Jesus’ Vision of Marriage. 2024.
Adrian Reynolds & Celia Reynolds, Closer: A Realistic Book About Intimacy for Christian Marriages. 2021.
Sheila & Dr. Keith Gregoire, The Marriage You Want. 2025.
Dr. Jennifer Konzen, The Art of Intimate Marriage. 2016.
Emerson Eggerichs, Love & Respect: The Love She Most Desires; The Respect He Desperately Needs. 2004.
Timothy Keller & Kathy Keller, The Meaning of Marriage: Facing the Complexities of Commitment with the Wisdom of God. 2011.